CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 149 JULY 2011

Commandment 2: No Need to Fix Anything – Just Add the Missing Parts: A Needs-Based Approach to Child and Youth Care

Gerry Fewster

Only a few years ago the word ‘unsustainability’ didn’t even exist. Now it’s used to describe almost everything we do on this planet. The reason is simple. In order to be sustainable the environment needs constant self-replenishment to support human life; the economy needs protected freedom to operate in the best interests of all; nations need security to respect other nations; religions need humility to maintain their spiritual connections; and, at the core, human beings need to express their caring and compassion in order to live in harmony on this planet. The message is clear. When we fail to attend to the essential needs in any living system it becomes increasingly unsustainable and our desperate efforts to ‘fix’ the accumulating problems only serve to dig the trenches deeper. Well, the same principle applies to the sustainability of human relationships in general and the development of our children in particular.

For the most part medical science has confirmed what we have always known about the physical and nutritional needs of kids, although fads and fashions might change. Meanwhile, obesity is rampant across nations that still have options. In the psychological realm, child development theorists have given us a broad list of specific needs in line with their specific areas of interest. So we can appreciate what Piaget had to say about intellectual development, understand Mowrer’s theories of communication and agree with Kohlberg’s notions about morality, even though we might never actually incorporate these ideas into our efforts to respond to the struggles of a particular child. But, in my experience, very few of the problems presented to professionals are associated with the needs identified by these anointed experts. In the vast majority of cases, the deprivations occur in relationships and appear as self-defeating patterns of behavior that can be traced back to what happened, or didn’t happen, during the child’s earliest formative years.

From this perspective, our primary relationships, from conception through the first three or four years of life become the blueprint that lays the foundation and sets the direction for the journey from the dependency of infancy to the autonomy of adulthood. If the essential needs are acknowledged and addressed, the core of this developmental trajectory is the emergence of the Self – an expanding expression of who we are through our relationships with others. If not, we are left with the professional ‘fix-it’ remedies we euphemistically refer to as “interventions.” Back to square one.

But if we can identify the foundational needs that nourish the development of the Self, perhaps we can create a relational context that offers what was missing from the outset. Again, if we review the relevant theory and research we will find a multitude of possibilities clustered around the orientation of particular theorists. Blending these notions with a little intuition, a dash of insight and the groundbreaking research of Daniel Stern, three fundamental relational needs emerge from the mix. They are as follows:

1. The Need for Bond

If the experts agree about anything it’s that the bond between infant and mother (or primary caregiver) establishes the foundations for the life-long developmental journey. Ideally, this provides the anchor point — a constant, loving and reliable presence that ensures survival and protects against the inherent fears of abandonment and annihilation. When this primary bond is weak or interrupted, children become anxious and insecure.

Feeling powerless and fearful of the unknown, they desperately try to control the world, using whatever means are available to them along the way. If someone moves close, they will distance themselves. If others move away, they will do whatever it takes to get them back. Their only trust is in their own defenses. Is there a Child and Youth Care worker anywhere who has not tried to fix this relational dance? At the extreme end of the continuum, infants who live with the terror of abandonment and annihilation have no option but to cut themselves off from both Self and Other. With no emotional contact on the inside and no concern for the feelings of others, all that counts is their own survival. These are the kids who will torture a kitten to affirm their power over life or kill a classmate with no sense of remorse. The label may be “psychopath” but no fix is available at this point.

2. The Need for Breathing Room

The primary bond that provides safety and security must also be the home-base from which the infant is free to explore the external world. Children who are encouraged to have their own thoughts and feelings, while making their own choices and mistakes, are on the pathway to personal autonomy and self-responsibility. The fledgling Self learns from direct experience rather than external instruction and needs to mobilize its internal resources to take the helm. This doesn’t weaken the primary bond. On the contrary, it transforms the union into a developing relationship that nurtures the growth of both child and adult.

