CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 268 JUNE 2021

The Diversity Commitments: Many Words, Many Meanings

Kiaras Gharabaghi

Lately, I have had a lot of discussions with people on issues broadly related to the topic of diversity. Some of those people are practitioners and organizational leaders in small town and rural areas, others are scholars, again others are students in child and youth care. These discussions are always immensely interesting, sometimes a little depressing, but usually at the very least hopeful. One aspect of these discussions that has become apparent to me of late is that we really do use a lot of different words and phrases to describe what we are talking about, but often we use these words interchangeably without much thought to what they actually mean. This month, therefore, I thought I would provide some of the words and phrases that commonly come up in my discussions, along with some brief thoughts on the possible meanings of these words and phrases, both from my perspective and from the perspective of the people using them. My hope is that this might help those of us trying to move forward meaningfully with decentering whiteness to have discussions in which we understand our language slightly better, or at least in which we can problematize some of the implications of the language we use. Note that in what follows, I discuss only those terms that actually come up frequently when organizations and students talk about ‘diversity’ and strategies to respond to diversity. This is not a list of terms we should be talking about, but rather one that focuses on what, in my experience, is actually being talked about, especially in Canadian child and youth serving contexts. So here we go.

Diversity – this is perhaps the single most popular term used these days to describe a very broad range of identity characteristics that are seen to be relevant to how we provide child and youth services. People talk about developing ‘diversity strategies’ or ‘taking initiative in the area of diversity’. My experience has been that people feel very comfortable using this term. At the same time, I get the sense that the term affords comfort and ease of use in part because it means absolutely nothing by virtue of meaning pretty much everything. Its most popular feature is that virtually everyone can see themselves reflected in the term itself. I too am diverse, since no one is quite like me. The term often is used to ensure inclusion of the standard diversity factors, such as race, gender identity, sexual orientation and ability/disability. But it can also include mental health, socio-economic status and class, cultural contexts, language contexts, and sometimes even personality. For sure, this term avoids any hierarchies of issues or circumstances, allowing for racism to occupy a similar place as professional issues such as pathologizing, stereotyping, or generalizing. For the most part, discussions that center diversity tend to be neoliberal discussions that place value on labelling differences while seeking ways to coopt such differences into the status quo.

Terms related to Culture – while I will single out specific terms related to culture that are often used by people, I want to more generally comment on the use of the word culture. There are many different problems associated with how we use this term, but certainly a particularly damaging one is that culture de-centers other identity factors, often quite intentionally. It is less of an insult to say to someone that they misread someone’s culture than it is to say that they are racist. In my experience, we like to talk about culture as an indication of our progressiveness because it avoids us having to talk about much more loaded concepts that we find threatening to our fragile sense of accountability. Beyond that, however, our use of the term culture is often highly superficial, reducing people’s own sense of culture to a limited set of activities, preferences and values. Furthermore, efforts related to centering culture tend to eliminate tensions within cultures, ranging from patriarchy to violence, and from shadism to gender perspectives, and more. There is limited room to consider sub-cultures, diffused cultures, or cultural centers versus cultural margins. Finally, there is almost always a sub-text of racism embedded in the culture conversation whereby we assign common cultures to Black people (also to Indigenous people), for example, while working hard to validate the cultural differences between the Welsh, the Irish, the English and the Scottish.

Multiculturalism – this term remains popular in Canada in part because the country has pursued a policy of multiculturalism at the federal level, and so the term is well embedded in the Canadian psyche. But I have heard the term used outside of Canada too, especially in Central Europe (notably Germany). Multiculturalism is perhaps the single most problematic term in this context, since it explicitly imposes a cultural identity on individuals based on their geographic heritage, forcing them into collectively identified groups that deny their more particular multiplicities of identities and raising expectations of them to behave in accordance with the norms associated with a particular ‘culture’. This almost by default eliminates many ways of being in the world, such as, for example, a gay Muslim, or a Black Jew. Multiculturalism constructs communities and then forces people to live within the boundaries of how those communities were constructed. In many respects, this term is the 20th and 21st century version of colonialism, with similarly devasting consequences. Just like the boundaries of African states were drawn by Europeans playing their game of balancing of power in Europe with no regard of longstanding territorial identifications of already well established and generally unconnected communities, multiculturalism creates packaged cultural communities to which each of us is somehow assigned.

Cultural Competence – this term, which became very popular in the 1980s and 1990s, continues to enjoy some life in professional communities and service organizations. The basic premise of cultural competence is the idea that services and individual professionals have to know enough about different cultures in order to ensure that their service approaches are meaningful to the people served. This term suffers from similar deficits as the term multiculturalism (and indeed, all terms that use the word ‘culture’) because it imposes on people (and even communities) pre-packaged understandings about their culture. On the one hand, in practice this means that people associated with a particular culture are not really allowed to resist their imposed culture. On the other hand, it also often means that culture is reduced and caricaturized to a series of rituals, food preferences and ceremonies that often are not at all reflective of current realities (for example, Lederhosen in German ‘culture’).

