A while back I had a moment being sparked out of the same old, same old, by a word from the always on news channel. It described my status to a t and yet I missed it thinking I heard lingering. It took awhile to learn I had it wrong finally being able to read the source article for the word, Adam Grant’s “There’s a Name for the Blah You’re Feeling: It’s Called Languishing” in The New York Times. He wrote:
Languishing is the neglected middle child of mental health. It’s the void between depression and flourishing — the absence of well-being. You don’t have symptoms of mental illness, but you’re not the picture of mental health either. You’re not functioning at full capacity. Languishing dulls your motivation, disrupts your ability to focus, and triples the odds that you’ll cut back on work. [1]
Grant was referring to the work of Corey Keyes who made the link between the word and emotion: Languishing is not depression or sadness, but rather “the absence of feeling good about your life,” Keyes says. Languishing is also the lack of meaning, purpose or belonging in life, which leads to emptiness, lack of emotion and stagnation, he says. [2] This reminded me of John Cleese in the classic Dead Parrot sketch on Monty Python with its flurry of dead references. Languishing seemed perfect for its own flurry of blah references: groundhog moments, same old-same old, running on the spot, procrastinating, stalled, really anything that describes living without a sense of well, living. A curious kind of suspended contentment. As life would have it another news item brought the thoughts of a 13-year-old girl who is clearly caught up in languishing. Like many young persons she was wise and profound in her observations and conclusions. This column will explore these as they certainly spoke to me as one concerned about how young people are experiencing this pandemic and about how shared experiences can produce shared insights.
Natasha Simon wrote “The life and loneliness of youth under pandemic restrictions”, her view on pandemic living. Manitoba came to a roaring halt with a Code Red declaration at noon on Mother’s Day. The often-chilly spring had occasional summer like days with the sense of change coming. The positivity rate went from 2 something to 15 something in a matter of days and bold action was called for. By that afternoon there were few cars on the road, parking lots were wide open and all that had eased open was now closed with untold reservations for a spot on the patio for a meal for mom just vaporized. Natasha recalled thinking: "It's only for three weeks," I tell myself, and then school will start again. You've had school all year until now. You are one of the lucky ones."[3] Well, hopefully, as factors like an extension of the lockdown and the looming end of the school year may end the year prematurely.
“I still got to go to school. I still got to see people at school and be around them. Still, it felt like nobody was really there. Usually we sat in a dark room with the lights off and the blinds closed, all of us facing some sort of electronic device, procrastinating and not getting our work done.”3
Natasha was expressing her experience of languishing. She was where she wanted to be and with those she wanted to be with and yet, there was separation. She details the expectations she endured: “We have been told countless times that if we don't socially distance, stay away from friends, go straight home after school, don't stay and talk to people, don't go to busy public places, don't hang out with friends and stop doing the things that make us kids, that make us human beings, we will cause harm to others.”3 Of course she is not alone in this and even though she clearly shares the experience the perceived experience is that it is happening only to you, shaping and confounding your day. Within hours on lockdown Sunday the grocer had the carts flipped over to barricade the entrance and force distanced lines to form as the nominal 125 persons limit had now been reduced to 100 forcing individual entry to the store.
Natasha had a fine sense of being harmful towards others, one which comes with a price tag. She wrote: “Now, kids are scared. If they break these rules they feel like murderers, ungrateful people who are just terrible and selfish. But while following these rules we are killing ourselves, slowly but surely.”3 Personally while I understood the science working on isolation and chewing gum constantly to stay in touch with those taste buds, I did not quite see myself as a spreader. The mask covered that off. An incident in a pet shop alerted me to the paranoia out there. A woman was bathing her golden who was just loving the attention and I was adoring this more than six feet away but still present. The woman was disturbed and anxious regardless and asked me to move back. I left the shop, but the incident lingered for me. As a social observer this unprecedented isolation from society may have unique implications. The elderly do have the advantage of having lived much of their lives where the young can only appreciate the future. Their guilt is unfair considering this virus operates the way it does. The early mutterings predict a roaring return to the skies and good times driven by this pent-up hunger or impulse once this lifts. As the use of masks was welcomed in just that sort of way by many there were individuals and businesses still cautious, keen to keeping their masks on just in case. It will take some time for the world to find a comfort point, if ever.
Natasha wrote about giving up as each day was a restricted and isolated nightmare followed by ending the day staring at the ceiling in her bedroom. She wrote: “The kids are so depressed and lonely that they are attempting suicide and they are being rushed to emergency rooms. Why don't the adults really realize that we NEED this to be over and we need to live our lives? Kids everywhere are failing in school, suffering from depression, suicide, loneliness and things kids shouldn't have to go through.”3 Regretfully, adults acting like children, participating in an insurrection and complaining a presidency was stolen in the election among the usual mass shootings, police shooting of black citizens kind of sucks the oxygen out of concern for the young by reporters. There has been much speculation that risk continues for children and youth but little firm data to go on. Many have just given up becoming truant from school and perhaps stable living. For child and youth care practitioners the potential for intervention would seem high indeed as so many will need help connecting and reconnecting.
“The pandemic started when I was 11 and I'm 13 now. I never got to finish Grade 6 or say goodbye to my friends. I had to start this whole new middle school and lifestyle without anyone with me to help me through it. I have seen so many of my friends succumb to depression.”3
Here Natasha identifies the major conundrum facing everyone who has had to live through this. Languishing tends to ignore time and its passing by blunting the lived experience. For her it was the significance of moving up to middle school. For her older peers, it means missing graduations, initiations and all manner of shared sports, performances and annual events. Languishing does not have many fans, certainly not for long. Boredom does no one any good so society applies several rewards (work brings holidays), seasonal events (the Christmas party, lunch or meal out) and professional gatherings (workshops, association meetings, conferences). For child and youth care a National Conference was cancelled early on, the Unity Conference in Dublin in November followed by the cancelation of a World CYC Conference in Glasgow for June. While Toronto has already cancelled ALL summer events the Ontario Association of Child and Youth Counsellors will stage a provincial conference in a few weeks at a college as per usual. I suspect it will be a sanitary and distanced series of workshops with masks always worn. It would not fly in Manitoba beyond 5 persons at this point. Even in our darkest forming days of our association we had more than 5 turn out in January. The meetings that followed fell back under the 5 and less for several years.
I invite you to follow the link for Natasha’s article to appreciate how close youth and adult experience of this pandemic is. Languishing tends to impact adults and the young in similar ways. Natasha did note the fear driven lecturing of the adults in her life. She tends to repeat her luck as if this may have been pointed out to her more than a few times, but this is where I agree with her. I also feel lucky with each stick of gum to confirm it along with an end of the day meditation on being lucky to have made it through yet another day with home keeping food preparation, correspondence and whatever enthusiasm has emerged like air frying or steam cleaning. No one is happy with this situation and all are putting in their best effort. Debriefing and some form of celebration or shared recreational experience would go a long way to embrace living once again.
[1] Feeling Blah During the Pandemic? It's Called Languishing - The New York Times (nytimes.com)
[2] Living, But Not Flourishing: The Pandemic-Fueled Feeling Known As 'Languishing' | Here & Now (wbur.org)
[3] The life and loneliness of youth under pandemic restrictions | CBC News