Understanding and encouraging different learning perspectives can bring youth a step closer to success. The author details four outlooks on learning and life and provides strategies that can bridge the gap between teachers, youth workers, and today’s youth.
While standing in line recently at a fast-food restaurant, I noticed that the young man ahead of me was probably homeless. He was so young that he might have only recently been in school, perhaps in a 7th to 12th-grade alternative education class uch as the one I teach. The poignancy of the situation, combined with the fact that it was a slow line, made me wonder what causes some youth to remain hopeful in school or other constructive youth settings, and others to drop out, perhaps first from school, then from life.
I made this connection between school and life because, in thinking about that young man, it seemed likely that his report cards would not show a record of success. Although we may never know the correlation between success and failure in adolescence and later life, we cannot deny that there is one. So the question becomes: What can we do in schools and allied youth settings to extend success and to nurture and restore hopefulness for these youth? I believe one answer is to build a bridge of hope by understanding and responding to the four different perspectives on learning and life symbolized by four Ws.
The Four Ws
During my teaching tenure, I have had the opportunity to experience several classroom settings: ESL, gifted, adult, and alternative, I have also worked with social workers, counselors, preand post-incarceration juvenile justice officers, police officers on community and gang detail, clergy, career counselors, and many others who work every day to rebuild hope in our young people. This experience has shown me that, while the circumstances of each situation are unique, there are common elements. I believe that we can begin to learn from these similarities about who is and is not being reached. We can then start to understand how to build bridges in order to reach all of today’s youth. We must consider four distinct outlooks on life: What? Why/How? What If? and So What?
These four outlooks can be understood through the work of Garmston and Wellman (1992), who identify four sub-audiences within every larger adult group. These authors symbolically represent the members of each of the subgroups with an interrogative that expresses what they are most interested in knowing about a new subject: What? Why/How? What If? or So What? I suggest that these interrogatives represent major perspectives on teaching, learning, and life (Kennedy, 2000), and that this idea can extend to classrooms, a natural audience, and indeed any youth setting. Recognizing these four avenues of inquisitiveness is the first step in building a bridge that will allow all students to cross over from fear, anger, and frustration to hopefulness.
The Understanding Adult
All teachers and youth workers also have one of these outlooks on learning and life. The teacher who can transcend her or his own perspective and reframe to differing outlooks is granting students access to successful participation in curriculum, instruction, and assessment.
The youth worker who can go beyond his or her natural outlook is demonstrating the validity of other perspectives and is validating those youth whose perspectives are different from his or her own. To become capable of such reframing, each adult must first understand his or her own view.
The What? adult. Very traditional teachers often believe the classroom culture should be one of asking and answering What? questions about a subject (Figure 1). These teachers often see their responsibility to be accurately imparting what is factually known. That is, education is seen to be primarily about perennial truth. This is sometimes called the “Great Books” curriculum. In this conventional classroom, the teacher will most often use direct instruction to impart the central ideas that were true yesterday and will be true tomorrow. Traditional youth workers will often see things as they have always been. The ideal, illustrated by the past, may serve as their goal for youth.
The Why/How? adult. The teacher who sees the priority of education as asking and answering Why? and How? wishes for students to learn the basic skills that will help prepare them for the adult job market and other adult skills (Figure 1). The teacher directs the learning of these essentials, which converge on the basics of literacy, vocational preparation, responsible citizenship, and those forms of math and science that seek and then test for one variable at a time. Youth workers with this point of view are generally concerned for the vocational and financial future of youth.
The What If? adult. Invention or speculation about problems, as well as innovative solutions, are seen as the route to learning by the What If? teacher and service worker, a view that leads to divergent paths and results. The teacher who has this perspective will be less a director and more a facilitator (Figure 1). This teacher maintains that schooling is not preparation for later life but is intertwined with the student’s current life. To facilitate such learning, the teacher will often point students to tools such as the news, media segments, the Internet, and guest speakers to inspire What If! problem solving of societal challenges. Other youth workers will expand on these progressive themes as they seek to re-ignite hopefulness in youth.
