I have a season ticket to watch Hibs, one of Edinburgh’s two professional football (soccer) teams. It hasn’t been a good season so far for Hibs supporters.
Up until the past couple of weeks they had hardly won a game and were beginning to be thought of as candidates for relegation from the top division. They had problems in every area of the field but especially in front of goal. An opportunity that presented itself in a recent match was symptomatic of their plight. Our centre-forward was through on goal. Any centre-forward worth his salt in that situation would have driven forward forcefully and at very least got a shot on target. But our centre-forward attempted some fancy back flick to a colleague in a less promising position than he was and the move petered out.
Basically, he shirked responsibility. To be honest, I don’t blame him. In another time and place he might have burst the net. But he was bearing down on goal in a particular time and place; the team wasn’t playing well, he had hardly scored a goal all season and the fans were on his case. Had he gone for goal and hit Row Z then the clamour from the touchlines would have reached fever pitch. And of course, this feeds into a vicious circle that saps a player’s confidence still further and makes it less likely that he will do what a confident centre forward will do in such circumstances.
I’ve admitted before in this column to my propensity to use football as a way in to reflect on some of the deeper things in life. So, I found myself pondering what this little cameo might have to say about Child and Youth Care practice. I am increasingly coming round to the view that such practice is, at root, about taking responsibility. The sociologist, Zygmunt Bauman, draws on the Creation Story to pose the question, ‘Am I my Brother’s Keeper?’ The answer, he avers, is self-evident – of course I am; I become aware of my brother’s dependence and I need to reach out to him (or her). It is such a sense of moral purpose that brings us in to Child and Youth Care and which sustains us in it.
That sense of moral purpose can be sapped, though, in contexts that make it difficult for us to take responsibility. And many current contexts do just that and they do so under the banner of improvement, modernization or whatever, the buzzword of the day might be. Excessive regulation saps responsibility. When rules and regulations take precedence over moral purpose, Bauman advises, the first thing to go is the moral impulse that brought most people into care work in the first instance. The task becomes redefined towards following the rules and being ‘professional’. All too often, our view of what it is to be professional means being objective and detached, and failing to take responsibility.
Regimes of accountability that degenerate into noisy cultures of blame also dissipate the urge to reach out to the other. In Child and Youth Care, we are called to take responsibility in situations that are messy and ambiguous and where the outcome is uncertain. Our interventions might just as easily end up in Row Z as in the back of the net. And the Row Z scenario risks unleashing the self-righteous guardians of a ‘best practice’ that they rarely deign to model but are only too keen to judge others against. Like Hibs’ hapless centre forward it can feel easier in such contexts to engage in some fancy footwork and pass the buck to a colleague or, increasingly, in our brave new world of inter-agency working, to farm the problem out still further to the police or the health services or anywhere else that al- lows us to absolve ourselves from taking responsibility.
The upshot of all of this is practice cultures beset with what a recent article calls insidious leniencies, basically, a lack of moral purpose or sense of knowing what it was that we came into this game for in the first place. We can all be prey to a failure to take responsibility. For the past few months now I have been putting off getting in touch with a couple of young adults I looked after as youths. I rationalize my failure; I convince myself that they have others that can reach out to them. I question whether I am that important to them anyway – and maybe I’m not. But I still feel some sense of unfinished business, some sense of responsibility. This sense of angst is, I suspect, part and parcel of taking a moral stance – we are left with the gnawing feeling that we are not moral enough, that we have not taken sufficient responsibility in reaching out to the other. It is maybe when this sense of not having done enough leaves us or when we rationalize it behind notions of professional distance that we need to touch base with what it was we came into Child and Youth Care for.
On a more prosaic note, Hibs have turned something of a corner in recent weeks and have won their last three games. There is more of a spring in the step of the players – they look more confident and are beginning to take some responsibility for what they do on the park. I see signs, too, that residential child care workers in Scotland (and indeed elsewhere across the British Isles) are growing in confidence and are beginning to take responsibility for their own future through setting up new practitioner-led associations. Far better to take such responsibility than to wash one’s hands, to be indifferent, or to pass the buck. At the end of the day kids need adults around them who feel some sense of personal responsibility towards them.