CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 281 JULY 2022

Parental Rights

Hans Skott-Myhre

Last month I wrote about the status of the mental health system, citing a report by the World Health Organization that is very critical of the mainstream approaches being used in psychiatry and psychology. The report challenged these practices as violations of patient rights. As some of you, who may have read my writings on rights might know, I am dubious about the discourses of rights. In particular I am critical of the idea that rights are either universal or given by the state to its citizens. I have proposed instead that rights are only actual when they are produced by the actions of those seeking the freedom to be more fully who they are. In this sense, patient rights are only real when they are produced through the acts of those designated patients. Patient rights are produced through the struggles of those fighting for greater degrees of autonomy and appropriate non-intrusive levels of care. This form of rights was reflected in what I reported in my last column, in both the rights proposed in the WHO report and in the New York Times Article that chronicled networks of care established by psychiatric survivors and their allies. This is grassroots mobilizations of care that builds rights through collective action from the ground up.

Patient rights from this point of view would be driven by the patients themselves. Their allies would act in accordance with the desires and actions of those whose fight it is to change the conditions of their own oppression. From this perspective, it is important to note that a liberatory theory of rights cannot apply to those groups privileged by the system with inherent hierarchical force. Such groups often squabble amongst themselves as to who gets to have the greatest degree of force in a given set of social relations, but this should not be confused with a legitimate assertion of the right of action as living capacity.

Gille Deleuze and Felix Guattari offer us a framework to make some degree of sense out what can appear to a bit of muddle over force relations described in the language of rights. In their work, they make a distinction between what they term minoritarian and majoritarian modes of social identity. The majoritarian form of sociality is comprised of those subjects affiliated with the dominant ways of describing the world. That is to say, that the way in which the world is commonly described has an element of domination to it. In particular, our descriptions of each other, are saturated with power dynamics that tell us where we fit within the taxonomies and hierarchies of our society. Language as we use it almost without reflection, describes a world in which certain groups in society have the final say as what can and can’t be said and who has the right to speak. The outcome of this assertion of definitional dominance makes up what Deleuze and Guattari define as the majoritarian discourse. This way of describing the world holds within it a hierarchy of status that defines which groups are the majority. In our contemporary society, they argue that this is those identified as male. I would add white and heterosexual to their definition.

All other identities comprise what Deleuze and Guattari term minoritarian. It is important to note that minority is not a numeric term here. The minority is composed of those groups who struggle to have a definition of themselves that is not premised in a comparative relation with straight, white, men. The argument is that as long as the definitions are controlled by the majoritarian discourse, the numbers are deceptive. In terms of relations of power, it is not so much a question of who is the larger group as much as who defines the dominant discourse or is defined by that discourse. Minoritarian discourses that are developed by those in the minority are then, by definition, an exception and a challenge to the dominant discourse. This gets tricky when we deal with groups who see themselves as minoritarian, but whose discourse is a repetition and reassertion of the dominant discourse.

I was thinking about this in relation to an article I read recently about parental challenges to the introduction of a mental health clinic in a public high school. Of course, I am not necessarily excited about the colonization of young people’s lives by institutionalizing “mental health” within their school. That said, I wouldn’t necessarily be opposed if the clinic adopted some or all of the proposed practices found in the WHO report. I suspect, however, that this would be an unlikely turn of events and so I was initially put off by the idea of a mental health center in the high school.

That is until I read further and found that it was a group of parents who were opposed to the mental health center, but on grounds that couldn’t be further from my own. As I have noted, my concern is with the ways in which mental health can violate patient rights (in this case young people’s rights) and I wish I could say that the parental opposition was founded in a similar concern over the ways in which the center might violate their children’s rights. Unfortunately, this was not the case.

Instead, what I found was an unsettling and disturbing assertion of “parental rights” that was actually centered on restricting their children’s rights. There are two things happening here that I think are worth investigating. Before I do though, let me delineate what the parents feared might happen if the mental health center was instituted within the school. Tellingly their concerns echoed talking points from reactionary discourses such as those being distributed across the United States by groups committed to reshaping education so that it excludes any reference to race, sexual orientation, or reproductive health.

The parents who successfully blocked the clinic were of the opinion that having mental health professionals in the schools would interfere with what they perceived to be their rights as parents. For example, they were concerned that their children might be advised by school-based therapists on matters such as gender identity or birth control. One parent stated that, “I do personally believe that there are a lot of agendas out there and that children are malleable.” Of course, they were referring to other people’s agendas, not theirs as a parent. In this view, children should be malleable to parental authority, but not to their peers or alternate discourses, particularly on matters pertaining to any form of sexuality.

Other concerns had to do with a learning program called SEL which trains students how to manage emotions and practice conflict resolution. Like Critical Race Theory which has also come under attack and been successfully prohibited in K-12 education in the U.S.in a number of states (ironically k-12 never taught CRT), parents really don’t have any idea what SEL is or what it does. They just believe that no one other than themselves should be educating their children in areas having to do with conflict and emotional well-being.

