CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 281 JULY 2022

Boundaries and Children’s Rights in Child and Youth Care: A Brief Reflection

Flavia-Alessia Preci and Tara Collins

I (Tara) was an overnight camp counselor along with one other counselor (who shall remain nameless) to support different groups of 11- to 13-year-old girls for whom we were responsible over the summer years ago. One day one of these girls told me what had been happening after bedtime. The other counselor had been taking a number of the campers into the forest to smoke in an effort to be “their friend”. It was a shocking lesson about a boundary of care that I had assumed would never be crossed.

Boundaries can be clearly established and well-practiced in organizations and agencies to facilitate professional relationships that exist between a Child and Youth Care Practitioner (CYCP) and a young individual or a group of young people. There can be instances however when boundaries are not understood or respected in practice, as the aforementioned camp example illustrates. There are numerous instances when human rights (including the United Nations (UN) Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC), 1989) that establish important boundaries that have not been or are not respected. The indefensible legal forced removal of thousands and thousands of Indigenous children from their families, homes, communities, languages, cultures, and land for placement at residential schools in Canada, United States, and Australia, facilitated colonization and yet the majority of these country’s populations deemed such practices as within the boundary of children’s “best interests”! [1]

While the literature addresses boundaries in care, a gap is apparent in the discussion of boundaries in relation to children’s rights. What is the connection between children’s rights and how institutions, organizations and CYCPs create and upkeep their boundaries? What are some issues when professionals ignore boundaries or when boundaries are problematic for a young person? This short piece offers some questions and considerations, recognizing that a complete discussion of professional boundaries would likely need hundreds more pages.  We will not be focusing on one setting only, but rather an accumulation of experiences and information from varying aspects of care. We argue that children’s rights are overlooked when boundaries reflect the all-too-common understanding that adults know best. This problematic mindset leads to discrepancies in the integrity and respect of various boundaries (personal, professional, ethical/moral, institutional) and can also infringe children’s rights. How can the issues related to boundaries in child and youth care practice be reconciled from a children’s rights perspective? Moreover, we argue that greater collaboration between young people and CYCs is needed to overcome the many challenges and tensions posed by boundaries for children’s rights.

Boundaries are referred to as limit-lines (Davidson, 2004, 2009). They exist to maintain safety and wellbeing of both parties in relationships (Mann-Feder, 1999, 2003; Cooper, 2012). Boundaries create a framework that “sets parameters within which … services are delivered” (The College of Psychologists of Ontario, n.d., p. 1). They exist in numerous forms to facilitate care between CYCPs and children and youth. They can be supported by institutional rules and practices. Lack of action in setting and respecting boundaries may be unintentional and do not always suggest malintent. Boundaries may only be recognized and established reactively, only after they have already been ignored. These types of mistakes may assist adults and institutions to advance their learning as they come to terms with their impacts upon others. Boundaries are important to ensure the correct priorities in the professional relationship and avoid such issues as abuse and neglect of children and youth from which they have the right to protection (e.g., CRC a. 19). Some individual and groups of children are particularly vulnerable to such violations of their right to respect of their physical integrity and to be free from sexual exploitation including for instance children with disabilities (CRC a. 34, 23; UN, 2006, a. 7, 17).

Issues of privacy and culture are among the many issues that arise as maintenance and respect of boundaries are neglected because boundaries determine the protection and infringement of privacy rights. This pattern leads to inconsistency in care. The varying outcomes of practice have an intertwined relationship with CRC article 16(1), which affirms these rights from unlawful interference. Examples that need to be considered include locking up personal belongings and determining control over what personal information is shared between practitioners. Such actions (and others) can strip the young person’s sense of identity and belonging, and the outlets that may support their coping strategies. Further, debate is ongoing about whether discussing these issues among practitioners is needed for support of the child or is unnecessary.  In my experience (Flavia), there was a time when one young person who was reprimanded had been the subject of discussion among staff members in a school hallway, even though other students were present and could hear the sensitive conversation. This hallway discussion also included a staff member who was not involved in this young person’s care even though sharing this information with them was not pertinent or helpful. In this situation, the child’s rights to privacy were violated. This example highlights the critical role of perspective in terms of understanding and respecting boundaries. What may appear to be gossip or interesting information about a young person to one practitioner may also be interpreted by another practitioner as a critical discussion about the young person of concern to identify issues and potential interventions.

