During my six-year-old daughter’s soccer games, I want to hurl myself in front of the ball and help the goalie make the save. Most of the time I manage to control this urge and simply stand vigilant beside the net, keeping company with whoever is fortunate enough to be in the pressure-soaked position at the time. Seeing the pain in their eyes when they let the ball slip by is agonizing. It is especially excruciating when it is my daughter’s turn. Watching her raw disappointment when she lets a goal in makes me physically ache inside. This is quite a change from last year when the girls were more interested in hugging each other and chasing bunny rabbits and butterflies on the field. This year, they know the score, and some of them shed tears when they lose.
Standing as sentinel with this team of girls, I’m pulled backwards in time and reminded of my past history in net, and all the trauma and isolation that comes with the solitary position. My introduction to playing goal was at the age of nine, on the ice rinks of Winnipeg. Because my dad was a goalie in ice hockey and because a print of Ken Danby’s “At the Crease” hung in our dining room, I felt qualified for the job. Playing goalkeeper also concealed my less than spectacular skating skills. We played ringette, because for some reason, as girls, we weren’t allowed to play hockey. In retrospect, I’m grateful that it was the soft, rubber ring being propelled towards my body and not the mean, hard puck. Mind you, I had enough goalie equipment on to stop a Zamboni. If our team had just piled up all the equipment in front of the net with out a body inside it, we probably would have stopped just as many goals. The position of goalie seemed a safe choice, except for the mind games. There was a lot of time for quiet contemplation, and I spent most of it ramping up my anxiety about what I’d do when the play inevitably made its way back down to my end of the ice. I bargained and prayed, pleading for just one (or ten) more goals for our team, to give us just enough of a lead to take the pressure off. Watching the electronic score board high above the rink, I attempted to speed time up by sheer force of will. The only effect this had was to actually slow the passing of the seconds down. Whenever my mom or dad or one of the other parents would come down to the end of the rink and keep me company in my exile, I was appreciative. It took the edge off of psyching myself out.
During my teens, I also spent a few years playing goal in soccer. One of the downfalls of my ringette training was that I tended to “deflect” the soccer ball (off my shins, torso, arms, whatever) rather than claim it. The ball would be sent back out to my opponents who would then gladly take another shot, this time from even closer range. Even with shin pads on, my legs were usually striking shades of yellow, purple and blue. The same little mind games returned, and, although I was always told that it was never truly the goalie’s fault, I still felt the familiar sting of failure when I let the ball slip through my fingers. That said, I returned game after game, looking for more of the same sadistic torture. The challenge of making the save and the allure of winning was an energizing incentive.
I don’t know if it’s maternal instinct or goalie empathy, but back on my daughter’s soccer pitch I simply can’t bear to let any of these girls stand alone in the net. I realize I want to protect these girls from more than just losing. I want to defend and shelter them, stop the ball from ever making it near them, stop any painful and hurtful moments they might have to experience. They are growing up and learning how rough and tough life can really be.
Self-doubt has yet to take them away from their true selves but it’s lurking on the horizon. But in soccer, if your defense covers you too well, you can’t see what’s coming and are in no position to protect yourself. You can’t stop the shot if you can’t see the ball. And if they don’t experience shots on goal, and risk being scored on, they’ll never know the pure exhilaration that comes with actually stopping one.
The surest way to make life hard for children is to make it too easy, and I need to give up trying to shield my daughter and these girls from failure. By sparing them the bad experiences, I also block out potential good ones and all kinds of learning opportunities. I can’t make their choices for them, and if I could, my track record is far from perfect; I might not be doing them any favours. Maybe that’s why I’m so apprehensive. I remember many mistakes and painful moments growing up. But in the end, I survived both losing games and growing up. And now, even though I don’t feel like an adult who has all the answers, I am in a remarkable place in my life. I never imagined myself as a wife and mother, and together with being, among other vocational identities, a daughter, granddaughter and sister, I’ve found a challenging and fulfilling (if precarious) balance in my life. Would I have found it and would I be as appreciative of it without all those missteps, mistakes, and goals, the ones I let in and the ones I saved?
I understand that eventually, I will be relegated to the sidelines of my daughter’s life, able only to watch the natural consequences unfold. And there she’ll be, completely beyond my control. In the end all I can do is stand beside her and offer words of encouragement and compassion. That will have to be comfort enough for us both.
Originally published in Relational Child and Relational Youth Care Practice Vol 20, Issue 1, Spring 2007, pg.45-46