You just keep on living until you are alive again
I have been reflecting on the truly appalling conditions that so many young people are enduring in the early part of the 21st century. Of course, there are those who would argue that statistically, living conditions are overall much better than they have been. But statistics are cold comfort to individual people living in fear, despair, anxiety, grief and trauma. Whatever the global level of statistical well-being, there is still too much pain and too much loss. I have written about all of that in some detail in this column and other places and so I won’t belabor the particulars. What I am concerned with here is the remarkable capacity of human beings to persist and go on in the face of what appear to me to be insurmountable odds. The ability to get up the day after watching your classmates shot to death in front of you, learning of your best friends accidental drug overdose, your cousin’s death by a police bullet, the loss of family and friends to a variety of pandemics from AIDS to COVID, to watch your community struggle to survive economic devastation, to be displaced by climate change or political upheaval, to survive sexual or physical assault – the list goes on and on.
And yet, we do get up and we go on living, although often we carry the open wounding and scars that can make moving on so profoundly challenging. For many of us in the field of CYC the language that we have for this is resilience. To be able to articulate the capacity to go on in spite of trauma has been a real advance over the focus we had for many years of wondering more about why we failed, than why we have success in continuing to live and not just give up. The American Psychological Association defines resilience as,
the process of adapting well in the face of adversity, trauma, tragedy, threats, or significant sources of stress – such as family and relationship problems, serious health problems, or workplace and financial stressors. As much as resilience involves “bouncing back” from these difficult experiences, it can also involve profound personal growth.
The capacity to go on, in this reading of resilience, is a question if individual adaptation. It is a process of coming back to a normative baseline; to bounce back. Of course, there is the possibility that surviving trauma through resilience might lead to “profound personal growth” that would take us beyond where we started. We would be “better” people as a result of our struggles.
But this narrative of excelling through pain is more than a little problematic. It is deeply embedded in the Western mythology of the hero or saint who suffers as an exemplar of what is possible. We hear the phrase “No pain no gain” in a variety of contexts to emphasize the idea that there is something noble and worthy in sacrifice and voluntary subjection to pain in the pursuit of personal growth. Indeed, the narrative of the APA on resilience explains that resilience very likely involves “considerable emotional distress.” But they tell us that like physical exercise we can all learn to be resilient if we learn how to weather suffering by building our capacity like a muscle. We just need to learn the proper regime of healthy responses to become more resilient people. In their view, “resilience involves behaviors, thoughts, and actions that anyone can learn and develop.” It is something anyone can learn. The APA suggests that we focus on learning how to connect, to take care of our body, practice mindfulness, avoid drugs or alcohol to mask the pain, find a purpose in your life, move toward your goals, and seek out modes of self-discovery. And of course, seek out professional help with all of this.
This normative and developmental view of resilience reinforces several rather toxic elements in Western colonial thought and practice. The idea that resilience is centered on good or healthy behaviors, seems to imply to me a kind of hidden moralism. Those who are resilient are those good people who are able to rise above their circumstances. These are people who exercise their better qualities and practices through acts of will. They live within the parameters for emotional health set by the overarching dictates of Western psychology. Suffering in and of itself is simply a good excuse to become a better person. It is to some degree, strictly functional like body building or maintaining a certain body weight. We can all overcome adversity if we take the helpful advice of the psychological experts. In this rather well-meaning account, we all have the capacity to be resilient, if we are willing to do the right things.
But there is a set of power relations buried in this account that privileges the domain of psychological expertise and its investments in returning us to seamlessly functioning citizens of global capitalism. There is an implicit suggestion that those who remain traumatized for too long are failing in some way, that they are lacking. Or worse that they are resistant to the best efforts of well-intentioned mental health professionals to “help” them. Although we wouldn’t say it out loud, perhaps they are simply slackers who are too lazy to feel better. After all, if it is simply a case of exercising an emotional muscle and psychology has provided us with the exercises to perform, then why wouldn’t we all do what is necessary to be resilient? In a subtle way, the apparently hopeful and strength-based approach hides within itself a critique of those who fail to respond to its ministrations. There is a message, that if you do not take advantage of the tools provided to build your resilience, you are somehow defying the social forces determined to help you be the best you can be. You are being difficult and need to seek help from those who know better.
