In December’s column, I offered an argument that staff in residential child care need containment in order to do therapeutically containing work with children and young people in their care. This work often causes anxiety, which gets in the way of clear seeing and thinking.
So in this month’s column I turn my focus to the provision of containing processes for practitioners. Ruch (2008) proposes a useful model for thinking about the way organisations can promote containing contexts, called holistic containment. This model helps to make sense of already existing conditions or practices. It also helps to identify missing or counterproductive practices, enabling us to better understand why we should strive to improve them and how we might go about it.
Holistic Containment
Holistic containment is comprised of three facets: emotional, organisational and epistemological. I like Ruch’s use of the word facet because it reminds me of a precious gem – each facet is simply a different face of that gem. The facets of holistic containment are similarly interrelated and when combined, make up the overall containment which provides optimal conditions for clear thinking, emotional availablilty and reflection on practice.
Emotional containment
Emotional containment can be thought of as feeling containment. It is about helping practitioners to manage emotions encountered in practice. On a basic level, emotional containment provides the necessary support to make the difficult times more bearable. However, emotional containment is also about helping to make unthinkable experiences or feelings think able, creating a space where it is safe to express them.
Practitioners often provide emotional containment for one another. Words of encouragement or gestures of support can have the immediate effect of making feel ings more manageable. Sometimes just the presence of a particular colleague can make the rest of the team feel a bit less anxious and a bit more capable (and, often, this in turn makes the kids feel a bit less anxious about the adults’ ability to hold it all together). In this case, that col league may indeed have a containing presence.
In Scotland, cups of tea serve a containing function. A cuppa is usually offered when a person has just been through a stressful event at work, both to encourage taking a break from the difficulty, and as a way of making a nurturing, supportive gesture without emphasising the person’s vulnerability. The cuppa is especially effective when the person know just how you like it.
Good supervision is emotionally containing, especially when it creates a safe space to identify and express feelings that are brought up in the work. When we experience good emotional containment, we are better able to listen to children and make ourselves emotionally available.
Some might resist the notion that we need emotional containment. Thinking about it might engender a feeling of inadequacy or unprofessionalism. I wonder if this also might provoke deeper fears about dependency, especially for those working in cultures where independence is highly prized. Ruch makes an interesting point, however, that emotionally containing contexts, ones that “enable practitioners to acknowledge their professional dependency needs” (p. 298), actually promote professional autonomy.
This is because emotional containment reduces the need to defend one’s own competence and professional survival, making space to focus on (and attune to) the needs of the child.
We know that, in children, dependence is necessary for healthy development and that secure dependence enables independent functioning (Maier, 1979). I wonder how often we think about, or allow ourselves to feel, our own dependency needs related to the work? In fact, when was the last time you heard those three words strung together – professional dependency needs?
Organisational containment
Organisational containment can be thought of as doing containment. It is essentially about organisational clarity. Expectations, procedures, rules and structures that are clear and serve the overall aims of the work help to contain anxiety. Perhaps it is easier to see the opposite. When there is a lack of clarity related to a new procedure, for example, or when a procedure is perceived as contrary to good practice, it raises anxiety and other uncomfortable feelings.
At social policy and organisational levels, the overriding focus seems to be on ever more rules, regulations and procedures to keep children safe and to improve practice. Ruch is emphatic in pointing out that this not only inadequate to meet the needs of practitioners, it can be counterproductive. Even when policies and procedures are clear and useful, without the other facets of containment, they are often used to avoid anxiety that it brought up in the work.
For example, sometimes it is easier to hide behind paperwork rather than facing the challenges out on the floor. Deferring to a rule rather than exercising our professional judgement can give a sense of certainty, even in the face of clearly poor practice. It provides us with a defence against the anxiety we would feel if we ventured into uncertain or contentious territory. Reducing our practice to techniques buffers us from the overwhelm and inadequacy we feel when we really embrace the complexity of a situation.
Following a procedure is less anxiety provoking than simply being present with a child who is in pain (and with our own pain that is triggered by this).
