CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 280 JUNE 2022

Relational Care and Mental Health

Hans Skott-Myhre

In Memorium
George Bjore
12/12/1985 to 5/11/2022 

In his column last month, Kiaras Gharabaghi took on the sacred cow of what has become known as mental health. For those of you who read this column with some regularity, you know this is a topic of considerable concern to me as well, so I am deeply appreciative of having an ally on this issue.

In his column, Kiaras asks us to think deeply about whether we actually have a mental health crisis rooted in the bio-medical sense of diagnosis and medical intervention, or whether what we are witnessing is a breakdown of social support networks. He wonders if what we are seeing in the pandemic of anxiety and depression is a very reasonable response to a deteriorating society that may well be toxic to young people’s well-being. In this, he is echoing anti-psychiatrists such as R.D. Laing who made the argument in the 1960’s that madness is actually a reasonable response to living in an insane society. Laing argued that those who appear to adapt well are the ones who are truly mad and in need of intervention. But the intervention Laing was proposing for the truly mad minions of global capitalist society was not psychiatric diagnosis and pharmacology. Instead, he advocated for a return to life itself as fully lived in community with others as an antidote to alienation and despair.

Some 50 years later, the voices that advocate for the kind of healing that can be found in living relationships of care remain marginal. Instead, we continue to advocate at every level for the idea that mental health can be found in varieties of psychiatric and psychological intervention designed to adapt us to living more successfully with our despair and alienation. In this, it is not surprising that the drugs we are prescribed do little other than numb the pain so we can go on. They mute the messages being sent to us by our unconscious that tell us that something is desperately wrong.

However, there seems to be a shift occurring in how we think about mental health. Recently, there have been several challenges to the mainstream approaches to ways in which we think about psychological, emotional and neurological difference and suffering. Of course, over the past fifty years there have been many challenges to the dominant medical model approach including the work of critical psychologists, humanistic psychologists, and feminists working in social, psychology, and education, patient rights advocates, LGBTQ+ activists, advocates working in the areas of health disparity, and those who have identified as psychiatric survivors. These voices have been raised powerfully for decades now, pointing out the ways in which mainstream psychology and psychiatry has failed to be helpful in remediating the suffering of women, people of color, the LGBTQ+ community, and those identified as neurologically different.

More recently however, there are voices coming from within the mainstream itself that are beginning to question both the effectiveness of the medical model approach, but also its foundational assumptions. I have written in previous columns about the critiques of the framework of diagnostic criteria put forward in the DSM from within the international psychological and psychiatric communities. These critiques have questioned whether or not there is any real science behind the diagnoses so commonly used to categorize human suffering in ways that are almost mandatory. These systems of diagnosis are deeply entwined with the administration of medications that have also recently come under fire from a number of sectors as not showing longitudinal effectiveness and having extremely problematic side effects including addiction.

Recently there has also been a broad study of the technologies used to make claims about neurological mappings if the brain. This study indicated that the research that has been used  to indicate neurological abnormality associated with diagnostic categories such as depression, bi-polar, schizophrenia and so on, have not used a large enough number of scans to make the kinds of claims that have been asserted. There have been similar critiques of the “science” behind genetic links that have been associated with diagnostic categories. The field of genetics has not been able to find adequate direct causal linkages to make such claims. When we put all of this together it would be hard to avoid the conclusion that mainstream bio-medical approaches to mental health are in crisis and may well require an entirely new approach to human neurological, psychological, and emotional suffering.

In the midst of this crisis comes a report from the World Health Organization that indicates that the kinds of treatment based on the bio-medical model might well be classified as violations of patient rights. The report refers to mainstream psychiatric, behavioral, and psychological approaches operating within 

outdated legal and regulatory frameworks . . . entrenched [in an] overreliance on the biomedical model in which the predominant focus of care is on diagnosis, medication and symptom reduction while the full range of social determinants that impact people’s mental health are overlooked, all of which hinder progress toward full realization of a human rights-based approach. As a result, many people with mental health conditions and psychosocial disabilities worldwide are subject to violations of their human rights – including in care services where adequate care and support are lacking.  

In an article last month on the crisis in conventional bio-medical approaches in the New York Times Magazine (NYT), the concerns raised in the World Health Organization report are echoed and cited. The NYT notes an overreliance on risk management and medications that have dubious correlations with long term positive outcomes. Indeed, the article cites studies that “suggest that maintenance on the drugs may actually worsen outcomes and even cause brain atrophy.” Overall, the article concludes that there is no conclusive science and that there is a “lack of progress in treating serious conditions, or even precisely diagnosing and comprehending them.”

