Alignment between the philosophical values of Child and Youth Care and the methods we use in the delivery of our educational curriculum is critical. This article provides reflections and practical strategies for integrating relational practice into the classroom and nurturing reflective Child and Youth Care practitioners.
Keywords
Relational practice, responsive
learning, relational teaching, safety in learning, sustainability,
situational experiences, academic institutions
Imagine a learning atmosphere that enhances engagement to the point where students don’t want to miss a thing. Away with the days where learners sit on a cold hard chair, behind a wooden tabletop desk, facing the front of the room while an ‘expert’ takes their place reading from slides, regurgitating what was already heard as a result of assigned readings.
Academic institutions are in a state of re-grouping, being progressive, attempting to create a constructivist learning environments (Jonassen, 1991). They are striving to assist the learner to reach self-authoring levels of critical thinking (Kegan, 1982). They build curriculum, bottom up using the Structure of the Observed Learning Outcomes (Biggs & Collis, 1982). They teach progressively through Bloom’s Expanded and Revised Taxonomy (Anderson & Krathwohl, 2001). The training room, while still sterile in color, is modified so that the moveable chairs and desks form a U shape. No one’s back is to that of another individual. Flipped classrooms (Bergmann & Sams, 2012) are the trend; where learners come prepared for class having pre-read all materials and ready to play with the application of the most difficult concepts. Learners participate in large or small group reflective discussions every 10-15 minutes and at least one interactive activity for every 60 minutes of session. Learners are allowed choice in how they complete some assignments, using their creativity to build their professional identity. As a result, they come away with depth and breadth of knowledge and practice skills.
As academia moves forward by meeting the needs of learners in these new ways, we’ve seen disparities and incongruence within our learners' identity formation. If not directly addressed, this discrepancy has the potential to cause impairment in ability to practice, dramatically reducing chances of post-graduate success. This disjointedness seems to come from the ecology of our learners, which appears to be increasingly toxic and elder deprived. A majority of them appear in our education rooms with personal trauma histories, potential mental, cognitive, emotional or physical health difficulties, familial stressors, financial distress, or other, just as significant, concerns that add challenge in participating in postsecondary education. The American College Health Association (2016) surveyed 25,168 Ontario post-secondary learners in the spring of 2016 using the ACHA National College Health Assessment II. Their results highlight increasing student stress states:
While colleges do their best to manage the impact of this stress (offering counseling, mindfulness sessions, brokering services, etc.) the fact is that these individuals spend most of their time (upwards of 20-25 hours per week) within their specific programs. Thus, faculty is positioned in a way in which connecting, caring for and eliciting safety is crucial. Hobbs (1974) suggests that “no one waits for a special therapeutic hour. We try, as best we can, to make all hours special. We strive for immediate and sustained involvement in purposive and consequential living (p. 393)”.
Under these conditions, we hypothesize that learners wouldn’t hesitate to take significant risks in their plight for congruency of professional and personal.
Relational Learning
Child and Youth Care (CYC) teachings are grounded in the concept of relational care. The context of our work occurs in relation to, and with, others (Bellefeuille & Ricks, 2010). However, some learners may not have experienced this type of caring in their own upbringing, or haven’t felt it in quite some time, and this may add additional layers of learning when then attempting to apply program knowledge in practice. In our CYC program we want emerging practitioners to be able to support a different way of being in the world with the young people with whom they work, through the relationship they develop with them. If our learners have not experienced themselves in a different way, they may struggle with both understanding and applying relational care within their practice. Often learners can recount what they are to do, but they often struggle to actually do it. A barrier may be the wall they’ve built around themselves as protection from pain, as we see in their hesitancy to be present and engage with others. Similar to the children, youth and families they hope to work with, some learners' private logic reflects either a hide or be hurt (i.e. flight), or that of hurt or be hurt (i.e. fight) mentality (Adler, 1969; Chambers & Freado, 2015). This private logic has helped them survive potentially harmful events within their world. However, as they move forward with fostering a professional CYC identity, it may impair their abilities to practice new knowledge of relational care due to a potential reluctance to experience further rejection or hurt. In essence, they are wounded (Phelan, 2009).
We have a duty as educators to meet our students ‘where they are at’ (Garfat & Fulcher, 2011), just as we would the children, youth, and families with whom we might practice. By inserting Hobbs (1982) principles of Project Re-Ed into our classrooms, we specifically target the student’s unmet need for belonging and well-being, if our faculty meets Hobbs (1966) criteria:
… a decent adult; educated, well trained; able to give and receive affection, to live relaxed, and to be firm; a person with private resources for the nourishment and refreshment of his own life; not an itinerant worker but a professional through and through; a person with a sense of the significance of time, of the usefulness of today and the promise of tomorrow; a person of hope, quiet confidence, and joy; one who is committed to children and to the proposition that children who are emotionally disturbed can be helped by the process of reeducation (p.105).
