Early pioneers in residential work with children and youth at Shotton Hall, Shrewsbury, UK, writing in 1968
Shared responsibility is often talked of as a method of running a school or institution; and since its very name has a positive ring, it has been identified with many kinds of set-up, from the prefectorial system of the English Public School to the experiments in school democracy of W. George, Homer Lane and David Wills. So it is most necessary to show what I mean by this term.
I look on a School or Children’s Home community as something which
does not exist in its own right, but is created as a powerful medium
through which to educate children for life and stimulate their
personality growth, and to take them away sometimes from undue stress.
In addition, except in day-schools, it has to provide certain
experiences or opportunities which the family would provide for children
who live at home all the time. The basic one is the experience of
belonging and identification; one may call this as basic even as the
experience of love, because it is the sense of belonging that carries
the child
through the many periods when his parents are not showing
him their love. There are many things that contribute to this sense of
belonging, and the Children’s Community should incorporate as many
as
possible of them into its way of life, or find substitutes for them.
One burden in bad times. The more parents value early attempts at sharing and helping, the more surely the foundations are laid for good attitudes later, especially to work and helping; forming individuals who creatively participate in their work instead of just carrying out orders.
How can we carry this attitude into the life of a Children’s Community, (for the sake of the children first, and also the community), and escape from the idea that work of any kind is a chore instead of a contribution? Perhaps it would be true to say that with children of infant and junior school age, it is most natural for them to offer their physical efforts for the common good. Older children, particularly those who have had negative experiences, are less likely to volunteer these freely; but they will usually offer their opinions on their surroundings and way of life.
This is the crucial point where shared responsibility can begin. In many places, open expression of such opinions is not encouraged. In other places they can be expressed, but because they are never allowed to have any effect, they soon become superficial and negative. But if opinions are not only allowed but asked for, even in serious matters (such as when a boy misbehaves outside the setting), the importance of finding the right solution will bring good sense and with it the feeling of commitment to the place. One effect of the children’s help is to reduce the individual’s paralysing sense of guilt. It is not necessary to this that all decisions must be put to democratic vote; the vital ingredients are a fair hearing of views and an honest discussion of them by everyone until there is some agreement on what is right to do. (One does not expect a family to make its plans on majority votes either, but still everyone’s views and likings have to be considered).
With this background it is only a very short step to a more active
participation in community responsibilities. Where the prefect system in
its simple form falls short is that it assumes there is a wide
divergence between what the adults want and what the children want; and
it then brings the oldest children over to the adult side with offers of
power and privilege. But if a community defines its aims clearly enough,
this divergence should disappear, and an understanding of the common
good emerge instead. This common good would be something to which
everyone would contribute according to
his own ability. For instance
if a group of children were in a shop together and one of them took
something without paying and showed the others they would tell him to
put it back because the act concerned them all, as a group with certain
responsibilities. The responsibilities of daily life, from getting one
another up in the morning to shutting up the house at night, would be as
much the child’s concern as the adult’s; they would not be delegated
from one to the other, but a chosen adult and la chosen boy each day
could do these tasks jointly, as suggested in the next section. Each of
them would carry the responsibility together. And this could be a
give-and-take relationship like the sharing of responsibility in a
family.
The adult would let the boy or girl take on what he could accomplish, always seeking to keep an element of challenge, but never letting the anxieties’ and demands grow too great to be borne. Children who cannot undertake this main task can still be given limited areas of responsibility; some of these are indicated in the chapters that follow. And if this attitude is extended through the place, so that the children arrange together such things as their cleaning duties, they may see even these as a responsibility shared with the adults who come in to clean. An atmosphere will be created in which older children will freely help younger ones not only with their tasks, but with the problems of growing older, mastering their moods of anger or gloom, and learning to identify with the adult world.
If shared responsibility is a flexible child-centred approach and not an almost constitutional system, it will be possible for the adults to allow a great deal of responsibility and freedom when the children can use it, and make their own influence and presence more felt before it becomes a burden, or the children involve themselves in a kind of ‘power politics’ which goes completely against the aims of this approach. It also allows those who are building up a new place to transfer their role gradually to the children as their confidence and capacities grow, until the point is reached where any newcomer can recognise and accept that there is a shared concern for the whole community. This remains an aim which will at times be nearly attained, while at other times the adults have to intervene directly at many points, and take a very obvious leading role. When this happens it should not be taken as a sign that “shared responsibility” does not work; it is simply a phase in the changing life of the community. The amount of challenge and freedom must always be related to the children’s capacities. There must be freedom to make mistakes, even in serious responsibilities, but not to the point where the community becomes insecure and panicky.
This feature from Lennhoff, F.G. and Lampen, J.C. (1968). Learning to Live: A Sketch-book for the Residential Worker with Children. Shrewsbury: Shotton Hall Publications.