I have been reflecting on the ways that capitalist logic saturates our daily lives and loves. The ways in which our core values are infiltrated by the logic and value of capitalism until predatory behavior becomes almost second nature. By capitalist logic, I am specifically thinking of the ways in which capitalism shapes what we value both behaviorally and conceptually. In other words, I am wondering how we ascribe value to things, people, and other species as well as how that influences how we treat them. I would suggest that capitalism offers us a fairly limited lens for ascribing such values.
Capitalism, as the name suggests, is a system premised on the accumulation of capital i.e. profit or wealth by private individuals. The driving impetus of capitalist value is the ability to ever increase the capacity of the private property to increase wealth. As a result, investments are premised on a logic that puts the development of profit over any other system of value. Put simply, it means that capitalism will put profit ahead of any other set of social relations including the comfort or well-being of living things. While capitalism is not opposed to meeting the needs of all living things, those needs will always be met after the accumulation of wealth is accomplished or likely. We can see this in the ways in which we as a society promote the accumulation of trillions of dollars in the hands of private individuals, while refusing to fund relatively small amounts of money for CYC services, schoolbooks or clean drinking water.
Because we live in a thoroughly capitalist milieu, the logic of the system influences us in a myriad of different ways. Some of these influences are obvious. Others are more subtle and operate at an almost unconscious level. For example, it is fairly common for us to have our self-worth tied up with our ability to have a “good job” and to be able to “support ourselves.” For many of us, this is a deeply rooted value. We feel increasingly good about who we are, if we are gainfully employed at a relatively high rate of compensation. We like to be seen as a hard worker who is responsible to the requirements of our job. If we lose our job or our ability to support ourselves, it can be very hard on our sense of our self as a worthwhile person. We can become depressed, anxious, and sometimes self-destructive if we are not economically self- sufficient.
Similarly, many of us are a bit suspicious of our fellow citizens who are unemployed or not economically successful according to our values. As a society we have, at the very best, an ambivalent relationship with people who struggle economically. For those who have experienced generations of economic insecurity, we hold both sympathy for their struggle, while at the same time too often describing them as unmotivated or lazy. On the one hand, we see the suffering of children living in poverty and cry out against a society that would treat its children in such a way. On the other hand, we scold their parents and adult family members for not climbing the ladder of meritocracy or pulling themselves up by their own bootstraps. Surely, if we have made it through our own struggle, we think, so can they.
In a way, the poor make us nervous. We know in the back of our minds (or maybe even more consciously) that our own economic position is actually fairly precarious if we are among the majority that relies on the movements of capitalist investments. Depending on what the current trend is in making money, any sector of the economy could be abandoned on short notice and any number of us could lose our livelihoods. We have seen this time and time again over the past four hundred years, but we don’t really need to look that far back. The economic collapses and rapid reversals of the late 20th and early 21st century offer us a plenitude of examples. The gig economy and the rise of the entrepreneur are premier examples of an economy that is highly variable, unstable, and incredibly risky. In fact it is more like a casino than a functioning social system.
And so, the poor make us nervous and we don’t like things or people that make us nervous. Of course, the capitalist economy also makes us nervous, but we really can’t relate to an impersonal system like capitalism, which in may respects seems completely beyond us, even if it directly organizes our daily behavior. And so, for many of us, we remain agnostic on how much we do or don’t dislike capitalism or capitalists. They are simply too alien and removed from our lived experience.
But the poor are much more accessible to us. They are who we must not become and we fear and hate them for this reason. We seek out ways of assuring ourselves that whatever made them poor is not something that will make us poor or homeless, or addicted, or crazy. And so we tell the stories about how the poor are lazy, unmotivated, damaged, criminal, or mad. Because these are qualities that we can resist in our selves. We can work harder, we can take motivational seminars on-line, we can seek therapy for our trauma, we can stay within the law, we can take our medications to manage our depression, anxiety, or rage. We can behave like people who are middle class and safe from poverty.
It is striking how pervasive this kind of logic is. Our willingness to subject ourselves and our sense of self to a system that would divide us and pit us against one another is a certain kind of madness. Of course, we don’t logically think these sets of relations in the ways I have described them here. In fact, if confronted with the argument I have just made, many of us would argue strongly that our logic is our own and the conclusions that we draw are based on real world experience.
What we fail to realize is that all our observations about the world we live in are filtered through the lens of the society that has produced us. We are trained in innumerable ways to think and act in accordance with the way that our society makes sense of the world. This is nowhere more true than in the world of social relations.
When we say that CYC is built on relationships, we might want to be quite careful about what kinds of relational logic are at play in our CYC engagements. I would argue, that it is quite likely that however well-intentioned we might be, we tend towards purveying and replicating capitalist logic in all of our relational engagements. Of course, we can and do work quite hard to cut through the social logic that saturates our world view. We might well point out that many of us in the field of CYC are well versed in social justice theories and practices. Our view of the poor is a liberatory one. We seek to be allies to the poor, disenfranchised, and marginalized groups in our society.
