CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 304 JUNE 2024

Cyborg Relations in the 21st Century

Hans Skott-Myhre

The world has changed and is changing in very real and fundamental ways as we have moved from the late 20th century into the 21st. I know I have been hammering away at that point repeatedly, perhaps to the point of annoyance in much of my writing here. But I think it is a point that needs to be made, if only because the scope of the change we are undergoing is so immense. The world as we have known it, for anyone over 20 years old, is becoming socially and culturally alien. The tricky bit about this is that the change is taking place in such a way as to normalize the shifts so that everything seems to be recognizable. There are still families, communities, schools, churches, governments, shops, homes, students, workers, jobs, banks and so on. And for the most part we still feel as though these social structures are places where we function as social citizens. In fact, we rely on many, if not all of them, for our bearings as we maneuver though our lives.

Our identities are caught up in these social forms in the way that we take on roles as parents, children, brothers, sisters, employees, supervisors, church members, members of a neighborhood or community. In fact, for some of us these identifiers are a crucial part of how we know ourselves. At the same time, though, many of us are beginning to feel as though the social ground on which we stand is not as reliable as we had hoped. For an increasing number of us, we feel as though our social coordinates are melting away and the ground on which we base our social identity is more like quicksand that bedrock.

175 years ago, Karl Marx, writing in the Communist Manifesto, noted that capitalism has the remarkable quality of destroying existing systems of social and political organization. He noted that the focus on profit as an abstract system of value erodes the living material reality of social relations. As capitalism spreads, the social world becomes ever more abstract and less connected to the world of lived human relations. Nearly 125 years later post-Marxist scholar Michael Hardt wrote an article he called “The Withering of Civil Society.” In that piece he argued that much of what was constructed as civil society engendered by the European Enlightenment, was being emptied of its social force by the emerging world of virtual capitalism at the end of the 20th century.

Hardt proposed that the social functions of government, churches, schools, families, and other organizational structures of civil society were losing their primary function; that of producing a society that serves the needs of its members. Instead, these social institutions were shifting the task of society into giving primacy to the task of making money.

So, the task of social institutions such as schools, for example, shifts from producing a well-educated citizenry, to the task of producing good workers and consumers for capitalist corporations. In a recent article in the New York Times about Ivy League Universities, it was reported that students were increasingly interested in earning degrees that would make them large amounts of money, simply for the sake of becoming wealthy. The article notes that Ivy League universities have always produced a student body that generally went on to become wealthy, but that the current trend goes beyond that. The authors note that to “sell out” was no longer considered an insult, but instead a mark of ambition and success. Making lots of money took precedence over improving the world, living one’s dreams, or caring for each other.

This trend towards turning all social institutions towards the task of producing ever increasing profits in the form of the money sign means that money as a value increasingly displaces human care and compassion as key features of our society. And while this is disturbing in and of itself, the indirect consequences are even more disturbing still. Of course, we can see the direct effect in the ways that our social institutions are deteriorating through financial neglect or sheer appropriation. However, beyond the obvious decline in the quality of care delivered at all levels of society, there is another possibly less obvious effect of the rise of 21st century global capitalism and that is how we are being shaped emotionally, psychologically, and physically.

Theorists from Marx to Foucault have argued that who we are and who we might become is tied to the ways in which society produces itself and what that society values. From the moment we are born, there are a myriad of social diagrams for identity that begin shape the parameters of who we imagine we can be. These include prescriptive parameters of key social indicators such as gender or race, where we are inducted into descriptors driven by the historical residue of history as it erupts into the present over and over again. Or the demands of family structures that set the descriptors for us as mothers, brothers, sisters, fathers and so on. Of course, there are so many of these social molds that it would be impossible to delineate them all; child, parent, student, worker, consumer, homeowner, adolescent, friend, lover, wife, husband, partner, artist, professional, the list goes on. And for many, if not most of us, the entry into these mappings of who we are or might become feels natural, almost seamless. There is a sense of normalcy in being shaped into these roles through an extensive network of acts and gestures both large and small. Of course, we think to ourselves, we are someone’s sibling, parent, spouse, or employee with all the expectations of performance that comes with that role.

