In her M.A. thesis and subsequent publication, Elisabeth Tilstra (2019, 2022) analyzed how outdoor adventure programs (OAE) interpret gender while organizing “risk processes and practices.” Outdoor adventure programs are typically tripping programs in the wilderness, and exposure to “perceived risk” is one of the dynamic mechanisms that they hope leads to personal growth, along with group dynamics, decision-making opportunities, and incremental accumulation of skills. Tilstra’s work is an outstanding example of how a small sample of seemingly ordinary data can, with skillful and expert analysis, lead to interesting theories.
The initial question was: How is risk gendered in youth outdoor adventure programs? Tilstra began by looking at 11 packing lists—the ordinary lists of items participants should bring, and she,
… analyzed the OAE packing lists … attentive to language that categorized gender, mandated rules based on gender, or made distinctions between “gendered objects” as sources and sites of regulation. We defined “gendered items” as items that are ostensibly used by one sex such as hygiene products for menstruation and sports bras. Items not considered gendered are those that have the same name, function, and/or purpose, regardless of the gender of the user such as t-shirt, pants, socks, etc. Gender “neutral” terms such as “underwear” versus boxers, panties, etc. are notable choices of wording.
She was asking, “Is this item gendered, and why?” She also examined the order and placement of items. For example, packing lists were divided into categories such as “required” or “optional” or “For Girls” — considered additional items rather than centrally important items. Intentionally or not, this places items for boys as central to the program and girls’ items as additional or deviant.
Sports bras were listed at the end rather than with underwear. Menstruation products were usually not listed or listed as additional — odd choices for something that is a necessity. Rather than letting the user identify which items are needed, there is an assumption that lists need to be labelled by gender, as if participants cannot figure out which items apply to them. In so doing they implicitly identify who is considered normal.
Tilstra also interviewed program managers and trip leaders. They reported that boys are physically risky while girls are emotionally risky, with physical risks understood as events that happen to participants, while emotional risks are actively pursued, e.g., being vulnerable. These too are gendered in the usual ways, and this creates problems and prevents solutions. Taking emotional risks is seen as healthy, characteristic of girls, while physical risks are seen are consequences of boys’ impulsiveness. Yet understanding these so narrowly prevents clear thinking about how to manage and mitigate risk; climbing a rock wall can be an existential threat — not just a physical risk — and the emotional dynamics of a group have consequences for how one experiences that existential threat. It also prevents program managers from accurately perceiving the range of individual responses that are possible and that overlap genders considerably. It hinders proper risk management preparation and situational risk management responses.
From a few packing lists and interviews, Tilstra has simply but brilliantly illustrated that our continued confusions about gender and sex have consequences for program management, for effective outdoor trip leadership, and for participant experience. We both over-interpret and under-interpret the meaningfulness of gender. Rather than letting categories of gender emerge in experience, we impose gender categories even on simple lists of items to prepare. This is a signal that our practices of gender may be similarly confused in other circumstances of daily life as well.
References
Tilstra, E. (2019). Mature girls, squirrelly boys, and “wily” risk: gendered risk in outdoor adventure education. Masters thesis, University of Victoria. Available from: http://hdl.handle.net/1828/10466
Tilstra, E., Magnuson, D., Harper, N., & Lepp, A. (2022). Gender and risk in outdoor adventure education. Journal of Outdoor and Environmental Education. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1007/s42322-022-00098-x