Child and Youth Care Agencies that serve the needs of youth and families all have a similar goal, no matter what program or theory is utilized. Every agency attempts to create better functioning people and families, who can live more problem-free lives and see themselves as happy and capable.
There are several different jobs and roles within each agency. Front-line staff, Child and Youth Care practitioners or foster parents, interact 24/7 with youth and families, trying to create learning opportunities and challenges, safety and healthy boundaries, so that the people they serve will learn to stay safe and out of trouble, and will no longer suffer from abuse and neglect in their lives. They also try to begin the healing process so that the effects of past traumas will not create future problems.
Other professionals such as psychologists and psychiatrists, social workers, teachers, and medical staff work directly with the youth and families, as well as advising and supporting the front-line staff so that they can accomplish the goals listed above. Supervisory support for front-line staff is a key part of every agency’s approach.
There are financial and physical needs that are taken care of by administrative people, and community, public authority, and professional alliances that need to be maintained.
The executive director of the agency is responsible for the goals of the agency, so he/she must focus on overall functioning and practical results. He/she needs to support the staff to effectively accomplish each of the jobs assigned so that the agency is doing what is intended. Executive directors must create productive and well organized staff, so they can do what is needed for the youth and families.
In effect, the client of the executive director is the staff, not the youth and families. He/she must ensure that the staff are trained, supported and disciplined, as well as focused on what needs to happen. The job is to organize and manage people, not through mastering all of the differing expertise areas, but by creating support and direction.
CYC agencies deal with youth and families who have suffered both abuse and neglect, often for several generations.
These people are not easy to help, and many poorly prepared professionals are astounded by the response their ill-conceived ideas create. Most youth and families have been profoundly disappointed and hurt by well meaning, but ineffective helpers.
Here is the problem as I see it – Child and Youth Care agencies accept youth who have many behavioral issues, they abuse drugs/alcohol, refuse to attend school, are aggressive and self-centered, and do not respond to authority. We take these youth and create very powerful external control environments which result in immediate, almost magical transformations – the youth attends school, stops abusing substances, is not aggressive, and obeys the rules. This is accomplished through enormous effort by the front-line staff, who diligently enforce every rule and expectation through the imposition of punishment and reward systems that are only possible because of the environmental controls available.
Unfortunately, everyone focuses on this surface change and regularly measures and reports on small progress, weekly or monthly. No one seems to pay any notice to the fact that within a week after returning to the community, all the prior behaviors return and little long term change has occurred. The behavioral motivations present in the agency do not exist in the community.
The executive director has a key role to play in this poorly functioning system. Behavioral programs do not work to change the youth and families we serve. Yet many training programs, supervisors, allied professionals and “youth experts” promote behavioral strategies to front-line staff. There are many reasons for this, behavioral training is easy, quickly accomplished, and requires little expertise. Many professionals in their graduate training long ago learned behavior modification theory and still do not challenge it today. Developmental and relational approaches are more useful, and Child and Youth Care practitioners who are skilled in these approaches need to be hired as both supervisors and front-line workers.
Even if there is some suspicion of approaches that do not create immediate accountability and justice, I would hope that most executive directors would at least be willing to admit that behavioral approaches do not accomplish the necessary goals and might be willing to stop doing this even if the next step is unclear.