Over the past couple of years I have been thinking a lot about the difference between achieving specific individual level outcomes and generating social impact. To be sure, there are many perspectives on whether residential group care has ever produced positive individual level outcomes. Some research points to positive outcomes on balance, while other research suggests that notwithstanding many good scenarios, there are far too many difficult ones to view residential care as something that can reasonably be expected to produce good outcomes. For the purposes of thinking about social impact, let’s assume for a moment that overall, the individual level outcomes of residential care are generally good – I know that isn’t entirely true, but I don’t want to reproduce the longstanding debate about this modality of care here.
To clarify, by residential care I mean staffed, institutional, semi-institutional or community-based group care for children and youth, usually with a view to either reunify young people with family or kinship networks, or to help young people with a transition to some form of independent living. I am also thinking specifically about the global North in this context, understanding that residential care manifests quite differently in the global South and discussions about the role of residential care in the global South take account of quite different dynamics and political economies (see Islam and Fulcher’s excellent series on Residential Child and Youth Care in a Developing World, published by CYC-Net Press https://press.cyc-net.org). I also want to be clear that what follows is not a critique of residential care. Instead, it reflects some questions that might usefully be asked about what else is possible.
I do want to start with a basic premise. Overall, residential care has had very little impact on societal issues or dynamics. There may have been specific moments in time when it did; for example, in the immediate aftermath of World War II, when many young people were left orphaned or otherwise in a difficult position because of losing their parents. This is, in fact, how FICE International originated as an organization, responding to the overwhelming needs of young people impacted adversely by the War. Outside of such moments, however, none of the issues we address through residential care have diminished; quite to the contrary, virtually all these issues have expanded over the past few decades. For many communities, these issues are structural and systemic associated with poverty, racism, ableism, neuro-normativity, and other, much broader themes (including migration), as well as with responses to such issues through urban planning and local and national policies related to minimum wage, nutrition, public service provision, mental health, access to education and health care, and others.
In this sense, we can meaningfully speak to what I sometimes call the geography of misery, by which I mean that part of society that lives life in ways that allow the middle classes to largely ignore the ills of society. That geography of misery holds communities that are trapped in inter-generational poverty and exclusions from which it is very difficult to escape. All global North societies have these geographies, and sometimes we refer to these as the global South intruding into or overlapping with the global North.
An obvious observation of residential care in the global North is that we draw our ‘clients’ from this geography of misery. As it turns out, there is an endless supply, and we absorb individuals from this geography into our evidence-based and trauma-informed services. The reality is, however, that the scale at which we work with individuals is nowhere close to the scale at which the geography of misery unfolds. This means that the individuals we absorb are largely coincidental ‘clients’ who arrive in our services through the coincidence of their lives having triggered some sort of system response. In a best-case scenario, we do excellent work and the young people absorbed into our residential care facilities improve their prospects for good lives (recognizing that the term ‘good lives’ is highly subjective and filled with a priori assumptions about what constitutes the good life). By the time we discharge these young people, they may be able to sustain independent living arrangements, or perhaps they have reunified with their families or kinship networks. And when that happens, we replace them with other young people, and so the story goes, over and over again for different young people.
For me, the question is this: Does this process, even in its most positive construction, have any impact on societal issues or challenges? And related to that question, I ask: Does this process perhaps even perpetuate the societal issues and challenges it aims to address at an individual level? In other words, are we collectively better off because some young people are absorbed into the residential care system, where, if everything goes perfectly, they may experience improvements in their lives? Or is it possible that this system, by virtue of responding to those scenarios that trigger some form of public response (such as child abuse, for example), actually supports the continued neglect and exclusion, as well as the legitimation, of the geography of misery?
Answering this question is surprisingly difficult and raises all kinds of ethical questions. However, here is some food for thought that might stimulate a new discussion related to residential care. Five points seem worth making:
I am asking these questions as a way of stimulating new conversations. As everyone knows, I am not against residential care at all. However, I am conscious that we invest enormously into this system (even today, when the system is under pressure to give way to family-based care settings) and yet we appear quite complacent about the geography of misery that is the lifeblood of our residential care system. It is time, I think, to contemplate how we might have social impact rather than continuing on our path to generate individual-level outcomes that don’t seem quite prepared to tackle how life really works in the 21st century.