The development of Level 2 practitioners involves a dramatic shift in how personal attractiveness is stressed by the more mature practitioner. During the first years of practice, there is a common-sense awareness that being liked by young people and families is an asset and practitioners evaluate their effectiveness by how much they are liked and needed by the young people and families being served. I have described the temporary usefulness of this approach in previous columns.
Level 2 practice, the Treatment Planner and Change Agent (Phelan, 2017), involves a major shift in thinking about how being liked as a role model is not a very effective strategy. The emergence of this contradictory idea about self grows as a Threshold Concept (Steckley, 2020) and dramatically alters the practitioner’s thinking about how to interact with others. Basically, the more mature practitioner realizes that being liked by young people and families is only temporarily helpful, these people really need to like and value themselves to change. Additionally, the practitioner realizes that he/she has wasted enormous energy and developed elaborate strategies that do not create this result.
Threshold Concepts are troublesome, according to Steckley, so supervisors can be very useful is supporting this shift in thinking. Developing into a Level 2 practitioner requires the worker to re-evaluate comfortable methods and ways of thinking that have served him/her well, but once this journey has begun it will be very satisfying, because the new picture of how to create effective CYC relationships will be more sensible and reinforcing. The response from young people and families to a more professionally competent and aware helper will be dramatically different from the compliant results previously sought.
To illustrate some practical examples, Level 1 practitioners use reinforcement like praise to create external control, so when a young person attends school regularly, he might say “I am very proud of you …”, which is seen as a positive reward, while the Level 2 practitioner might say “ You have been attending regularly, how are you able to do that?” which focusses the young person on himself, not the worker. This simple shift in approach may not even be noticed by others but it will be powerful for the young person. Parents in family work may get messages from Level 1 workers based on treat your children like I am suggesting, when Level 2 workers will look for moments of nurturing by the parent and highlight the parent’s skill.
These are simple examples, but over time the developing Level 2 practitioner uses less external control, becomes a less important presence, focusses people on themselves and their strengths rather than how useful his/her interventions are, and realizes that being not needed is the goal.
The journey to create this “self” as a CYC practitioner involves being more self-reliant, not looking outside oneself for approval and validation, because this is what needs to be created by the young people and parents. Modlin (2013) describes this shift as self-authoring thinking, which is a necessary process for professional practice. CYC supervisors also must be self-authoring to be effective.
The process of re-focusing one’s efforts on the way young people and families see themselves rather than how they see you will expand the empathic awareness of the practitioner. This new view of the other person can result in seeing more strengths and survival skills being used, rather than uncooperative resistance to change. As the more mature Level 2 practitioner lets go of his/her own self-awareness, he/she is more open to seeing the other person’s needs and life logic.
Rethinking how your “self” influences what you believe and observe is not an easy process and will take time to evolve. CYC supervisors can be a powerful influence in this shift, but they must have also experienced this change of self to support their workers. As this new, less intrusive “self” interacts with others, relational practice can be possible. When effective relational CYC practice occurs, the practitioner must not be focused on personal likeability.
More on the development of “self” as a CYC practitioner next month.
Modlin, H. (2013). Meaning making: Another perspective. Relational CYC Practice, 26 (3), Fall 2013.
Phelan, J. (2017). Intentional CYC supervision a developmental approach, Cape Town, SA: CYC-Net Press.
Steckley, L. (2020). Threshold concepts in residential child care: Part 2, Relational practice as threshold. Child and Youth Services Review, 112 (2020).