CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 281 JULY 2022

Nine Reflective Practice Questions

Thom Garfat, Jessica Hadley and Andy Leggett

Effective Child & Youth Care (CYC) Practitioners are reflective practitioners: curious, wondering, inquiring of themselves (Phelan, 2004; 2007). The reflective CYC Practitioner is constantly asking themselves questions: Why am I doing what I am doing? What elements of context are impacting this interaction? What could I do differently? How am I feeling about what is going on? Constantly reflecting on their experiences and actions. Curiosity. Wondering. Reflection.

Without this process of reflection, the practitioner is simply reactive – reacting to whatever occurs without the reflection which would allow them to be responsive rather than reactive (Brendtro & Du Toit, 2005). In being reactive, the practitioner responds only to the behaviour presented rather than considering the context, the needs, and the meaning of the behaviour. In these cases, the practitioner does not consider the possible implications of their action. Reflective practitioners wonder constantly about their context and how that context impacts on their actions (Garfat, Freeman, Gharabaghi & Fulcher, 2019) and the implications of those actions. Reflective practitioners are responsive practitioners. Without reflection we are reactive.

Over our years of practice, teaching, and training. we have identified several questions on which the effective practitioner might be constantly reflecting. This short article identifies some of these and the authors encourage readers to identify other, important, reflective questions for the CYC practitioner.

How might what I am doing, or thinking of doing, impact the in-between between us?

In Relational CYC practice we are always focused on the in-between between us (Garfat 2008); the co-created reality (Peterson, 1988) we sometimes call ‘the relationship’. However, unlike traditional ‘relationship-based’ approaches, in Relational CYC practice we are concerned with the characteristics of the relationship itself (Garfat, 2008). Is it, for example, a place of safety, of fear, of learning, of pain, etc? We want, of course, for the in-between between us to be a place of relational safety (Garfat 2015, 2016) where risks can be taken and learning and development can occur in the interactions between self and other.

Because we are concerned with the characteristics of the in-between between us, we are constantly asking ourselves, “how is what I am doing, or thinking of doing, likely to impact on the in-between between us?” Will it help to enhance the feeling of safety? Will it make it a more threatening place? Will it encourage the development of a place of learning? (Garfat, Freeman, Gharabaghi & Fulcher, 2019). How might my actions impact on the characteristics of the in-between between us?

This constant question helps to keep us focused on the characteristics of the in-between and promotes intentionality in our actions (Garfat, Freeman, Gharabaghi & Fulcher, 2019).

I wonder what need of theirs is being met by this behaviour?

Relational CYC practice involves a focus on what we call a ‘needs-based approach’. With this focus, as we engage with a young person or notice their actions, we wonder ‘what need of theirs is being met by this behaviour?’ Are they seeking, for example, to meet their need for Belonging, Mastery, Independence or Generosity, to use the Circle of Courage framework (Brendtro, Brokenleg & van Bockern, 1990).

Often young people attempt to meet their needs through actions that are harmful or painful for themselves or others, and a needs-based approach suggests that if they can find a way to meet their needs in a less painful, more satisfying manner, the old behaviour will no longer be necessary as their new way becomes preferable to them (Garfat, Freeman, Gharabaghi & Fulcher, 2019).

This orientation helps us maintain a focus on the young person’s needs and supports us in being responsive to the need rather than reactive to the behavior. Remember, a reflective practitioner is a responsive practitioner.

As reflective practitioners (Winfield, 2005), we are constantly questioning, ‘I wonder what need of theirs is being met by their behaviour?’

I wonder what this means to them?

Meaning-making, or interpretation, is central to all our interactions with youth and others (Garfat, 2004). A person acts, we make meaning of their action and, based on that meaning, we act. Once we act, the other person goes through the same process. So, the process of interacting with others involves a cyclical process of action, meaning making, action, meaning making, action . . . While this process may not always be conscious, it is there, just the same.