Cultural Responsiveness – amongst the terms using the word ‘culture’, this is probably the most meaningful one, since it inherently recognizes that people exist in some kind of cultural (or systemic) context and can therefore not be reduced to their individuality. In this way, it is a term that explicitly validates that individuals and community are interdependent in some manner. In theory, the term does not prescribe what we mean by culture. In practice, however, the term is often used interchangeably with the term cultural competence and suggests to professional practitioners that they should use their understanding of culture as a framework for their interpersonal practices with specific individuals. Another deficit of this term along with all terms that use culture as the core concept is that it reduces the full complexity of identity to cultural stereotypes, which can, and often has, seriously damaged people.

Inclusion – what could possibly be more progressive than inclusion, particularly if we understand the term exclusively as the opposite of exclusion. The intention behind the term is of course a well-meaning one and comes from a recognition that the way in which services are structured often results in some individuals being denied service by virtue of their identity characteristics. The term itself was predominantly designed to respond to the exclusion of people with disabilities in what is sometimes called mainstream social contexts. For example, young people on the autism spectrum should be ‘included’ in mainstream classrooms. Of course, the norming of what constitutes the mainstream and what does not is itself a form of exclusion. Perhaps more importantly, however, the very concept of inclusion can be problematic if one considers that inclusion in systems of oppression is hardly a step forward. In discussions about inclusion, we rarely ask the question whether people actually want to be included in institutional cultures and processes that systematically oppress them.

Anti-oppression – This term, along with its derivative, anti-oppressive practice, has without a doubt become one of the more popular ones over the course of the past fifteen years or so. People use it all the time to amplify their commitments to social justice and their progressive thinking about ‘diversity’. Most of the time, this term serves as an umbrella term for just about everything that seems wrong or unfair, and very often, anti-oppression is tied not only to the manifestation of injustice within those groups who experience oppression, but also to the privilege associated with social groups positioned at the high end of power and coercion. First and foremost, anti-oppression takes on the concept of white supremacy and more generally issues of power and seeks to label and then resist power structures that chronically provide advantage to some while marginalizing others. Anti-oppression, as a term, demands much more than an analysis of specific actions taken by ‘oppressors’; it demands a systemic and structural analysis, and often focuses on the oppressive patterns embedded in much more macro-level systems, such as capitalism, neoliberalism, gender, race, and even at a much deeper level, systems of ontology and epistemology. This is, on the whole, a good term and a good way of thinking, but it does come with some major problems as well. For one thing, almost no one using the term, especially in service organizations but also in academia, is equipped to live up to its promise. In other words, references to anti-oppression and anti-oppressive practice rarely move beyond the level of superficial head-nodding to social justice issues, complete with validation of virtually any complaints or possible constellation of unfairness experienced by anyone. Beyond that, however, perhaps the greatest challenge to the anti-oppression enthusiasts is the authoritarian streak of the movement itself. No sooner do organizations (including academic units such as Schools of Child & Youth Care and Social Work Schools) label themselves as anti-oppressive, demands for conformity to a particular way of being, thinking and dealing with knowledge appear. In academic settings, no one ever wants to talk about the great silencing of perspectives that may be critical of particular ‘truths’ established by the anti-oppressive movement, resulting in some academics getting attacked and insulted and others resorting to an often slightly pathetic performance of anti-oppression enthusiasm while living the good life based on their privileges. In service settings, the failure of anti-oppressive commitments to take account of the wide gulf between the very legitimate and typically very profound critique of capitalism, neoliberalism, whiteness and white supremacy on the one hand, and the everyday practical realities of living in a capitalist, neoliberal, and white supremacist institutional context, results in a comfortable and convenient co-existence of two dynamics: the status quo of oppressive practices, and the rhetoric of anti-oppressive practice, which run parallel and rarely collide. Occasionally they do collide as a result of yet another micro-aggression or organizational injustice, at which point the organization implements mandatory anti-oppression training for everyone by contracting with the resolutely capitalist anti-oppression training industry.