So while good levels of organisational containment are necessary as part of an overall holistically containing work environment, they must take their place alongside other facets of containment if they’re to be beneficial.
Epistemological containment
Epistemological containment, the final facet, can be thought of as thinking containment. Basic epistemological containment is about spaces or forums where practitioners can make sense of the more complex, contentious and uncertain areas of practice. It also is about recognising different forms of knowledge and how they can inform our practice more richly.
This facet of containment enables open-mindedness. It strengthens us
to resist the allure of jumping to conclusions or clinging to false
certainty. When we can tolerate uncertainty better, we notice
more
and have greater creativity in under standing and addressing issues.
Epistemological containment has much in common with meaning making.
In Garfat’s (1998) study of the effective Child and Youth Care
intervention, he asserts that, to a great extent, the process of
intervention is a process of meaning making. So much of the work is
about trying to understand how a kid is making sense of things, and then
helping him to find ways to make sense of those things in ways that will
serve him better. I have found that I am helped to do the same thing, at
the same time, through that process.
Attending to the processes of
meaning making, our own as well as others’, re quires openness and being
able to stay grounded in not knowing. Practitioners need forums in which
they can embrace and explore different sources of knowledge in order to
help them make sense of events or aspects of practice.
Amongst more reflective practitioners, these forums can arise informally, during that cuppa after the kids have gone to sleep, or with kids while ‘hanging out and hanging in’. These spontaneous occurrences of epistemological containment are much less likely, however, if there is not a deliberate and committed provision of such forums in a planned way. Common opportunities for more formal epistemological containment in residential child care include individual supervision, group supervision, meetings focused on one or more of the kids (sometimes referred to as case conferences or grand rounds), and external consultation. It has been my experience, however, that these forums are rarely used for the kinds of meaning making work that would constitute epistemological containment. As Ruch emphasised, we’re so busy doing that we often fail to attend to feeling and thinking.
The weekly staff meeting is a good ex ample of how, in one of the places I worked, we obscured feelings, meanings, and thinking about thinking with an eclipsing focus on doing. We had a set, required agenda that included things like menus, clothing and unit upkeep. Now you would think that we could touch on and tick off each of these more instrumental items rather quickly so that we could get to more substantial discussion – discussion that might actually provide a bit of emotional or even epistemological containment. Instead, we would get caught up in protracted and unsatisfying discussions that didn’t seem to help develop our practice – week after week. At the time, I hadn’t appreciated the power of anxiety.
That anxiety was doing two things: it was keeping us in the ‘safe’ territory of superficial issues, and it was interfering with our ability to see clearly what was going on and to do something differently. Does this sound familiar to any of you out there?
Relationship
The essential thread that ties these facets of containment is relationship. While the fabric and structure of a building, for example, contributes to (or detracts from) processes of containment, the main way feeling, doing and thinking containment is provided is through relationships. Even something as seemingly solid and static as a procedure (organisational containment) is significantly affected by how it is communicated and modelled, both of which are influenced by the relational context within which that communication and modelling takes place.
For the most part, it is within individual relationships and networks of relation ships that all three facets of containment take place. Holistic containment (the integration of all three facets) can often manifest through an individual and how she relates to her teammates. Unit man agers often bear the greatest demands (usually unconscious demands) for containment, particularly when simultaneously they’re involved in direct practice (working directly with the kids) and indirect practice (providing support, super vision and other management functions for the team).
Meeting the containment needs of unit managers warrants further attention and is key in providing containing contexts for practitioners, but, as ever, I’m running out of words and time. This will be the subject of a future column.
References
Garfat, T. (1998) ‘The effective Child and Youth Care intervention: a phenomenological inquiry’, Journal of Child and Youth Care 12(12), pp. 1178.
Maier, H. W. (1979) ‘The core of care: Essential ingredients for the development of children home and away from home’, Child Care Quarterly 8(3), pp. 161173.
Ruch, G. (2008) ‘Developing “containing contexts” for the promotion of effective work: The challenge for organisations’, In B. Luckock and M. Lefevre (eds), Direct Work: Social work with children and young people in care, London, British Association for Adoption and Fostering.