And this holds true for us, and for the young people with whom we work.

To truly understand a young person’s response to us we must understand what our actions mean to them. To understand their actions, we do well to understand what it means to them, otherwise we only know what it means to us.

As reflective practitioners we are, therefore, constantly wondering what our actions mean to the young person and what their actions mean to us and to them. It is only through dialogue, self-reflection, and observation that we might answer these questions.

Thus, the question: “I wonder what this means to them?”

Why am I noticing what I am noticing and what am I missing?

We act based on what we notice (DLE, 2019) whether that noticing be of physical movement, noticing what is going on for me, noticing elements of context, or anything else. Noticing is a stimulus which prompts our reflections and, thus, our actions. We act only on what we notice.

However, it is impossible for anyone to ‘notice’ everything and different people notice different things. In a sense, our noticing limits our perceptions and often the factors which influence our noticing can serve as blinders to other things that are going on at the time. For example, if we, because of our previous experience, are on high alert to notice indicators of possible aggression we may fail to notice acts of kindness by a young person.

And, as reflective practitioners, we wonder why we are noticing that which we are noticing and, of course, “How is my previous experience influencing my noticing?”

So, we are constantly wondering “Why am I noticing what I am noticing and what am I missing?”

How are my own needs being met in what I am doing or thinking of doing?

We all have our own needs. And all our actions are directed towards meeting our own needs (See, for example, Garfat, 2002). However, this does not mean that meeting our own needs in working with youth, and others, is always a bad thing as is sometimes implied.

Indeed, in working with youth, meeting our own needs to be generous, to feel useful, to be meaningful may if carefully considered, be helpful and meaningful in working with others.

However, meeting our own needs to be in control, to be powerful or to stay safe, may not always be so.

Noticing what needs of our own are being met helps us to ensure that our actions are for the benefit of the young person, not just ourselves.

So, always we are asking the question “how are my own needs being met in what I am doing or thinking of doing?”

Am I being consistent with myself?

We all have our own beliefs about how change occurs or the process of change. We believe that one step follows the other and, through this process, we arrive at a new place where we (or other) act differently in the world.

We also all have a way of ‘being in the world’ which is our normal everyday way of being – the way we want to be or, at least, the way we are.

Yet, sometimes, and for a variety of reasons, we act differently than one might expect according to our beliefs and normal way of being.

Young people can tolerate differences between how people are – e.g., one person you can joke with, another you cannot. But what drives everyone crazy is when we are not consistent with ourselves – if I can laugh with you today, I expect to be able to laugh with you tomorrow – and if I cannot, then there is no consistency in my world, and it disturbs me. Consistency of self, across experiences with young people, is essential for their stability.

When interacting with young people we are always asking “Is this way of acting consistent with my beliefs and who I want to be in the world?” and “Will the young person experience me as being consistent?”

How does this moment fit with their overall goals?

One of the main features of Reflective CYC Practice involves ‘making moments meaningful’ (Garfat, Fulcher & Digney, 2019) and one way in which we make moments meaningful is in connecting the present moment to the overall / longer-term goals which we are working towards with the young people. To make moments meaningful we need to constantly hold these goals in mind as we engage, interact and intervene. Without doing so, we will engage with the young person and their actions only as it relates to the present moment and not to their future. Holding these goals in mind influences how we respond. For example, if a young person is acting in anger, we could simply respond to it as a behaviour that needs to be controlled or, keeping the longer-term goals in mind, we might see it as an opportunity to help the young person see how their actions impact on others.

Thus, we are always asking “How can I connect this moment with this young person to their overall goals?”

What is my intention / purpose here?

An important characteristic of Relational Child & Youth Care practice is ‘intentionality’ which means, essentially, that everything a Child and Youth Care practitioner does is done with a purpose (Molepo, 2005). As Ricks, (1992, p. 56) said, “the intentional involvement in intervention requires that the worker be thoughtful and have clarity of purpose in determining ‘what to do before doing it’”. This is a core principle of reflective CYC practice.

