My first experience with a Child and Youth Care Week was in October of 1996.
In April of that year, I landed my dream job, Program Manager of the Developmental Neuropsychiatric Program (DNP) at a state hospital. It was a specialized program for the long term treatment of adolescents who had concurrent diagnoses of behavioural disorders and learning disabilities. It had a capacity of 22 patients on three units, one for boys, another for girls, and a third coed unit for patients preparing for discharge.
It had considerable resources for these 22 children – three psychiatrists, five psychologists, three teachers, two social workers, a music therapist, a recreational therapist, lots of nurses, and lots and lots of Child and Youth Care workers called “Behaviour Shaping Specialists,” BSS’s for short. (Where do we come up with these names?) Qualifications for BSS’s were high for our region – a college degree or several years of prior experience in the field. Pay was likewise relatively high.
Medication was de-emphasized. Behavioural treatment was the order of the day. All of that attracted me to the job–I considered my orientation to be primarily behavioural and I looked forward to working with a team of psychologists with more than ample staff and resources.
And so in October, we came to ‘CYC week,’ a week the hospital set aside for recognition of its direct care staff–the Psychiatric Aides on other units and our BSS’s. The hospital made note of the week on the sign at the entrance to the hospital where they posted various announcements. After that it was up to the individual programs to recognize their direct care staff.
The RN Manager who hired and supervised the BSS’s ordered color-coordinated T-shirts for each of her staff, a different color for each unit. The rest of us put on a special covered dish luncheon for the BSS’s on Friday, with enough left over for the evening and overnight shifts. Tributes were paid. The RN Manager told them they were all special, the backbone of the program. “You all do such a great job. We couldn’t get along without you,” and so on. One of the psychologists gushed, “You are all terrific. We could not do our jobs without the data you people provide.”
But it all fell flat. Extremely flat.
The problem was that the hospital treated their employees as disposable commodities. Commendations were actively discouraged because commendations could make it more difficult to dismiss employees if they appealed their dismissal to civil service. Disciplinary memos for any infractions were the rule–disciplinary memos helped to justify dismissals. Consequently, employees were readily ‘written up’ for any infractions of the policy and procedures manual, which was over seven centimeters (three inches) thick. It seemed as if the hospital was more concerned with dismissing employees that with retaining them. The RN Manager on DNP had a reputation for being especially strict with her staff.
Morale among the BSS’s was abysmal. In the twelve months preceding my arrival, the turnover rate for our BSS’s was a staggering 95%. It’s not that we lost 95% of our BSS’s that year. There were many who had years of service. But we had so many more who left in their first few months.
In time, I concluded that we had three types of BSS’s. There were those new employees who had no investment in the job at all and who left quickly, after discovering that the job was not for them. Then there were those who had been there for a few years. When they left, they could withdraw their contributions to the pension plan in which participation was mandatory. It could be several thousand dollars. They also got paid for accumulated leave, which was often substantial because they accrued leave in lieu of pay for any overtime they worked. They worked a lot of overtime because of staff shortages due to turnover, and rarely were approved to take either their compensatory leave or their vacation, again because of staff shortages due to turnover.
More thousands of dollars. They actually could count on a substantial cash ‘bonus’ for resigning, perhaps enough for a new car. Finally, we had the employees who had been with the hospital for many years. They could not afford to leave because they had so much invested in the retirement plan. So we had lots of disgruntled employees who left, and lots of disgruntled employees who could not leave. So when the RN Manager gushed about how “terrific you all are,” it did not ring true. Many of her BSS’s had been on the receiving end of her disciplinary memos. More, there was at least one whom she was actively trying to terminate and everyone knew it.
And when the psychologist gushed about the data the BSS’s provided... Their most important contribution, providing behavioural data for the psychologists so they could revise their behaviour plans?
Really. I could just tell how important a part of the treatment team that made them feel. In reality, BSS’s were discouraged from forming relationships with the kids out of fear that they would undermine treatment. Psychologists did the treatment.
They developed the treatment plans and revised them weekly on each child. And they met individually with each child on their case load (of four or five) weekly to discuss their progress–provided the child was not on restriction.
The treatment was behavioural, based on the strictest of token economies. Children earned points for each activity period, one for being on time, another for ‘participation,’ and a third for showing no more than two prohibited behaviors during the period. There were some 42 prohibited behaviours that required token fines, sixteen of which also carried room restrictions of from one to three hours.
No one was allowed to speak with children on room restriction, neither the BSS’s nor their psychologist. When children became distressed, perhaps cursing, staff were not to attempt to de-escalate children. They were only to say, “That’s cursing, that’s two tokens.” In a ‘neutral’ tone–not punitively, and not with any empathy. Children were then expected to stop cursing, go to their jar of accumulated tokens, take out two and hand them to staff in payment of their fine.
What children often did was to escalate further, ‘earning’ more fines. Eventually they threw something or tore something up (both were classified as property damage and carried a room restriction of three hours in addition to a fine), or attacked staff (aggression, another three-hour room restriction). These aggressive behaviors almost always resulted in the ‘necessity’ for physical restraint.
There were usually about 30 episodes of physical restraint in a given month.
BSS’s were expected to record behaviour accurately and completely, and to award tokens, impose fines, enforce restrictions, and safely subdue children who needed to be placed in restraints.
Consistently and with no extraneous dialogue. (Even the social workers were not allowed to spend too much time with their kids–they arranged home passes and wrote progress reports.)
So. BSS’s were simply score-keepers and enforcers, often physically so. There were a few who seemed to take some satisfaction in filling this role. And there were many who did not. And the recognition for these during their week of celebration ... well, we all sure did eat good!
CYC week, for CYC’s who are truly appreciated, it is just icing on the cake. For those who are not allowed to contribute to their potential and who are not recognized for what they do ... It’s just an exercise to make everyone else feel good. And maybe to eat well.
The other benefit of Child and Youth Care week, when CYC’s can pull it off, is to highlight their potential and their contributions. That could not happen on DNP. I sincerely hope it can happen elsewhere.
Just my opinion based on my observations of one program. (I also worked in another program that did not celebrate a Child and Youth Care week. But they did not have to. They routinely recognized the contributions of their Child and Youth Care workers.)
Nevertheless, Child and Youth Care workers are indeed the most essential component of any residential program. Even on DNP I occasionally noticed staff who had relationships with children and who used those relationships to help children get through the strict behavioural ‘milieu.’ No one can be sure, but I suspect those staff had at least as much to do with the improvement of those children who did improve as did the team of behavioural psychologists. And for the few children who did not improve ...