Consideration of culture is ignored too often. In some cultures, for example, individuals kiss on the cheek upon greeting, whereas individuals in North American culture often opt to shake hands. Some cultures prohibit all forms of physical touch in interactions between varying genders. Reflecting on my personal experience about this difference, I (Flavia) felt the contrast from being a student in Italy, where displays of affection were normal, and suddenly discovering that such affection was not practiced when I became a student in Canada. I continue to have fonder memories of my school years in Italy than Canada and this difference might be a factor. We recognize how some trauma may mean that such displays are unacceptable to some people. But if both parties collaboratively decide that displays of affection can be welcomed and safe, then the decision of boundaries in relation to displays of affection can reflect variation on a case-by-case basis. We might consider that children may not receive affection from other individuals in their life space and that care might be the only space where they feel appreciated and cared for by others. The lack of affection and expressions of appreciation might affect, complicate, or even invalidate some relationships between practitioner and young person.

Culture may also inform one’s conscious and/or unconscious biases in their professional efforts with children and their families. As a result, CYCPs must consider how non-discrimination (as provided in CRC a. 2) is respected in their practices and how this critical principle is informing (or not) decision-making with respect to marginalized children and families. For example, are biases influencing decisions to call the police for “help” in difficult situations with young people? Or what about when staff interpret and justify policies in a manner that lead to some groups of children in schools (but not others) to be labelled, stereotyped, targeted, as well as punished to far greater extents? Every such discriminatory decision causes harm for the young people and their families and violates children’s rights to respect.

Staff and young people may suffer the consequences of their personal boundaries being pushed, suggesting that boundary rules may be too loose in some cases. Boundaries need to protect children as well as others in interactions within a setting. In order to support their best interests, a professional might blur their boundaries for the sake of the young person. Child and youth care is anything but passive, however overinvolvement can infringe a practitioner’s safety. Overinvolvement can also lead to intrusive and controlling practice (Phelan, 2004). Both approaches neglect the needs of the young person and sustainability of care over time. It is up to the worker and the young person to find a working balance together. Professionals with balanced boundaries “actively use professional judgment, consistently apply self-reflection skills, and are intentionally accountable to other professionals” (Davidson, 2009, p. 9).

Collaboration is the goal. Young people must work together with the practitioners to set boundaries in a way that promotes safety of both parties and upholds their rights. Collaboration is teamwork and must prioritize youth centeredness. This entails “being together for the whole process, making room for others to speak and share ideas, and collaborating effectively to get things done” (Michener, 2022, p. 5). Through collaboration together, efforts can be made to facilitate young people’s understanding about boundary setting as a skill. Such learning will inform the care they are currently receiving, as well as support their development.  If this approach is taken in practice, the benefits of collaboration will feature a healthy and sustainable upkeep of boundaries between the professional and those receiving care.

To support collaborative efforts in creating and setting boundaries, children and youth would benefit from education not only about children’s rights to empower them in relationships with others as well as this topic of boundaries. How can young people learn what is okay and what is not okay in respect to boundaries? How can they learn to speak on their needs? Since they are implicated, young people must have roles to make decisions in collaboration with professionals that support their rights as human beings to culture, agency, and belonging. We recognize that boundary rules exist to protect all members in a professional interaction, but it is important to consider the benefits of collaborative decision-making in respect to these rules.

Furthermore, the young person’s evolving capacities develop over time and require caregivers provide “appropriate direction and guidance” (as per CRC article 5) but should not suppress the child’s role in the process and exercise of their rights to support developmental opportunities and engagement. Young people should have the power to set these limits, which will make it easier for all parties involved in a relationship to respect the boundaries that are set. Through collaboration, young people learn to set their own boundaries, which can help inform the boundaries that they set in other areas of their life space, including with their peers. Taken together then, this effort supports their rights to education and safety, and develops a tangible skill that will benefit their development as well as relationships with others.

