CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 269 JULY 2021

Re-Naming Child and Youth Care Practice

Kiaras Gharabaghi

Although it’s been a fairly quiet debate, there have been, for some time now, many voices in our field who have expressed discomfort with the field’s name. The term child and youth care, unlike the name of other professions, is not a term used everywhere; in fact, it really has currency primarily in a handful of countries, notably Canada, South Africa, and to a much lesser extent in places like the United States, Australia, Israel, and a few others. This is quite different than Social Work, for example, which is a broadly understood term across much of the world, both in the global North and in the global South; or the term Social Pedagogy, which at least has currency across much of Europe and South America. In Canada, where I live, the term child and youth care is quite ubiquitous. It is used both to describe a professional practice and it is the name of the academic discipline one can study at college or university to engage in that practice. Most provinces in Canada have a professional association that uses the term as well, and there are at least some journals that I am aware of that have the phrase child and youth care in their name: One is called Relational Child and Youth Care Practice, another is Child & Youth Care Forum, and in South Africa, there is the journal of the National Association of Child Care Workers called Child & Youth Care Work. There used to be another journal based in the US by the same name, but it seems to have disappeared in recent years, or at least I have not come across it for some time. And then there is CYC-Net and CYC-Net Press, which at least use the acronym for child and youth care in their names.

Over the years, debates in Canada about the name of the field have been somewhat muted, but nevertheless re-emerge at regular intervals. The core argument against the name is that it doesn’t entirely capture what the field is actually about. This perspective is often held by those who see child and youth care practice as hopelessly stuck in interpersonal, often transactional, practices taken largely from a white, middle class lived experience and struggling to meaningfully engage with the whole range of histories, economies, politics and identities embedded in how we are in the world. Even in Canada, many communities really don’t see themselves reflected in either the phrase or the practice of child and youth care. This includes Indigenous communities, African and Afro-Caribbean communities, disability communities, and communities that fall outside of the binary gender constructions. Ironically, those who do support the name child and youth care often find themselves working precisely with individuals and groups from within these communities, all of whom tend to be disproportionally represented in the institutions and settings where child and youth care takes place. Additionally, the large numbers of cultural and spiritual communities that shape their lives according to values and ways of being that reflect their heritage or traditions (often referred to as newcomer communities despite having been in Canada for generations), don’t really engage with child and youth care either and are often puzzled when confronted with a child and youth care practitioner.

Even those who like the name are nevertheless challenged by its exclusions. Much of child and youth care practice unfolds, at the very least, in the context of families, so that a name that excludes work with adults (caregivers, parents, kin, significant others) can appear as problematic.

Furthermore, particularly in developmental and autism sectors, child and youth care practitioners often work directly with ‘youth’ who are actually adults. This suggests a degree of ableism and neuro-normative biases that are an inherent by-product of the name of our field, perhaps mixed with a dose of patronizing arrogance in that we deny these adults their identities by imposing a child or youth label on their needs (if you need a child and youth care practitioner, you must be a child or a youth).

There is in fact no inherent reason why a practice that goes by the name child and youth care cannot substantively be meaningful beyond an interpersonal focus on children and youth, nor is there an inherent reason why the field itself cannot continue to evolve beyond its white foundations under its current name. But there may be inherent compromises that the field demands of individuals and groups of people that are ethically unacceptable. I think it is important that we engage this possibility.

