Common sense is the most fairly distributed thing in the world, for each one thinks he is so well-endowed with it that even those who are hardest to satisfy in all other matters are not in the habit of desiring more of it than they actually have.
Rene Descartes (1596-1650)
The quote above is 460 years old, yet it is still very relevant today. We each cherish many common-sense ideas that may or may not be factually accurate. One of those concepts, empathy, is my topic this month.
Empathy can be framed as the ability to perceive the world from the perspective of another, being able to stand in someone else’s shoes. This quality is an important skill for doing relational CYC practice and is often listed as a key ingredient of the relational approach. Unfortunately, many CYC practitioners think of empathy as a way to understand someone else by framing the question “How would I feel if that situation had happened to me?” This definition of empathy assumes that the other person shares your personal logic about life and has a similar developmental reality.
CYC practitioners who are still thinking about connecting with others from a Socialized perspective will evaluate the quality of a relationship by measuring how much the participants like each other. Therefore, the goal in relationship building is to get the other person to like you. I can then believe that I am achieving a useful connection when I am important to the other person and they miss me when I am absent. CYC practitioners who create relational efforts this way will be primarily focused on themselves and emphasizing personal attractiveness as they build connections with the youth or families. This is actually how relationship building was described in the CYC literature for many years but has shifted dramatically as we have refined relational practice ideas over the past twenty years.
The logical extension of this type of relationship framework is to attempt to become a role model, so the other person will want to be more like the CYC practitioner in behavior, life logic and attitude. When this is the model being used, molding the other person to be more like you, it is very easy to think that empathy involves imposing your logic and developmental reality when understanding the other.
Genuine empathy is much more complex than this, trying to think like a sexually abused teen-age girl or a physically neglected seven-year-old requires developmental sophistication and respect for an individual’s life logic that is illogical to the helper. We are naturally hard-wired to ignore information that does not align with our preconceived ideas, so we easily dismiss the many illogical communications from the youth and families in our care. When youth lack remorse or repeat self-defeating behaviors, we assume that they need to be directed to use better judgement (our logic and morality), rather than to view it as a perfectly logical behavior from their perspective. Parents who don’t appear to be caring adequately for their children just need to be trained in good parenting skills (our logic and morality), because we cannot imagine that neglect is a legitimate response.
The empathy required to perform at the level of CYC practice demanded by relational CYC work goes far beyond the framing of life events through the personal perspective of the helper. We must become skilled at seeing the world from the challenging life logic of a person who is profoundly different, who cannot and generally will not share our values and beliefs. Standing in the shoes of that person changes our understanding of how to be helpful.