But, how many of us can put aside the logic of hard work and meritocracy even in our advocacy for social justice? And how many of us can have a relationship that is not premised in emotional or psychological profit? Indeed, I would argue that the logic of profit runs deep under the surface of our relational engagements. One way this is talked about overtly is in the psychological framework of social exchange theory. This theoretical framework comes from the field of psychology, which I have argued in other columns, here and elsewhere, is deeply intertwined with capitalism and one of the main vehicles for disseminating the logic of the system. In this case, the idea is that it is human nature to seek out relationships that offer us a positive “cost-benefit.” That is to say we measure the effort we put into a relationship against the rewards we receive from that relationship. I would argue that this view of human relations is neither natural nor human nature, but an effect of living within the frameworks of capitalist logic.
Remember that I proposed that capitalism is a system of value. I borrow that idea from Karl Marx who saw value as central to the way capitalism functions. For Marx, what is fundamental to human nature is the capacity to act and create, The act of creation in and of itself has no inherent value except in the enjoyment we receive from our ability to be creative. And we create an infinitude of productive acts. Some of these are physical innovations in which we alter the material world in an immeasurable number of ways, and some are relational in which we create connections and alter our neuro-biology through our entanglements with others. In either case, the fundamental value of social engagement according to Marx is to enhance our ability to do as much creatively as possible. This kind of value he called “use value.” That is the value of an activity is immanent to its own effects. In other words, use value is the pleasure we get from producing, creating, and acting. Certainly, one way to organize society would be to set it up so that we are as free as possible to express our capacities to their full extent. Indeed, Marx described a perfect communist society as,
where nobody has one exclusive sphere of activity but each can become accomplished in any branch he wishes, society regulates the general production and thus makes it possible for me to do one thing today and another tomorrow, to hunt in the morning, fish in the afternoon, rear cattle in the evening, criticize after dinner, just as I have a mind, without ever becoming hunter, fisherman, shepherd or critic.
We might note that there is no cost/benefit analysis as to how social relations are arranged. Society regulates the way things are produced so as to provide the maximum degree of possible expression by it citizens.
Under capitalist logic such as exchange theory, we have a different set of values. Here we have what Marx described as exchange value. To open the possibility of exchange value we have to take use value and add something to its inherent value. After all, my enjoyment of what I do is not something I can exchange with you for something you have that I want. My enjoyment of an activity is mine and is limited to the duration of the event or activity I am involved in producing. To exchange it, I have to add an additional value to my production. That is to say I need to create an abstract cost or benefit beyond my sheer pleasure. In other words, I am moving from a system that inherently values human activity, to a system that places variable value on some forms of human creativity and not others. This shifts the question from, what can I do to express my unique capacities as a human being, to what are my activities worth to other people? Will others value what I am a capable of doing or will they insist that I do other things that they have determined are valuable?
This is particularly powerful as a lens for understanding emotional entanglements. To the degree we are invested in social exchange or capitalist logic, we look to see how our relationships offer us an emotional profit. That is to say, we want others to make us feel better and better. If they fail to do this, then under social exchange logic, we should seriously question the cost/benefit of the relationship.
I would argue that this is a truly pernicious view of human relations that is deeply influential in complex and problematic ideas about self-care and burnout. The logic of emotional exchange is built on the idea that there should an emotional profit to human relations, but under that is another idea, This largely unconscious motivation is the sense that we are at core missing something and that through our relations with others we can fill that emptiness up. This kind of drive can create a voracious appetite for emotional exchange that cannot help but fail. Such failure drives us from failed relationship to failed relationship, always looking for that person or persons who can fill us up. I would suggest that this underlies the logic of burnout when it is premised on the idea that one can be emptied of emotional reserves by encounters with trauma and pain.
The alternative logic to the idea of emotions as a field of exchange with costs and benefits, winners and losers, might be found in the work of the philosopher Spinoza. He suggests that we are not empty, nor can we be emptied, because we are inherently entangled with the force of all living things. When we artificially bound ourselves off from others because we are afraid we will lose or win something in the game of emotional exchange, we diminish our access to the infinite energy of life itself.
Spinoza suggests that emotions are not things that we have and can exchange, Instead, emotions are degrees of experiential intensity that indicate a possible movement between who we are and who we might become. To the degree we try to own them and contain them for resale to another in exchange for what we imagine others might have to offer, we lose the some of the capacity to fully express who are becoming. And it is who we are becoming that is signaled by the intensity of feelings we are experiencing. This is not unlike the moment that precedes any other act of creation. The moment before we write the first word of a poem, make the first brush stroke of a painting, make the first cut on lumber for a building project. In that moment there is an intensity of possibility, of what might now happen. Relational entanglements can also open us to the full intensity of the free interchange of emotions without cost or benefit. Just the use value of seeing what can happen here. Spinoza refers to this as joy and in CYC, I think we can all use a bit more joy.