These parents appear to be afraid of losing control if other adults or peers take any role in shaping their children’s social and emotional well-being. In this regard, parents who opposed the mental health center were also particularly concerned about the possibility that their children would have the right to seek therapy without parental consent for up to six sessions. The idea that young people might have any capacity for determining their own avenues of assistance without parental input was a complete anathema. As one schoolboard member put it, “I am not going to make it easier for kids to go around their parents . . . I don’t think we should be helping a kid to walk into a mental health facility in a school and say, ‘I’m thinking about an abortion, let’s talk about that,’ without the parents knowing, for up to six visits.”

It is important to note that the implementation of the mental health center in the high school was overwhelmingly supported by the students themselves. They testified at the school board hearing and took a poll amongst themselves which indicated almost unanimous support. The school board president diminished the importance of this advocacy by students on their own behalf stating in regard to the poll, “How do you know they were honest responses? They were dealing with kids.”

As I mentioned above, there are two elements to this story that I would argue are important to note. The first is the perversion of developmental discourse as a means of invalidating young people’s input on matters of importance in their own lives. For those of us working in CYC to work developmentally means to be cognizant of the ways in which we give full attention to the lived experience of a young person at a particular moment in their lives. It means not imposing our adult worldview on their experience. It should not be a means to enforce a majoritarian adult discourse as a means of social control in ways that invalidate the minoritarian perspective of the young person. Indeed, in many instances it is specifically the alternate discourse of youth that can inform and refresh our own perspectives in ways that reverse the calcification of our own free and creative discourse as we are inducted into majoritarian adult discourse.

That said, it is regrettably more common to deploy the frameworks of developmental discourse as a way of promoting and valorizing adulthood as a desirable end product. This viewpoint sets a hierarchy of experience, in which those of us who have reached a rather arbitrary age of majority, are designated adults and assume a superiority of judgement and cognitive capacity. In this view, adults have the necessary prerequisites to determine what is best for young people and to legislate what they have a right to do. As Erica Burman points out, there is perhaps no more powerful site for the dissemination of this adult discourse than the family. The deployment of parents as disciplinary agents of the dominant set of social norms is a powerful means of social control.

Kathleen Skott-Myhre points out the mainstream developmental discourse can also drive a wedge between parents and their children on key matters where they might actually have common ground. Certainly, mental health care might well appear to be just such common concern for parents and their children. The epidemic rates of depression, anxiety, self-harm, addiction, and other emotional and psychological struggles are not restricted to any particular age group. Our misery is a shared experience across adults and young people in the world we live in today. To split us along lines rather capriciously designated as adults and young people is truly self-defeating. It promotes greater degrees of unnecessary conflict and alienation at a time we need more relational affiliation and shared commonalities of purpose.

The discourses that are associated with parental rights are founded in a broader social movement premised in fear and resentment built out of a profound sense that the nuclear family is coming apart. Those with a heavy investment in the family as a site of patriarchal normativity are doing all they can to hang to a hierarchical system of privilege that associates parenting with white, heterosexual, masculinist modes of thought and practice. The battle over the mental health center, then, is less about young people’s well-being and mental health, and more about the raw assertion of privilege and power.

Which is why these parents are not fighting for rights. They are fighting for the ability to assert their traditional domination of young people in very fundamental ways. Earlier, I stated that the majoritarian discourse was centered on masculinity, heterosexuality, and whiteness. The opposition to the mental health center closely echoed these majoritarian forms of identity. The parents who opposed the center did so because it might open up alternate minoritarian identities for their children that would ally them with greater degrees of sexual freedom in both practices and identities, as well as challenge the masculinist set of practices that marginalizes and subverts our full range of emotional capacity.

In the past few days, the U.S. Supreme Court has asserted the majoritarian discourse that denies women the right to reproductive freedom. Kathleen Skott-Myhre in her work on development has drawn a clear correlation between the interests of women as a minoritarian set of alternative values and practices, and the political interests of those young people labeled adolescent. She argues that when women are inducted into the majoritarian developmental discourse associated with convention mothering under the patriarchal standards of the family, they lose their ability to see the commonalities of struggle they have with their children. This is tragic loss of possible political affiliation which could benefit both women and young people in resisting the ever-increasing fascistic impulse of the capitalist system in crisis. Women and young people are being targeted with the same set of majoritarian discourses and modes of subjection at all levels of society, from the Supreme Court to the local school board. If we in CYC don’t begin to pay attention and join in resisting this movement, it will be on our doorstep soon enough.

Foucault suggests in his work that there are sites in society that appear on the surface to be operating within the dominant coordinates of majoritarian modes of control. However, some of these sites hold within them alternative minoritarian modes of thought and practice that have revolutionary possibilities. He called these spaces heterotopias and I have suggested elsewhere that our CYC programs hold just such possibilities. Given the reactionary formation that greeted the possible introduction of a mental health center into the schools, perhaps such programs hold such hidden perversities as well. We can but hope so and seek such heterotopic spaces in which to work and develop new capacities for the assertions of actual rights by those who live them and act them in their daily lives. 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App