But striking this delicate balance between bonding and breathing room can be a perplexing challenge. Devoted parents often over-protect, permissive approaches can create abandonment and parents who vacillate between the two are likely to send the emerging Self into a tailspin. Then thereare those conscious and unconscious agendas parents have for their child – to be loving, obedient and happy before becoming a neurosurgeon. Not much breathing room here. Parents who are not aware of their expectations, options and choices will blindly pass on whatever they learned from their own experience of being parented. Not much ‘conscious parenting’ here. If this sounds a bit like Child and Youth Care practice, ignore the connection.

3. The Need for Attunement

The key to establishing an effective balance between bonding and breathing room is the parents’ ability to understand and respond to the subjective experience of the child. All children have a basic need to be seen and heard, and to be with caring adults who see and hear without judgment or conditions. At the most primal level this naturally occurs between a mother and baby where mother has her own secure sense of Self and baby basks in her unconditional love. Later this becomes apparent in the caregivers’ ability to understand and reflect, rather than direct, the child’s internal world through accurate ‘mirroring’. If the bond provides the glue, and breathing room creates the context, then attunement is the essential process that makes authentic relationships possible. There is no prescription that can bring this about, only the unconditional availability of one human being to another. Again, no reference to Child and Youth Care is implied.

So what if this is so? If there really are three fundamental needs underlying all the other developmental considerations, can the deprivations and interruptions of infancy be addressed later in life? Most theorists have argued that development occurs through specific stages that must be accomplished sequentially, and that omissions at one stage cannot simply be patched up later. Well here we are not talking about the usual physical and psychological developmental pathways; we are concerned with the emergence of the Self, and in this domain, the theories are less linear and the options more encouraging. While definitions may vary, the empirical view of the Self as a complex internal system that organizes and directs personal experience and learning has become widely accepted. The far-reaching research of Daniel Stern exemplifies this perspective and shows how this self-system is in place and highly active from birth onwards. For present purposes, the key point is that while the Self develops through identifiable phases, no phase ever closes down. In other words, all aspects of the Self remain open and responsive to new information that is effectively presented at subsequent points along the developmental continuum. This is wonderful news for those who believe that our potential for growth and change is never closed off through environmental circumstances. It’s also a pretty nice idea for those of us in the ‘people business’ who like to think we can be helpful.

Implications for Child and Youth Care Practice

I firmly believe that Child and Youth Care is the one profession that can lead the way in creating a needs-based approach with sustainable relational outcomes. This might sound overly ambitious for a ubiquitous group of self-defined “baby-sitters” that continues to question its role and validity in the scheme of things. I also believe that our only hope for survival on this planet is to learn how to relate to each other as curious and compassionate human beings and that this must begin through our relationships with our kids. And if that isn’t enough of a challenge, try renting a villa in Libya.Unlike other related professionals, most Child and Youth Care folks have the opportunity to bond through their direct involvement in the lives of young people, rather than through hourly sessions and predetermined interventions. The day-to-day interaction in residential settings provides ideal opportunities for bonding and, strange as it may seem, the most controlled environments can be the most conducive in creating interpersonal boundaries or breathing room. The reason is that these are relational processes that become more relevant and necessary as interactive conditions become more intense. By the same token, attunement becomes a very viable personal alternative to the impersonal intrusions and routines of institutional life.

For me, Child and Youth Care has always been about the development of Self through relationships and, for my money, no other profession can make this claim. Of course knowledge and skills are involved in establishing bonds, creating breathing room and enhancing attunement, but these are natural processes rather than remedial professional techniques. The key to effectiveness and sustainability is the degree to which the practitioner can draw from her or his sense of Self to meet a youngster at the contact boundary. In other words, Child and Youth Care is still in a position toside-step all the professional politics and posturing to go to the heart of the matter.

Conclusion

On the one hand, this is just another stab at the old problem of how Child and Youth Care might define itself as an identifiable profession. On the other, it calls for a complete redefinition of the object of the exercise. Is it radical or irresponsible to suggest that we should step off the ‘curative treadmill’ and go straight to the heart of the matter rather than join the others in alleviating symptoms and resolving problems? Can we still claim professional status if we unabashedly accept the role of surrogate parents addressing the needs of infancy? And, if we prove our point, will anybody listen to what we have to say? Well ...

Reference

Stern, D. (1985). The Interpersonal World of the Infant. New York: Basic Books

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App