Several scenarios come to mind, all of which point to some major problems. I think, for example, of friends and colleagues who have been engaged in particular communities doing work (paid or unpaid) that is entirely in keeping with what everyone seems to agree are some core principles of child and youth care practice, including relational ways of being, participatory structures and processes, care expressed in multiple ways appropriate for the communities where care is offered, and even behavioural guidance, spiritual guidance, academic performance, trauma-informed healing practices, and so on. They may be doing this work completely outside of the field of child and youth care, having never set foot in a child and youth care program offered at colleges or universities, but what they do nevertheless is what people are taught is child and youth care in their academic programs. In order for these friends and colleagues to find space within our field, and potentially to get paid for the work they do by institutional employers, they have to adopt the language and the politics of the field (such as the demand to join professional associations, to participate in training events, to seek certification and write certification exams, etc.), and most importantly the name of our field, even if that field has explicitly and intentionally excluded them. This is very similar to Indigenous peoples having to say that they live in Canada, which is the name given to their lands by settlers who stole those lands through violence and deceit (the word is based on a Haudenosaunee term but it is not the name of the lands where Indigenous people live; note also that the world indigenous is not an Indigenous word).

In another scenario, we can focus on how the name child and youth care centers children and youth in describing, or naming, our practice. The idea of centering children and youth may sound innocuous enough, but in fact, this too is already a political act that runs counter to many community traditions and ways of being. Furthermore, the name child and youth care suggests that care for children and youth can be constructed separately from care for community, care for other generations, and care as spiritual good rather than pragmatic practice. Once again, we can see how the name itself creates boundaries for truth in our practice. One might even argue that framing care as a practice is already a step toward denying other possibilities.

Finally, we can imagine people engaged in their communities who did in fact complete a child and youth care academic program and use the principles and skills associated with child and youth care in their community practice. In calling themselves child and youth care practitioners, they are forced to fit their practice in a child and youth centred framework that may not at all correspond to their desire or intention. In other words, the name child and youth care may force people to convey understandings of their intentions that are quite different from what they desire.

I am sure there are other scenarios where the name of our field is itself a burden to people whose practices reflect the most contemporary and critical articulations of the field itself. The point really is that almost no one thinks that child and youth care is strictly about children and youth; even the characteristics of child and youth care as articulated by Garfat and others suggest that there is far more to child and youth care than the name is able to convey. So why do we hang on to this name?

Perhaps it is an emotional attachment to the hard work that has gone into putting child and youth care on the map of professional disciplines. Perhaps it is about the protection of the investments that have been made by organizations, academic institutions, businesses and individuals in branding this name and sustaining their livelihood. Or maybe it is about the fear of losing relevance if we were to change the name now, at a time when we are seeking professional regulation and government mandates for our field. I understand all of these reasons, but I am not sure any hold up to scrutiny. The field has already changed its name multiple times; at the very least, in Canada it has moved from child care to child and youth work, to child and youth counselling to child and youth care. Elsewhere, a wide range of other terms and names are used that include youth work, youth development work, community service work, social service work, and others. No matter what we have called it, we have largely failed in our quest for regulation and governmental mandates (with the exception of South Africa, child and youth care is not mandated anywhere; the same professional practice based on pretty much the same principles is called Upbringing Assistance (Erziehungshilfen) in Germany and is regulated and government mandated; social pedagogy is also government regulated and mandated across Europe and in some South American jurisdictions, and psycho-éducation is regulated and mandated in both France and Quebec).

Does tradition matter? Should we keep the name because it has a history, a tradition associated with the hard work of people who prepared this field of practice for the rest of us? Well, I always think that traditions that are meant to honour those who came before always end up limiting those who are here now and future generations. I think the tradition we should uphold in our field is really about constantly striving to do things better, in more inclusive ways, relevant to the current state of knowledge representing multiple knowledge traditions. If child and youth care really is about the moment and making it meaningful, then this moment calls for an openness to re-think our name. I don’t want to suggest a new name, largely because I am not new, and I am not the key to our future. I heard that some Schools of Child & Youth Care in other parts of Canada are thinking about changing the name of their School to engage precisely the debate I have highlighted here. I don’t think they should, because I know that for the most part, the people leading the charge are old like me, and the last thing they ought to be doing is setting the limits for the next generation. But I do think the invitation to change the name ought to be given to those who will shape how we are in the years to come. Whatever they come up with, I will support it. 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App