Within the frameworks of this extensive and complicated social mapping there are major and minor variations. The broad parameters of these roles are set by the dominant culture of any given historical period. In our time, the major reference points lead back to the colonial shaping of social institutions and the residual structures of industrial capitalism. However, within this dominant overlay of European colonial structures there are an almost infinite number of variations that have either refused the colonial diagram or have created hybrid forms of indigenous social structures and colonial mappings. That said, to one degree or another all these alternative forms of structures and roles are referenced against the dominant mapping of our times and to some degree found to be less optimal, less acceptable, and at times even simply alien and exotic. For all of their force, there is a crisis in all these social mappings. In significant ways, the substance of what each of these roles was to provide is slipping and opening a kind of uncertainty as to who we are supposed to be and what we are supposed to do.

On the positive end of this we have far more opportunity to discover and assert new social roles that can create new forms of gender, family, employment, education, sexuality, race, and government. On the more problematic aspect, these shifts open reactionary formations that try ever more brutally to enforce the old order no matter what it takes. But these attempts to force our practices and performances of our selves will inevitably fail because it is the nature of time to move on and if it returns it is never to the same place.

The uncertainty of all of these developments, both positive and negative also begins to form a significant aspect of who we are as subjects of the 21st century. We are unstable subjects who, in large degree are liminal. In other words, we are subjects living in what Anzaldua called the borderland; a space of indeterminacy. It is important to remember that such spaces are anything but neutral. Borderlands are immensely productive, made up of all the swirling elements of ontological possibility that make up historical moments of transition. We are not who we have been, and, in many respects, we are not anyone yet.

I have to wonder whether we have adequately accounted for this indeterminacy in the ways that we think about and practice our work with young people. Do we assume that both the young people and ourselves are essentially the same kinds of human beings we have always been? When we encounter the children of the 21st century are we continuing to map them onto developmental and relational diagrams of the last century? In our work are we prone to see the bodies of young people as simply human? Or are we beginning to account for the ways in which bodies are being reconfigured in our world today.

I would argue that there are many reasons we might want to rethink our 20th century diagrams of the human body in our work with young people born into the world of fully virtual capitalism. The developmental trajectory of our bodies is being altered by hormones and chemicals in our food and water supplies, our psychological and emotional lives are being greatly impacted by both the velocity, intensity, and uncertainty of life in the 21st century, our neurology is being reconfigured by our encounters with the machines that more and more encompass significant amounts of time.

While I think shifts in our physiology, psychology, and emotions might at least seem familiar, the fact that we have become cyborgs may be less so. As theorists such as Donna Haraway have suggested we are no longer humans using machines, so much as a human/machine form of subjectivity in which it becomes almost impossible to disentangle where the machine ends and human begins. Marx writing in the middle of the 19th century, predicted a time when there would be a development in capitalist production that will create a web of machinery spread across the planet in a vast network of machinic communication within which humans would serve the role of points of conscious links between different elements of the machine. I am not at all sure he wasn’t predicting specifically our historical moment. We are indeed linked as conscious elements in world wide web upon which we are no longer simply dependent but codependent. We might even say that our relation is co-evolutionary. That is to say that our relation to our phones, computers, algorithms, screens, and keypads is impacting dramatically on the very nature of what it means to be human.

So far as I can see, we haven’t really taken this on in any significant way within our work with young people. To the degree we have even acknowledged the ways in which our children have become cyborgs, the discourse has been one of various levels of denial and confusion. We worry about phones, streaming platforms, and social media in the way we used to worry about different subcultures and countercultures and their ostensible disastrous effects on young people’s lives. Such concern was both ineffectual and largely misplaced in the past and I would argue that moral panic about the inevitable rise of cyborg generations is not only misplaced, but irrelevant. As a society, we will be ever more cyborg as long as we have the capacity to create and be created by cyber space.

From my perspective a more useful approach would begin with an acceptance of what is happening to us as coevolutionary components of a new form of cyborg consciousness. We need to start asking questions like, what does relational work look like if we are working with young people as cyborgs? Does communication look different? Do our programs need to change to accommodate more virtual activity? What kinds of self-reflection is necessary for workers to overcome their biases about an emerging world that may seem quite unfamiliar and alien? How do we resist the temptation for nostalgia about the world that is passing? What elements of being human are worth amplifying in our relationship with the machinery of global capitalism? How can we seize back this new form of social relations from the predations of capitalist production? Should we?

This is all uncharted territory, and I am certainly not of an age or position to do more than suggest possibilities. I have no idea if these are the questions we should be asking or if there is a while other set that can or will emerge from those who are born of this age. However, I do believe that asking questions as to how proceed by meeting young people where they are at is vastly preferable to wringing our hands and cursing the way the world has changed. The world is indeed changing, and I hope we as a field can keep up. The future is now if we can hold the faith necessary to engage it. That is the task if we are up to it. 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App