It is this lack of scientific credibility that is partially at the root of the WHO report’s concerns about the use of these technologies as a form of patient abuse. The NYT article cites a 2019 report in The New England Journal of Medicine that stated, “We are facing the stark limitations of biologic treatments,” it argued. “There is no comprehensive biologic understanding of either the causes or the treatments of psychiatric disorders . . . Something has gone wrong in contemporary academic and clinical psychiatry,” Echoing this, the WHO report cites Dr. Thomas R. Insel, the former head of the National Institute of Mental Health (2002-2015),

I spent 13 years at N.I.M.H. really pushing on the neuroscience and genetics of mental disorders, and when I look back on that, I realize that while I think I succeeded at getting lots of really cool papers published by cool scientists at fairly large costs — I think $20 billion — I don’t think we moved the needle in reducing suicide, reducing hospitalizations, improving recovery for the tens of millions of people who have mental illness.

This rather stunning admission that all of the research dollars allocated to the biomedical approach to mental health has essentially offered nothing to the well-being of patients subjected to these modes of treatment, flies in the face of the all-pervasive calls for mental health treatment we see splashed across all forms of media world-wide. This horrific misdirection of people who are suffering into systems that have very little to offer them is unconscionable. And yet, it goes on with ever increasing fervor. We are told that everything from school shootings to depression and anxiety can be treated if we could just get young people into treatment soon enough.

I was appalled to hear a therapist on a well-respected public radio program suggest that the Uvalde school shooting might have been prevented if the shooter had been offered anger management training at some point. This kind of blind faith in treatment models that are widely prescribed, is seldom paired with the actuality that our society is increasing angry and violent. The argument that it would be less so if more people would seek treatment, ignores the fact that the rage and violence we see in what now epidemic proportions is not an individual problem. It is a symptom of a society in deep and toxic decline. There are simply too many of us falling apart on a day-to-day basis; too many of us killing one another or ourselves; too many of us crippled by anxiety; too many us crippled by depression; too many of us traumatized and alone. This is not an individual intrapsychic set of issues. It is now all of us living in a global asylum unresponsive in any meaningful way to our anguish.

The World Health Organization points directly to the current regimes of psychiatric and psychological care as iatrogenic (physician caused) in relation to the proliferation of human emotional and psychological suffering. Michelle Funk who is the primary author of the report told the New York Times that

Present methods can do damage and undermine outcomes not only through psychotropic side effects, and not only through the power imbalances of locked wards and court-ordered outpatient care and even seemingly benign practitioner-patient relationships, but also through a singular focus on reducing symptoms, a professional mind-set that leaves people feeling that they are seen as checklists of diagnostic criteria, not as human beings. “The widespread belief by many in the health sector that people with a mental-health condition have a brain defect or disorder of the brain,” Funk added, “so easily leads to overwhelming disempowerment, loss of identity, loss of hope, self-stigma and isolation.”

It would be hard to imagine a better descriptor of the state of morale under global capitalism today than “overwhelming disempowerment, loss of identity, loss of hope, self-stigma, and isolation.”

Of course, this statement is meant to refer to patients under the care of mainstream psychiatry, psychology, and big pharma. But then, I have to ask, how many of us are there left who are not captured within the machinery of the global open-air asylum. It is rare to find a young person under 40 who cannot self-diagnose their anguish or who has not been on some form of psycho-pharmaceutical regime, sometimes since they were very young.

Despite this overabundance of inducti0n into the world of chemical management of human suffering, we do not seem to be getting better. In fact, a casual perusal of the world in which we live shows us violence, alienation, profound sorrow, trauma, and hopelessness. We are without a doubt going mad and not in a gradual decline. We are losing touch with ourselves, our sociality, our sense of comradery, our love for each other, our desire for collective care, and our hope for the future. At best, we could say that our system of mental health care is ineffective. At worst, we might have to admit that it is part of the problem. That our best intended efforts at care have been corrupted by the bean counters, minions, and bureaucrats who continue to see our suffering as market shares, and our agony as possible profits.

The good news is that there are new modes of care on the horizon and I believe that the relational approach of child and youth care can play a major role in moving us towards new worlds and new peoples. The WHO report cites 22 programs internationally that they say hold out a promise for more just and equitable care. Such programs put combatting alienation at the forefront, with the bio-medical model in the back seat. Such work is not unfamiliar to us in CYC. We are founded on relational care and human dignity as central premises of our work.

I do worry though about how deeply our work has been infiltrated, both at an institutional and personal level by the ideology of biological psychiatry. I hope we can resist the seduction of this failing model and open ourselves to the reality of living fully through the affirmations of life force. There is the possibility of a new dawn. I hope we will be part of the sunrise. If only to honor the lives lost unnecessarily in the maelstrom of a world gone mad. 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App