CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 148 JUNE 2011

Abuse and Historic Abuse in Residential Child Care: Some Thoughts about Certainty

Laura Steckley

I remember that brief conversation well. Okay, not the whole conversation, but the part where, I’ll call him Allen, came and spoke me while I was photocopying in the downstairs staff office. He was concerned because, I’ll call her Trisha, was beginning to see him as her boyfriend. Allen was worried about keeping that boundary without Trisha experiencing yet another adult rejection.

That’s really the part I remember most. I know we talked about how he might sensitively handle the situation, and I remember that the conversation was brief.

Allen was a trusted member of staff who, as far as I know, didn’t give anyone cause for serious concern. From memory, he had been working in our establishment for a couple of years and I do remember that it was his first time doing this kind of work. Allen sometimes struggled with what I perceived as a desire to take short cuts in developing trust with the kids, and he sometimes appeared to have role confusion related to friendship. Gosh, what new practitioner doesn’t struggle with these things?

When Trisha started telling staff that Allen was her boyfriend, no one believed her. We had, however, had regular reminders that if abuse was alleged, whether or not we believed it, we were to report it to our program director and she would contact the local child protection team. Whatever Trisha told the staff, they viewed it as alleged abuse, followed protocol and passed it along to our programme director.

Trisha wasn’t believed because she had a long history (with us and before us) of telling lies, sometimes outrageous lies. She also was sometimes sexually provocative with the male staff, and we believed both behaviours to be related to the numerous incidents of sexual abuse she experienced at the hands of her mother’s many boyfriends. We thought we were helping her to work through all of this.

So no one was particularly surprised when Trisha came out with her stories about how Allen was her boyfriend. Nonetheless, members of the child protection team were informed and started the investigation very shortly after Trisha’s disclosure.

Within a few days, Donna also came forward with similar information – that Allen was her boyfriend too. Apparently, Trisha had begun to speak to the other girls in the unit. This dramatically changed the impression everyone had about what was going on. Donna was a relatively ‘together’ kid, one who hadn’t (to our knowledge) lied to us before.

During the process of the investigation, Allen gave a detailed confession. Most of the details weren’t shared with us; we were told that he had been sexually involved with both girls for a period of weeks, but that he had not had intercourse with either of them. With involvement of the child protection team, Allen made a video that was shown to each girl; in it, he confessed, apologised and made clear that they were not to blame for anything related to everything that had happened and was happening.

The girls were spared from having to undergo further investigation and from having to testify in court. We were spared from the uncertainty as to whether he had committed the acts. Allen was sentenced to two years in prison.

I won’t go into how horrible it was to realise that one of our own had been abusing these girls, other than to say that it has stayed with me very vividly. I can’t help but be affected by it when I consider the current issues of historic abuse here in the UK.

There have been significant scandals of abuse in residential child care in Britain, much of them reaching back across many decades. These scandals have received high levels of media attention, and in the minds of many, historic abuse immediately comes to mind when people hear the term ‘residential child care’. The term ‘widespread abuse’ rolls off the tongue, but widespread related to what? To foster care? To kinship care? To care in families of origin? We don’t know the answer to this, and I suspect we never will.

Still, any abuse is too much abuse. And even the notion of abuse is complex and contentious. We live in a society where people regularly abuse each other, in all sorts of ways and in all sorts of settings. Sometimes this is clearly acknowledged as abuse and sometimes it is subtle and invisible. We have come through a century in which the concept of abuse and the notion that children are damaged by it was borne into our collective consciousness. Belting kids in mainstream schools was commonplace until relatively recently, not just for misbehaviour but for answering a question incorrectly. Seeing children as active agents who possess rights and help to shape their own life-paths is an even more recent way of thinking – one that still isn’t reflected in way that the adult world relates to kids. Added to this are the questions being raised about the process of investigating historic abuse, and while I don’t feel particularly on top of this subject, I do believe that that this issue – historic abuse of children and young people in residential child care – and the way it is addressed will significantly shape the future of our sector.

And, I think, the future is now. I suspect the influence of dominant discourses about historic abuse varies across different establishments, and there is likely even greater variation amongst individuals who care (or have cared) for children and young people.