Anti-racism – this term is different from both the ‘culture’ terms and the ‘oppression’ terms in that it squarely focuses on race as the center of social injustice. The term itself makes no assumptions of the connection between race and culture and therefore maintains a validation of diversity within social groups that may be associated with similar geographic heritage or cultural rituals, ceremonies and conventions. I like anti-racism in part for its historical analysis, which typically is very strong in its tracing of race across pre-capitalist, capitalist and increasingly post-modern and post-capitalist political economies. The term is stronger when it is more specific; in my context of central Canada, for example, I prefer a focus on anti-Black and anti-Indigenous racism rather than anti-racism generally, owing in large part to the peculiarities of white-Indigenous and white-African/Afro-Caribbean relations in a Canadian context. At the same time, at the organizational level, anti-racism language often is entirely instrumental in nature, and applies only in geographic contexts where racialized communities are visibly and significantly represented (usually in big cities); smaller cities and rural communities (which carry disproportionate political power across all of Canada and the United States) see no relevance to anti-racism because their communities, they say, are predominantly white. Anti-racism, as a practice, is seen as relevant only in relation to the those subjected to racism, but rarely to those with power, privilege and coercive resources to uphold racism at a systemic and structural, and dare I say, cultural, level. As a result of the instrumental associations with anti-racism, anti-racist practices are very often entirely neo-liberal by design, focusing on hiring practices and proportional representation of racial minority groups (usually resulting in horribly oppressive scenarios for the one Black person or the one Indigenous person who proportionally represents their community) and on relatively disconnected ports of inclusion of racialized communities, manifested by relationships to those communities that come with a lot of ceremony and public relations infrastructure but that remain largely irrelevant in the everyday functioning of the institution. In practice, anti-racism often become a little bit of a (disturbing) circus.

Positive Space – this term is not as common in my discussion with people, but it does come up often enough to be mentioned here. The term itself is of course associated with organizational approaches to LGBTQ2s+ communities, employees and service users, but organizational leaders often point to their longstanding work in creating ‘positive spaces’ as a way of establishing their ‘diversity’ street cred. My sense is that the message here is something along the lines of “well, we have done a lot to render our organization a positive space, and now we want to extend that work to becoming inclusive of everyone, regardless of race, ability and disability, or whatever”. Positive space is a good thing; extending the use of this term, or believing it to serve as a foundation for a comprehensive social justice strategy is probably not a good thing. For one thing, in many organizations that take pride in their positive space work, this social justice work is almost entirely white, middle class social justice work. The space is positive for a professional white same sex couple and their children, which doesn’t in any way imply that it is positive for a homeless racialized person identifying as Muslim and outside of binary gender categories. Incorporating positive space language into diversity strategies often gives strength to colour blindness as a value and operational concept.

Accessibility – this term, surprisingly, does not come up very often in my discussions, which is perhaps telling about the commitments behind those discussions. Accessibility is often associated with measures designed to render spaces physically accessible to people with disabilities, and in very practical terms, usually involves a ramp and a main floor bathroom. I mention this term primarily to point to the infancy of our ‘diversity’ movements in practice. Almost no child and youth services are accessible, and every time a person arrives at a centre who may require ASL or descriptive captioning or some other modification of service that can’t be addressed through a ramp, a mad scramble ensues to figure out what to do. In many child and youth services, rendering services accessible to diverse cultural norms, or diverse ways of being, is entirely out of the purview of discussion. Almost every core mechanism of child and youth service provision, from privacy laws to the way case conferences are organized, represent accessibility issues for almost everyone except white, able bodied, cis-gendered consumers.

Equity – I saved this term for last only because it is perhaps the single most complex term despite is brevity. Equity is complex because it implies, at least in spirit, that it is understood from the perspective of those seeking equity rather than those designing equity. This, in and of itself, usually means that the term goes nowhere in practice, because almost nothing in child and youth services is actually designed by those seeking equity. This means that our discussions about equity are really discussions about the creativity of those with power and privilege in constructing frameworks for equity that usually are reduced to some basic standards of equality of opportunity. Equity work almost always is about ensuring that we don’t offer things to some groups but not to others, but such work struggles profoundly with allowing equity-seeking groups to define the circumstances that would afford them access to opportunities that are meaningful to them. Institutions are not built to be equitable, because this requires multiple processes and procedures to respond to similar things; most institutions are designed to create policies and procedures that are universal in nature and apply to everyone. Conversations about equity are difficult largely because the nature of the concept of equity is so far outside of the lived reality of most institutions that we encounter the limits of our imagination when using the term.

So, there you have it. A short and admittedly somewhat surface-based review of the terms we use in general discussions about ‘diversity’. I think it is important to really think about these terms because the discussions where these terms are used usually reflect serious and authentic intentions on the part of child and youth services to do better. I always appreciate those intentions and the efforts associated with these, but I also know just how quickly such intentions reproduce the status quo. Aligning what we do and how we do it with the rhetoric of diversity intentions turns out to be extraordinarily difficult. In the meantime, the lives of many young people, their families and their communities hang in the balance.

Just one more note. Another term that often comes up in discussions is ‘intersectionality’. I haven’t raised it here because the absurdities of the term’s usage are of such great magnitude that this will require an essay all of its own. Perhaps sometime soon I will get to that one. 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App