Thus, as we intervene, or prepare to intervene, we are constantly reflecting on “what is my intention here?”; “what to I hope to achieve with my actions?” or, simply, “what is my purpose in doing what I am doing, and will this action achieve the desired purpose?”

Am I prepared for this intervention?

One of the aspects of a CYC Intervention is preparation. And in ‘preparation’ we wonder if we are ready – and if the young person is ‘available’ for our intervention. We wonder … Am I physically well situated? Do I understand the connection between this moment and the future? Am I psychologically ready for the feedback which might come? Do I have alternatives available?”

All of this, essentially asks “Am I prepared for this intervention?” And if the answer is ‘yes’ we move forward. But if the answer to these many questions re preparedness is ‘no’ then we regroup and make a different decision. Because if I am not prepared it is very unlikely that my intervention will be effective.

* * *

All our engagements with young people and others benefit from a process of reflection. The foregoing has offered some questions which we have found to be helpful. This process of wondering, of being curious about the young person, ourselves, and our actions, is a characteristic of Reflective Child & Youth Care Practice. As mentioned, without reflection we are simply reactive.

References

Brendtro, L. K., Brokenleg, M., & Van Bockern, S. (1990). Reclaiming youth at risk: Our hope for the future. Bloomington, IN: National Education Service.

Brendtro, L. and du Toit, L. (2005). Response Ability Pathways: Restoring Bonds of Respect. Cape Town: Pretext Publishers.

DLE: The purposeful use of daily life events: Participants guide (2019). Cape Town: The CYC-Net Press.

Garfat, T. (2002). All behaviour serves a purpose. Cape Town: CYC-Online, 40 (May), np.

Garfat, T. (2004) Meaning-making and intervention in Child and Youth Care Practice. Scottish Journal of Residential Child Care, 3 (1), 9-16.

Garfat, T. (2008). The inter-personal in-between: An exploration of relational child and youth care practice. In Bellefueille, G. and Ricks, F. (Eds.) Standing on the precipice. Edmonton, Canada: MacEwan Press. pp. 8-9.

Garfat, T. (2015). Trauma, relational safety and a child and youth care approach. CYC-Online, 198, 4-5.

Garfat, T. (2016). Nudging the development of relational safety. CYC-Online, 213, 2-4.

Garfat, T., Freeman, J., Gharabaghi, K., & Fulcher, L. (2019). Characteristics of a Relational Child and Youth Care Approach. In T. Garfat, L. Fulcher, & J. Digney (Eds.), Making Moments Meaningful in Child & Youth Care Practice. 2nd Ed. (pp. 6–44). Cape Town, South Africa: The CYC-Net Press.

Garfat, T., Fulcher, L. & Digney, J. (2019). Making moments meaningful in Child & Youth Care practice. Cape Town: The CYC-Net Press.

Molepo, L. (2005). Working with youth and families affected/infected by HIV/AIDS within the South African reality. In T. Garfat, and B. Gannon (Eds.) Aspects of Child and Youth Care practice in the South African context. (pp. 63-74). Cape Town. Pretext Publishing

Peterson, R. (1988). The collaborative metaphor technique. Journal of Child Care, 3, 4. p. 11-28.

Phelan, J. (July, 2004). Curiosity for the mature child & youth care practitioner. CYC:OnLine, 66. n.p.

Phelan, J. (Feb. 2007). Curiosity and the ability to ask good questions. CYC OnLine: 97.

Ricks. F. (1992). A feminist's view of caring. Journal of Child and Youth Care, 7(2), 49–57.

Winfield, J. (2005). An exploration of reflection and reflective practice. In B. Gannon and T. Garfat (Eds.). Aspects of Child and Youth Care Practice in the South African Context. Cape Town: Pretext. 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App