I often reflect on how differently things might have unfolded back when I was working with Allen, Trisha and Donna. If Trisha had been the only child to come forward and if Allen had not confessed, we would not have had certainty. In fact, I wonder if colleagues would have instinctively reached for false certainty. When I mentioned above that Allen was a trusted member of staff, I should add that he was highly integrated into the social circles that often form amongst residential child care practitioners. He had been to the homes of several colleagues, and they had been to his. They had regularly spent time informally debriefing in the bar after work.

I also think about how this might have unfolded here in Scotland. In Colorado, residential child care/residential treatment wasn’t stigmatised; it was invisible. So while we still struggled with similar issues of poor professional regard, no required qualifications and poor resources, we didn’t feel distrust towards the systems of response to allegations of abuse. If Trisha, with her history and current functioning, had come forward in a Scottish unit or home, one that perhaps had a history of badly handled investigations in the past, I wonder what would have happened?

Clare Curtis-Thomas, former MP and chair of the all-party group on abuse investigations here in the UK, refers to cases of historic abuse as ‘conscious cases’. They are conscious cases because of the prejudicial nature of the offenses, and because of our collective concern [guilt] about children who have been in care homes for years without taking any action against people who perpetrated abuse against them. As a result, according to Curtis-Thomas, there is a predisposition by juries to believe evidence despite any objective counter arguments that there might be. In other words, people have a tendency to cling to certainty rather remain in the discomfort of uncertainty, especially when so much is on the line – in this case, the opportunity to deliver justice for a victim of abuse and to assuage our collective guilt and discomfort. More generally, a large portion of the population is quick to grasp at certainty about the guilt of the accused for the same reason; it is easier to drive that guilt into a handful of people rather than hold it collectively.

By the same token, the opposite can happen. There can be a desire for certainty about the innocence of someone accused, based on the dysfunction of the system, our belief in the positive potential of Child and Youth Care or our own personal experiences in practice. I’m not sure I would have felt certain about Allen’s innocence if the situation had unfolded differently, but I might have if I had been as close to him as some of my other colleagues were. And I suspect that some of them had been initially certain of his innocence and would have remained so if Donna hadn’t come forward and Allen hadn’t confessed.

For the past 15 or so years, I have felt quite certain that Allen was grooming me that day in the downstairs staff office. The conversations I had with the investigators reinforced this, and only recently have I opened to the possibility that he might have been reaching out for help. This opening of mind is really just a consequence of thinking more deeply about the relationship of certainty to how we react to these sorts of things. You see, I don’t remember how long before the investigation that he and I had had this conversation. It is possible that Allen was beginning to cross some lines with Trisha (or even just considering it) and maybe he was looking for a way back from this. It’s also possible that I, we, needed to construct various instances as grooming in order to distance ourselves from what had happened. We needed a clear and distinct line between him – the abuser, and us – the helpers. This natural instinct was further reinforced by a significant focus of the investigation, which was whether or not any of us had colluded with him. Conversely, the conversation with Allen could have indeed been a totally calculated event in order to protect himself should Trisha tell anybody. It could have even been some complex mix of the two. I’ll never know.

Until recently, I thought I had the luxury of certainty in all of this. And to some extent, I did. I have certainty that Allen did what he was accused of doing, and that what he did clearly constituted abuse. I also realise I indulged in some false certainties and simplified things in order to bear the horribleness of what had happened. All sorts of rules proliferated in order to bring about certainty that this would never happen again (e.g., male staff were never to be alone with female residents) and, looking back, I suspect we became less reflective about the ways we did or didn’t respect kids’ agency and rights. You see, we couldn’t tolerate seeing ourselves in even a similar light to that in which we came to see Allen. So where am I going with all of this?

I’m not certain, but I think it has to do with being strong enough and brave enough to tolerate the complexities and uncertainties related to this big, pressing issue of historic abuse in residential child care – to resist that strong, natural urge towards certainty. The current debate is naturally loaded with emotion and it seems to be creating divisions. Yet dialogue and debate serves an important function in forwarding our thinking and understanding. For this to be possible, we need to listen closely and openly, and speak frankly and candidly, WITH one another to find a way forward through this mess.

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App