Figure 1: Teacher and Student Outlooks
| Teacher expects to ask and answer about class content | |||
| What | Why/How | What If | So What |
| factual information is most important to teach and learn? | does the physical world work as it does? | students were encouraged to speculate on solutions to societal problems? | does this learning have to do with the individual student’s life? |
| Teacher believes role is to | |||
| Transmit | Direct | Facilitate | Co-Learn |
| perennial truths to students. | the learning of skills useful for adulthood. | student solving of self-selected current/ future) societal problems. | as students pursue issues in which they have a passionate interest. |
| Student is motivated to learn by asking | |||
| What | Why/How | What If | So What |
| are the facts of this subject? (as an academic) | do things work? (as a troubleshooter) | there were different possibilities? (as an innovator) | does this have to do with me? (as a collaborator) |
| Student’s most comfortable assessment mode is | |||
| Traditional | Deductive Inquiry | Open Inquiry | Inductive Inquiry |
| Conventional tests and quizzes, short essay. Test me on the facts presented. | Convergent tests, right/wrong answers, and techniques. Give me a hypothesis: I’ll test it. | Divergent assessment/ learning builds on student imagination. Give me an idea: I’ll make it better. | Student has input with teacher on what/how of assessment Choose assessment from my life. |
The So What? adult. So What? is a question that initially sounds surly and disrespectful but becomes legitimate with examination. This type of thinker is really asking, “How does this affect me and those I care about, today?” As Figure 1 shows, a teacher who sees his or her work from this outlook will most often view curriculum as emergent and instruction as a process of co-learning with students. The focus is on the individual’s personal, passionate encounter with learning. Those who work with youth beyond the classroom will be concerned with the quality of daily life for youth.
Engendering Hope by Helping Youth Achieve
We can also see in Figure 1 how the major classroom activities of learning and assessment, and how youth activities beyond the school, look to youths of differing perspectives. How effectively do students use their natural inquisitiveness to learn about and create assessment tools that will teach adults and other students things they may not see from their vantage points? In this era of accountability, high-stakes assessment is seen as the critical test for judging the effectiveness and degree of learning, and so weighs heavily on youth. If we can construct assessment in ways that nurture and even re-ignite hope for learners, this will act as a blueprint from which to build the bridge to hope using curriculum and instruction (Shoemaker & Lewin, 1993). This in turn will offer applications for non-school settings.
The What? youth. I have been most successful in curriculum planning and assessment with this group of academics by having them design traditional assessment items, such as quiz and test questions on the factual knowledge learned (Figure 1). Students are vested in the outcome by their outlook-they really believe in the importance of conventional assessment-and usually do a fine job. I can then take the best of their questions and use them to compose a whole-class quiz or test. I also give convergent assessment instruments to the divergent and emergent thinkers with the realization that this may not seem like basic knowledge, but higher-order thinking to those of other perspectives (Kennedy, 2000). Outside of school, these same youth will hold conventional expectations of themselves and others. The past mistakes of these youth-for example, becoming a teen parent or being incarcerated-will haunt them inordinately. Because these idealists can no longer take the traditional route to adulthood, they often feel as if they are beyond redemption. Those who work with these youth will want to help them overcome their focus on the past as well as their all-or-nothing approach to life. I often ask youth who are stuck, “What mistakes in your past would you change if you could? How many of those things can you change? Does this mean that your life is over? So what can you do?"
The Why/How? youth. I have had students from this perspective pursue “I-Searches” in which they asked questions such as, “Why does math have many branches?” (Kennedy, 1996). I generally help these troubleshooters design or refine the question and the process, leaving only one variable, which students can then investigate to gain the solution. We can see that in Figure 1 this is termed deductive inquiry. These students are also interested in the mechanics and functions of things around us. They can become very adept at making or explaining illustrations, diagrams, or 3-D models of things such as motors, planets and moons, a ship, an airplane, or a hydraulic lift. These students invariably raise questions about material perhaps touched on but not fully covered in class. Nurturing these students in their natural curiosity about Why and How things work gives them motivation and context for learning to work within other perspectives-a skill and range that will lead to further academic and life success.
After school hours, these youth, who are realists in outlook, will be interested in practical and mechanical things: the equipment of police and probation officers, how social workers and psychologists achieve results, how the laws that affect them work, the immediate career options/training that can be illuminated by career counselors. These students will want to know the most direct route to completing whatever education is necessary for opening up opportunities in their chosen career paths.
The What If? youth. “What if Pythagoras, Euclid, Archimedes, Heron, or Hypatia came to our classroom?” This is the type of question a What If! learner would like to hear at the end of a learning unit that covered these mathematicians. Picture one student innovator beginning a reply, standing as she gathers steam: “Oh, you mean what if Archimedes walked into our room right now and started to talk about leverage ... and we showed him our modem hydraulics ...” I have witnessed such impromptu responses from What If! learners on many occasions. These imaginary scenarios can easily go on for a full 5 minutes-laced with facts and concepts that the student has learned. Such beginnings form the foundation for asking what it is that historical figures and epochs, as well as the inventions they have produced, might tell us about the challenges facing us as a community today. Assessment of such learning must be a very open type of inquiry (Figure 1) in which the teacher poses the initial question, and then student imagination takes over. The results will diverge from traditional expectations but will be interesting and worthwhile.