Constraints to collaboration feature power imbalances between authorities and youth people, pushback, and isolation. Power imbalance can make it difficult for collaboration to be successful. Young people might feel uncomfortable in voicing their needs (e.g., The College of Psychologists of Ontario, n.d.). Alternatively, they might instead show anger and disinterest towards collaborative efforts. We must consider that their boundaries have been crossed in the past, and young people have lost trust and sense of safety. Another challenge exists when practitioners may be isolated in their efforts to make collaboration happen. Other colleagues might be too busy, don’t know you, or don’t care to support this process. How can one person change the system’s practices?

In conclusion, our goal as practitioners should be to overcome a significant barrier of the general lack of awareness about children’s rights. Children's rights provide a framework that others can understand and a foundation for collaboration between young people and practitioners to overcome the many challenges and tensions posed by boundaries. Such issues related to privacy, culture, non-discrimination, and education are among the many rights to which young people are entitled and are directly connected to the limits placed upon young people when receiving care. These limits or boundaries set by institutions are often disconnected from young people and their needs. While boundary rules are set within a professional environment with the intention of keeping a young person safe but may serve the institution more than the young person and may fail to consider the extent to which these rules affect their development (Hart, 2017). As a result, boundary rules should be explored and developed further in our practices not only by CYCPs. Children and young people must be included in these decision-making processes, and practitioners must act in their best interests and respect their other rights. Given the diversities of young people, and their rights to participate, collaborative efforts support the idea in practice that boundaries are not one size fits all even if they are presented and positioned as such.

References

The College of Psychologists of Ontario. (n.d). Professional Boundaries in Health-Care Relationships. https://cpo.on.ca/wp-content/uploads/Professional-Boundaries-in-Health-Care-Relationships.pdf

Cooper, F. (2012).  Professional Boundaries in Social Work and Social Care. Jessica Kingsley Publishers. https://www.respitenow.com.au/uploads/3/9/0/3/39035687/boundaries_for_carers.pdf

Davidson, J. C. (2004). Where do we draw the lines: Professional relationship boundaries and child and youth care practitioners. Journal of Child and Youth Care Work, 19, 31-42.http://acycpjournal.pitt.edu/ojs/jcycw/article/view/366/350

Davidson, J. C. (October, 2009). Where do we draw the lines: Professional relationship boundaries and child and youth care practitioners. CYC Net. https://cyc-net.org/cyc-online/cyconline-oct2009-davidson.html

Hart, P. (2017). The reality of relationships with young people in caring professions: A qualitative approach to professional boundaries rooted in virtue ethics. Children and Youth Services Review, 83, 248-254. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.childyouth.2017.11.006

Mann-Feder, V. R. (1999). You/me/us: Thoughts on boundary management in Child and Youth Care. Journal of Child and Youth Care 13(2), pp 93-98

Mann-Feder, V. R. (2003) . You/me/us: Thoughts on boundary management in Child and Youth Care. CYC Net. https://cyc-net.org/cyc-online/cycol-1003-you-me-us.html

Michener, C. (2022). RELATIONSHIP – The Practice of Child and Youth Care. Fleming College. https://wpflemingcollege.com/childandyouthcarepractice/relationship/

Phelan, J. (2004;2003;). Child and youth care family support work. Child & Youth Services, 25(1-2), 67-77. https://doi.org/10.1300/J024v25n01_05

Truth and Reconciliation Commission (2015). Honouring the Truth, Reconciling for the Future: Summary of the Final Report of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada, https://ehprnh2mwo3.exactdn.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/Executive_Summary_English_Web.pdf

United Nations (UN) (1989). Convention on the Rights of the Child, UN Doc. A/RES/44/25, http://www2.ohchr.org/english/law/pdf/crc.pdf

United Nations (UN) (2006). Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, UN Doc. A/RES/61/106, https://www.un.org/development/desa/disabilities/convention-on-the-rights-of-persons-with-disabilities/convention-on-the-rights-of-persons-with-disabilities-2.html

[1] For more details about Canadian experiences and impacts for example, see Truth and Reconciliation Commission (2015).

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App