Hobbs’ principles (1982) are as follows. However, note we have replaced ‘child/adolescent’ with the word ‘learner’ and the word ‘adult’ with the term ‘faculty’:
The application of these principles leads to opportunities for learners to create new associations of safety in relationship with others. They support both independent and inter-dependent identity to be nurtured and developed. When learners experience a sense of community with its own capacity of healing, helping and mentoring they may then be able to replicate CYC program knowledge of being cared for in relationship with others with whom they work.
Responsive Learning Environments
There are several concepts that can help modify a post-secondary CYC college program experience to be a better fit with our learners' developmental needs as well as CYC professional practice and values. We like to think of our role in post-secondary education as “building training rooms with heart” (Curry, Lawler, Schneider-Munoz & Fox, 2011). By doing so, we support the deeper connection to the material and to practice. The holding environment (Winnicott, 1945) and/or containments (Bion, 1962) should be responsive to unmet needs, mediating stressors to build positive narratives all the while gradually reducing dependency. They should include Maier’s (1979) core ingredients of care: bodily comfort, differentiations, rhythmic interactions, elements of predictability, dependability and caring of the caregiver. Thus, it is our goal to build CYC family where learners feel held, supported and challenged because the premise of human experience is emotional, not just cognitive. Regardless of our unique challenges, all people feel. It is our responsibility as educators to facilitate emotional learning in diverse ways via lived experience in our training spaces. It is through facilitating responsive learning environments that we believe sustainable learning occurs. We should be asking ourselves, how do we make this moment meaningful for the learner and for ourselves? In doing so we inhabit the inter-subjectivity of our practice as well as offering critical care experiences to our learners.
The Role of Safety in Learning
Felt safety, which refers to an individual’s need for emotional security within a relationship, may begin with the incorporation of extended time to foster the relationship between students and faculty. Attending to the personal, the emotional needs of students are vital in creating a sense of safety and security. Open door policies, office hours, and before/after class connections are enhanced with the use of regular ‘hang outs’ (Garfat and Fulcher, 2011) independent of credit hours. These gatherings can take place in the physical academic and non-academic spaces as well as in the virtual space (through closed Facebook intake groups, twitter time, etc.). We are working on creating covenants in each course to share power in the building of norms as well as content specific opening/closing rituals and routines. In earlier semesters risk taking is buffered with instant access to peer support through the use of such mechanisms as time in/out role-plays, whereas in later semesters risk includes giving/receiving constructive feedback on individualized performance. Overall learner workload is managed with oversight so as to ensure outcome-based assignments that are limited in number and separated in submission timelines. Emotional regulation is taught early on so it can then be reinforced and evaluated through doing activities where practice occurs during high stress periods within a semester. We are also starting to plan for failure as our best learning can come from these moments. Hanging-in (Garfat & Fulcher, 2011) while a student sits with the discomfort that arises when they become or are made aware of their own incongruences between personhood and their learning is a necessity. Students who might not be in the right state to move forward step out of their course work but are provided with opportunities to remain program connected.
Spatial Co-Design
We are exploring alternatives to spatial design of the classroom (yes, this may take a little more time to set up, but if the benefits and experiences outweigh the time needs, it is well worth it). Faculty are beginning to re-organize learning spaces in conjunction with students so there is a consensus on what works best for the group in the different moments that arise. We have created a supplies list that includes a variety of seating choices such as rocking, balance and beanbag chairs as well as hard surface items like yoga mats, carpets, etc. Taking the time to construct teaching spaces together provides an opportunity to learn more about the individual feelings as well as group dynamics of a class.
Engaging in co-creation of physical spaces provides active opportunity to demonstrate characteristics of relational practice which faculty can refer back to throughout their teaching.
Instilling Passion and Sustainability
In our program, we have given special attention to creating a diverse and complementary faculty team so as promote both the uniqueness of experiences in our field and a multitude of authentic connections to it. Teaching that which we are most passionate about allows our faculty to transmit relationship and investment with discipline content and demonstrate competence, complexity, and sustainability of career within CYC practice. Through this varied exposure, learners receive opportunities to explore where their own passions might lie. This can be harnessed in both faculty and learners through their active role in on-going personal and professional development plans. In our program we re-visit these plans, often consisting of goals related to four different categories: self-care, self-growth, knowledge, and skills. These categories nurture the growth and development of both personal and professional identities, supporting the integrative nature of these parts of Self. We also request that our students take into account lifespace strengths and barriers as well as Redl & Wineman’s (1952) surface management techniques to help stay on course. Regular check-ins on these plans are crucial to determine if an individual needs to be more realistic, hasn’t acknowledged something getting in their way or if assistance might be needed from others. Involving others in such plans is essential as interdependence may help us to be responsible when we have to adapt based on feedback and provide tangible evidence of outcome.