Outside the classroom, these inventive youth will be interested in justice, exploring and finding new paths and patterns, and experimenting with new and innovative ideas. These futurists appreciate those adults who do not respond to their unique suggestions or thoughts with idealism or excessive realism, but rather compliment their ability to generate new ideas. In group brainstorming sessions, these youth, who are among the most in need of special help in America, are irreplaceable. On controversial social questions, they often take the position of “live and let live.”
The So What? youth. This group disdains traditional written schoolwork, but loves to build, draw, and perform. In fact, many have gotten into trouble for doing these things during class time. However, if the So What? question of personal relevancy is answered, these collaborators are given a meaningful reason for learning traditional facts and essential skills (Figure 1). They can then often master much of the same information included in the written work from other perspectives (especially if cooperatively grouped with those of differing outlooks), although their products may be constructed in nontraditional ways. For example, often these students complete and organize work from the back to the front, which can be unnerving at first for the traditional teacher. However, this is merely a corollary to their seeking the relevance of learning that includes a need to see the big picture.
Without this personal relevancy, these students often have a more difficult time succeeding in a system that will measure them largely in terms of more traditional factual knowledge and practical skills. (This is especially true under the current trend toward standardized assessment.)
Both inside and outside the classroom, these youth are concerned with the significance of lessons and events for their lives today. To reach these youth, we adults – especially traditionalists in outlook or training-will need to learn to begin with personal experiences, and only then make the transition to business. People must come before tasks. The youth worker or educator who has a traditional concept of what it means to be “professional” with youth (i.e., distant and removed) will reach these youth only by unbending, perhaps to the point of sharing something personal first in order to demonstrate a willingness to appreciate and recognize the youth’s outlook.
To bring this discussion full circle, we might contrast this strategy of effectively working with collegial/collaborative youth with how this personal strategy might play with traditional youth. The latter will see such an approach as a waste of time and may lose respect for the adult using it. If adults first understand and then familiarize themselves with the four outlooks, giving up the one-size-fits-all model once and for all, we are on the way to reaching today’s youth.
Adult Versus Youth Perspectives: When Hope Is Dashed
What if a teacher or youth worker cannot or will not admit that different youth perspectives are real and legitimate? Educators have often missed seeing how such a mismatch between many students’ points of view and that of their teacher can create misunderstandings, lead to frustration, and increase student risk of failure. Unless teacher and student outlooks can be expanded to include and validate different perspectives, student hope will be dashed and teacher frustration exponentially increased. The same holds true beyond the classroom.
To understand the concept of mismatches, take a moment to reflect on your own experiences. As you have read this article and looked at Figure I, you probably identified most strongly with one or possibly two of the four perspectives. Equally as likely, you shuddered at the thought of one or more of the others, perhaps thinking, How could anyone really believe that? Now imagine being present at a staff meeting, in-service training session, conference, or university class where the boss or pundit was of the point of view that makes you shudder. Try to recall some of the specifics that made you feel angry, tired, or misunderstood. Now think what it might be like for youth in the same situation, because for some, we are that boss.
By way of illustration, consider this scenario. A new teacher, highly successful in the Great Books curriculum of a large university, meets her new class on the first day of school. She looks out and, from her perspective, sees all those students whom she imagines are eager to learn the factual What? she has been so successful in acquiring. However, what she does not see from her outlook is that in the back sit So What? Johnny and his followers, whose hope may have been dashed in the past during year-long battles with traditional teachers. What follows can be one of two things: a year of frustration for the teacher and for Johnny-and of course, poor assessment results for him-or just possibly, Johnny’s renewal of hopefulness for success in school and life. The latter would occur if the teacher were willing to take the risk of allowing that a very different point of view may have legitimacy.
For a second illustration, imagine a youth counselor (or a social worker, probation officer, or church youth worker-all of whom serve as counselors at times) who believes that an adolescent whom he is counseling should go to college. The youth is certainly bright enough and would make an excellent professional. The youth herself, however, has a very pragmatic mind-set. She wants to attend a trade school and begin her career as soon as possible. If this counselor does not reframe his idealistic perspective to her realistic outlook, he will risk alienating this youth and perhaps jeopardize her future altogether. The direction such a situation will take is influenced by the ability to reframe (Bolman & Deal, 1994), or see the situation from another’s perspective.
However, this is more than just momentarily switching from one point of view to another. I prefer to think of reframing as developing an enlarged perspective that allows for the reality and legitimacy of all four points of view and a change in the entire culture of youth work, from exclusivity to inclusivity.