There is a politics here, but it can be difficult to see. Those whose circumstances would place them in harm’s way to the greatest degree are those who are marginalized and disenfranchised by the dominant system of global capitalism. If you are Black, female, poor, Indigenous, a person of color, a member of LGBTQ community, a migrant, or a religious minority you are at far greater risk for intensified levels of human suffering. Correspondingly, the demand on you to be resilient and bounce back is also amplified.
That said, the demand to seek psychological support from a field dominated by White, cisgender, heterosexual, middle class professionals can seem to be suspect. To seek assistance with one’s suffering from those who have access to the dominant realm of privilege based intersectionally in race, class, gender, and sexuality, can be daunting. And those concerns are not without merit. Nathaniel Harrington speaks to this concerning the mental health response to the trauma of the George Floyd murder and the traumatic effect on Black men.
Even when Black people do seek help for mental health issues … white clinicians often don't understand the unique and persistent stress of being Black in America … Researchers even suggest that Black pain is … treated with a subtle indifference, as if the pain basically matters less.
And it is this subtle indifference to the pain of the “other” that frames a certain politics of avoidance masked by individualized models of resilience. In these models, I would argue that the multigenerational context of suffering without surcease is placed in the background as context, while the ability to “bounce back” and show little or no sign of the ongoing assault is foregrounded. It is as though we in the dominant society were saying, “this trauma is unfortunate, but people survive our ongoing attacks and go on to thrive.” Instead of being accountable to the harm we engender on a daily basis, we can focus on how our fellow human beings survive the toxic society we continue to produce because it benefits some of us. If we can show that people are resilient and bounce back from the traumas of racism, heterosexism, misogyny, homophobia, transphobia, poverty, then such trauma becomes less urgent. Yes, we agree it should change, but then we really don’t do what is necessary to change it. Instead, we focus on how to change those who suffer because of it.
In CYC we see this daily. We mobilize our agencies and programs to triage trauma by focusing on the strengths and resilience of those suffering from effects of the very system that funds our efforts. Very few of our agencies are organized around organizing young people, their families, and communities into political projects that might impact the conditions underlying the trauma we are so enamored of treating. Instead, we focus on building the kinds of resiliency that would allow young people to bounce back and find their place as docile citizens who will cause less trouble for the system that continues to attack them.
However, perhaps we need to remember that the system that I am referring to here can only continue to traumatize the young people and communities that we care about, if it has our complicity and assent to continue. One of the politically devastating aspects of individualized approach to resilience is the way that it can separate us from the force of collective understandings of trauma as something shared. That contemporary trauma is not a matter of individualized circumstance, but something experienced by millions of people. No one should have to feel that resilience is up to them alone. Resilience is not a matter of personal struggle to “bounce back.” Collectively, if we bounce back together there is the possibility that we will not bounce back to a normative accommodation to the world as it is. Instead, we might bounce back to a world we have not yet seen that might well be less painful and serve us all better.
In this regard, Michael Lerner proposes a collective approach to resiliency that takes into account the power of all of us working together. He refers to this as community resilience. He suggests that we need to remember that human communities are complex and adaptive systems that have inborn capacities for persistence in the face of trauma and disruption. However, to effectively adapt and persist, we need to engage all members of our community and be sure that whatever actions we take benefit all of us, not just a few. To do this we need to keep track of what it is we value at all levels in the particular place in which we live together. What is important to us that we want to sustain and what can we afford to let go of? He suggests that it is critical that we develop ways to produce a rough consensus about these values in order to be able to produce resilient communities that are capable of supporting each of us through disruptions and traumas. Rather than the individualized prescriptions of the psychological approach that calls on us to develop our own plan of personal growth, Lerner proposes that we need all of us working together to envision new futures for our communities. He tells us that we can come to understand ourselves as a system that needs to adapt, rather than as individuals. Lerner suggests that human systems are complex and dynamic, made up of combinations of all us thinking and working together and this foundation in community can allow us to find the courage to face the future through our shared vision and values. I would argue that this model of resilience may well have actual political capacities through which we might shift and change the system engendering the traumas that require our resilience.
I often wonder how our work would change if we adopted a collective approach to the pain and suffering, we encounter in our work. What if we were to think about resiliency as a question of building a sense of shared values developed by consensus between young people and adults? What if our programs moved away from adapting young people to the world and began to envision our relation to young people as working together with adults to adapt the world in ways that actually worked in their favor? For me, this is a question of affirming life and living. At the end of the day resilience is like the quote at the beginning of this piece, “You just keep on living until you are alive again.” To have a collective vision of what it means to be alive and to value that above all else may be the key to making it all bearable.