I am currently learning, or re-learning, how incredibly difficult it is to follow through on the changes that know must make. And as always, observing my own experiences in seeking change inevitably pushes me to reflect on being with young people. It especially pushes me to reflect on the expectations I have held, and I supposed most of us hold, that young people make changes in order to move forward in as constructive and meaningful a manner as possible. On the one hand, such expectations, when thought of not as impositions on young people in terms of how to be, but rather as encouragement and expressions of believing in their capacity to be what they want to be, are necessary, and they should always aim high. On the other hand, this is one of those times when I realize just how much I rely on the generosity, encouragement, support and perhaps most importantly, forgiveness of others to keep trying. And then I wonder whether young people living under extraordinary circumstances, perhaps in residential care or on the streets, with mental health challenges or chronically replaying trauma, can rely on similar levels of support and forgiveness as they try to make whatever changes they deem necessary.
Here is the thing; after a total commitment to smoking cigarettes (a lot of them) for the better part of the past 28 years (I started very young), I am attempting to quit. Cold turkey. Just stop. My attempt started as a New Year’s Resolution, a practice that apparently has a failure rate of 99%, typically within the first day or so. Looking at it strictly from a dichotomous outcomes perspective, I am doing well. Today, as I am writing this (it’s Valentine’s Day), is Day 45. But it really wouldn’t do justice to the past 45 days to just look at whether or not I am smoking. To be fair, I also have to cite these developments:
In other words, I have been a joy to be around. I do try, for the record, to balance this by doing the task-oriented things that might be helpful at home (I cook, do laundry, wash dishes, buy groceries, pontificate about the quality of homework completion, etc.); at work, I focus my energy on being present for my students, offering lots of on-line support, face to face consultation time, research assistance and even participation in School social events. But my mind, clearly and categorically, is on one thing and one thing only: “please make it be tomorrow, so that it will be Day 46”. I have no idea how that is going to be helpful, but I figure when one tries to change a behavior that one has engaged in approximately 200,000 times over the past 28 years, it might take some time. I am desperately hoping for a gradual return to my version of normalcy roughly at Day 100.
So, what does this have to do with Child and Youth Care practice? Or with young people seeking change on their own terms? Well, I have so far been able to maintain course only because of this:
I have always prided myself in being critical but not dismissive, edgy but not angry, non-compliant but not contrarian for the sake of it. For the past little while, I have at times floated between the extremes of these dichotomies, but I have had the luxury of forgiveness on the part of those affected. Indeed, if I reflect on all of the responses of those listed above, they all have something in common; they reflect an authentic, non-judgmental, encouraging but not directive, kind but not unrealistic, acceptance of where I am at and where I would like to get to. And they express patience.
My quest to change something in my life feels all-consuming and barely possible, but I am so far coping only because of the generosity of my social context. I can only imagine what it might feel like for a young person in care, or faced with mental health challenges, or perhaps living on the streets to take aim at something about her or his life that s/he knows ought to change, but that is going to be hard as hell to do. And I wonder if there are very many young people out there who get the kind of unqualified and totally authentic response from their social context that I have had the privilege of receiving.