Building a Bridge to Hope for All Students
One further concept is necessary in understanding how to build the bridge to hope for all students in our institutions and practices. We have heard repeatedly in the 1990s about a paradigm shift in education: that we needed it, that we were in it, or that it was coming. Everyone now knows this concept is an application of Thomas Kuhn’s classic, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions (1970). What may not be so apparent is that in education-and probably society as a whole-we seem to confuse “paradigm shift” with “pendulum swing.” That is, our understanding implies replacing the old with the new, which means both starting over and discarding everything learned from, and even good about, the old. This shift has made most educational reform efforts into either-or propositions (Dewey, 1938). Whether or not this is a correct perception of Kuhn’s idea, I submit that it is our reality in education (and probably many other fields, from youth work to politics and religion). This leaves us forever chasing “the new” and denying the value of the experiences that brought us here. Thomas Oden (1992) calls this phenomenon “modern chauvinism.” The shallowness of such a methodology for thinking about and constructing models of reform, which give hope to all points of view, must become obvious.
Instead of continuing with the metaphor of “paradigm,” I would like to propose thinking of youth work as a syntagm, with a specific application borrowed from Dorothy Sayers (1941). In her classic work, Sayers speaks of an arch. In the present instance, we might adapt that to a specific type of arch-a bridge. While the shift implies exclusion (a moving from and to), a bridge is “sustained by the tension of the two-a construction of something not there before” (p. 191). The bridge is inclusive, needing both to exist: “The good that emerges from a conflict of values cannot arise from the total condemnation or destruction of one set of values, but only from the building of a new value, sustained, like an arch, by the tension of the original two” (p. 191).
Only upon solid pylons can we success – fully build such a bridge to hope in the classroom or other youth settings. In this case, those pylons are the healthy participation, access, and understanding of all four youth perspectives. The strong, understanding adult role model serves to connect the pylons and so allows the bridge to be constructed by the joint efforts of both the adult and youth (Kennedy, 1999).
Crossing the Bridge to Hope
As the young man ahead of me in the fast-food line placed his meager order and carefully spilled out some change, I wondered which of the four perspectives he had. Would his life be different today if more adults had understood his outlook? There are countless examples of youth who have altered their course after being allowed to follow their natural perspective. Consider this scenario of the process in action: A student arrived in one county school’s class after being expelled from the district and even all the other county classes. This was her last chance. What had she done to be treated so harshly? She had done nothing violent. She had not hurt anyone. She had not brought a weapon to school. She was not involved with gangs. She had never made a bomb threat or even joked about it. She was expelled because she had dared to participate in her own learning by asking What If? of her teachers. She did not understand why this brought about such strong reactions. In her view, this was the natural route to learning. She thought that she was contributing to the class, while traditional teachers, counselors, and administrators saw her as challenging their authority. They thought she was interrupting the pattern of teacher talk, handouts, and textbooks. They also viewed her questioning of governmental authority and practices as leaning toward anarchy instead of a natural part of her learning process.
This student arrived at the “last stop” battered by and wary of educators. The teacher in this class, however, recognized this student as a budding innovator and saw her desire to discover different possibilities as a gift instead of a threat to tradition and authority. The student began to respond. She eventually became a class leader in peer counseling, tutoring younger children, and academic excellence.
She graduated from high school a year early and quite ably worked with a very traditional teacher to prepare for her college entrance exams. She is now in college preparing to become an educator herself. If every educator and youth worker were willing to reframe to see the adult-youth interplay from all four perspectives-turning them into four pylons upon which to build the bridge to hope-the waves of youth crossing the bridge from fear, anger, and frustration to hopefulness would be stunning.
References
Bolman, L., & Deal, T. (1994). Becoming a teacher leader: From isolation to collaboration Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press
Dewey, J (1938). Experience and education. New York: Macmillan.
Garmston, R., & Wellman, B. (1992). How to make presentations that teach and transform. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision of Curriculum Development.
Kennedy, M. (1996). A teacher’s manifesto: Designing learning which cures rather than causes academic risk: Parts 1 & 2. The Journal of At-Risk Issues, 2(2),3-27.
Kennedy, M. (1999). Elephants and adolescents. The Journal of Court, Community. and Alternative Schools, Spring, 13-15.
Kennedy, M. (2000). Lessons from the hawk. Brandon, VT: Holistic Education Press. Kuhn, T. (1970). The structure of scientific revolutions (2nd ed.). Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Oden, T. (1992). Two worlds: Notes on the death of modernity in America and Russia. Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press.
Sayers, D. (1941). The mind of the maker. San Francisco: HarperCollins.
Shoemaker, B., & Lewin, L. (1993). Curriculum and assessment: Two sides of the same coin. Educational Leadership, 51(5),22-23.
From: Reaching Today’s Youth, Vol.4 Issue 4, pp51-55. Portions of this article were adapted from the author’s book, Lessons from the Hawk (2000) with permission of the publisher, Holistic Education Press, Brandon, VT 057033.