Cultivating the peer community helps extend this focus on continuous learning and growth. As part of placement experiences, learners are put into small groups of seven along with one faculty. We refer to these as pods because the expectation is that the individuals work harmoniously in support to move across their semester. Those that have more give more and those that need more take more with the idea that this should balance out to a 50:50 ratio over the course of each term. In the first placement, faculty model pod facilitation while in the second placement learners try this on and by third placement, the pods become self-authoring. To move this experience beyond campus, it is important that we also help learners first connect with external resources and networks. We are aware that not all alumni stay in our region, nor do they progress at the same pace following graduation. With this in mind, we try to encourage program faculty to be active in the CYC world and share these connections with their learners by bringing in guest speakers, creating awareness about external events and encouraging participation in them as well as virtual gathering through CYC-Net.
Throughout a learner’s formal education, they cover a vast amount of content and it can be overwhelming – especially, when they are still in the developmental stage of worrying about themselves (Phelan, 2012). The glue that seems to allow them to take the time necessary to integrate this into identity, while creating confidence at graduation, is the use of a common and consistent language while a learner has been on site. By embedding the characteristics of a CYC approach (Garfat & Fulcher, 2011) across curriculum it serves as a form of grounding for early practice. This is enhanced when all program assessments also evaluate based on the domains of practice (Stuart, 2013).
The Modeling and Practice of the In-Between Space
It is rare that faculty would co-facilitate the whole of a course. For a variety of systemic reasons, it usually cannot or does not occur. However, our most recent experience has reinforced how beneficial sharing the space is for both students as well as faculty, suggesting that it promotes greater congruence and ‘matching’ with CYC practice.
By engaging in co-facilitation students witness the dialectical presence and relationship of two practitioners and the negotiation of shared space between them and with students in the class. We can demonstrate presence and rhythmicity (Krueger, 2000) as well as trust and vulnerability at engaging in the in-between space, the space of connected and co-created experience (Garfat, 2012), as we share in the art and practice of teaching. Sometimes students may forget that faculty are human too and make mistakes. One great benefit of co-facilitation is the noting of our errors to each other as well as to the class; in doing so, we get ‘unstuck’ while demonstrating the significance of being genuine, honest and imperfect – all characteristics important in negotiating the forever fluid landscapes of our relationships with others.
Storytelling that Speaks to Being Human – Showing Vulnerabilities
Storytellers have disseminated our histories, myths, collective and individual truths, since the dawn of time. Each profession has its own narratives and storytellers. The sharing of stories evokes feelings and has the ability to impact identity; challenging perceptions and private logic that people may have. Sharing our personal experiences is an act of vulnerability. When we risk vulnerability, we have the potential to build trust, safety and connection to others. Storytelling has the potential to increase self-control and competence, as facilitators can link skills and knowledge demonstrated in the story to domains of practice.
Sharing stories from practice also reaffirms that faculty are human, have made mistakes, are imperfect and have experienced ‘not knowing’ (Anderson-Nathe, 2010). The stories of facilitators can ‘bring to life’ tougher concepts which students may be struggling with, offering an alternative route to understanding and application. The effective use of stories may also cultivate different feelings for individuals and for the larger group.
Thus, facilitators share to enhance both individualized learning and also that of the group, paying attention to both the general and specific goals of the members.
Improvisation and Situational Experiences
Within our program, we focus on mirroring the mode of practice and “aim for the felt experience of the learning situation” (Ward, 2010, p.184). Making use of the everyday events (rituals, routines and events) in the lives of our learners promotes and demonstrates the effective use of lifespace, and the embodiment of CYC practice in an academic setting. We can use naturally occurring events, such as someone coming unprepared for the tasks at hand, or created events, such as forced group work. To take advantage of all the little moments that make up learning, we encourage the use of a professionalism and engagement mark assigned to each course. Professionalism rubrics would measure presence through dress, preparedness, teamwork, use of supervision, communication skills, ethical practice and willingness to work on self, while engagement rubrics would look to assess contribution, bi-directional caring, and inclusive practice.
Students are encouraged to keep daily notes to document how they demonstrate and participate in weekly course content, submitting a self-evaluation including ‘proof’, to support their grade. Faculty take notes and provide constructive on the fly feedback but also formalize comments at mid and final points based on a rubric clearly laying out performance expectations. At those times, if students are concerned, they are encouraged to speak to their faculty about their concerns and how to improve their marks. Often when we first introduce the professionalism and engagement mark, we are met with reluctance as those who are more gregarious discover they will need to make space for others, while individuals who are more reserved learn that they will need to take more space. While we appreciate both types of individuals, we challenge learners to think back to how relationships are developed and grow. Respectful engagement is a necessary component and this method encourages and supports learners to be more cognoscente of their moment-to-moment interactions with and impact on others.
Conclusion
By matching the classroom to the complex needs of the practice environment, along with the processes of practice, educators can promote “true caring [which] largely reflects the mutuality of care received and care rendered” (Maier, 1979, p.9). As Angelou’s (2002) poem reminds us, “people will forget what you said, people will forget what you did, but people never forget how you made them feel”.
References
See PDF for a full reference list.
Originally published in Relational Child and Youth Care Practice, 30, No.1, pp131-142.