CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 280 JUNE 2022

Heroes No More?

Kiaras Gharabaghi

Almost exactly two years ago, a couple of months into the COVID-19 pandemic, one of the most commonly used terms to describe frontline workers was ‘heroes’. Just about anyone who continued going to work to provide services to others, from child and youth care practitioners to nurses, and from grocery store clerks to gas station attendants, these were the heroes that kept our societies moving. Shuttered business put out signs that said, “Thank You to our Frontline Heroes”, grocery stores allowed frontline workers to skip the line up to get in. For a brief moment, at least in Canada, some frontline workers even got a pay raise (it was one dollar per hour). Realistically, we knew even back then that the hero status was not going to last forever. But we played along and allowed ourselves to be devalued and our practice to be misrepresented as heroic.

It comes as a surprise to exactly no one that frontline workers are no longer heroes; in fact, they are now once again, as they have always been, the workers of the minimum wage economy, scraping by with barely livable wages. In some parts of the world, child and youth care practitioners are faring slightly better than that, but certainly not at the level one might expect a hero to fare. The same is true for nurses, midwives, and other professionals whose work involves caring for the most vulnerable amongst us, or at the very least, caring for others in their most vulnerable moments.

I don’t care so much about the hypocrisy of the hero label that was so generously thrown around early into the pandemic and has now all but disappeared. It was never more than a manipulative effort to keep those with the fewest resources in society serving those with abundant resources. Sure, the whole thing is ugly from start to finish. In most industrialized countries, there are clear patterns on who those with the fewest resources are: racialized people, Indigenous people, people with disabilities, refugees and immigrants with marginal socio-economic status and power. I am much more concerned about the ways in which we so quickly and so completely bought into the very structures and processes by which our profession, and also other care professions, were exceptionalized so that the practice of care and its value to communities and society at large could be minimized.

When care professionals were declared heroes, they were forced into heroism against their will. The alternative to accepting the hero label was to be deemed a villain. If child and youth care practitioners had abandoned their children and youth, or if nurses had simply walked out of their patients, they would not only not be heroes, but they would be villains. There was never an option to just be someone looking after their own wellbeing, much like the rest of society did. We were not really heroes in the eyes of others; we were one decision away from being villains. And so now that we are no longer heroes, what are we?

Well, I think within our own professional communities, we continue to be important and valued. But within society at large, and certainly in the eyes of governments, we are taken for granted much as we have always been taken for granted. The care we provide is no longer worthy of a label. It is just labour that someone has to do, but it continues to be unworthy (in North America) of legal mandates, professional regulation, or recognition as skilled practice. Unfortunately, we contributed to this situation by failing to resist the hero label. It is not heroic to care for others during times of crisis; it is to the contrary an expectation, and the idea that everyone is cared for during such times ought to exist as a public good, to be protected and strengthened over time.

We might have learned something from the rhetoric that accompanies the heroism of those who serve in the military. Those who die while doing so become heroes for a brief moment as they are laid to rest, to be forgotten shortly thereafter. Those who live, albeit it with trauma and other damages, are left to their own devices, become overrepresented amongst the homeless, victims of the opiate crisis, and criminalized for acting on their trauma. It turns out that when a group is labelled as heroes, their exploitation and eventual discarding can proceed in uncontested manner. I worry a great deal that this is the fate awaiting child and youth care practitioners and other care professionals. Nurses are another example of this process. Everywhere in the world, we have encountered a serious shortage of nurses, and we recognize that this shortage of nurses creates significant challenges for us. During the early stages of the pandemic, we declared the nurses as heroes. As they started “dying”, or burning out, we did nothing to support them. Today, we discard our heroic nurses shamelessly and instead focus on increasing the capacity of nursing schools to attract more future heroes waiting to burn out.

The pattern of heroism is clear; our heroes are little more than commodities to be discarded when they are no longer useful. For me, this process teaches us an important lesson: we don’t need societal recognition of child and youth care practitioners or other care professionals. What we need is societal recognition of care as a public good, as the cornerstone of our humanity, and as the one thing we cannot live without. If we learn to value care, we won’t need heroes. When we declare care to be the work of heroes, we devalue both care itself and those providing it, because we render it exceptional and therefore temporary and expendable. Be careful what you wish for. 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App