CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 299 JANUARY 2024

As we enter 2024 …

Hans Skott-Myhre

2023 was a horrible year for far too many children and young people around the world. So many of them were subject to violent deaths, assaults, erasure, food scarcity, homelessness – the list goes on. And so, as I enter 2024, I am a bit jaded and more than a little worried about what we, as adults, are doing to make this upcoming year different. My sense is, that whatever we are doing, it is too little, too late. And I hope that I am very wrong about that. Perhaps, we adults will experience an awakening that will radically shift the way we think, and who we are, in such a way that we will open our capacity to affirm life over death, love over fear, and kindness over brutality. But I am more than a bit dubious about that happening anytime soon and most probably not in the upcoming year.

That said, of course there are innumerable small acts of love and kindness between young people and adults every day all over the world. There are adults who are deeply and profoundly committed to affirming life in their encounters with children and youth. There are political and social movements that are working diligently to affirm the right to existence and affirmation for young people, both in the center and the margins of our increasingly global society. The good news is that sometimes they win and our children are able to exercise their right to life, health, political expression, cultural affirmation, and the dignity of bodily sovereignty.

On the other side regrettably, since the beginning of the 21st century, despite powerful movements, demonstrations, acts of resistance and courage, the lived experience of young people’s sovereignty has lost more than it has gained. Of course, this is not unique to young people. Adults have also experienced an erosion of political force when it comes to pursuing the right to a pluralistic society where acceptance, love, and justice are valorized and made a practical reality.

We should note however, that this pattern of struggle is not unique to the 21st century. The contestation between greed and care is ongoing, but the fight for the dignity of all life tends to intensify during times of massive transition between one way of life and another. And make no mistake, the shift to an economy and way of life founded on virtuality and cyber capitalism is just such a transition.

It is in this context, as the social moorings of the past century slip, and life is thrown into open flows of possibility, that there are reactionary political formations which attempt to force life back into familiar channels. For example, we have the global reassertion of forms of fascism and dictatorship centered on a mythical social and cultural purity premised in fundamentalist forms of religious belief. We can see this in Russia, Hungary, India, Israel, Afghanistan, and the United States to name a few. In these instances, the movement is to mobilize the political power of the state to enforce moral imperatives upon the citizenry of the nation.

Such movements impact the freedoms of young people in terms of who can attend school and what they can learn, the ability to express pluralities of gender or sexuality, the capacity for minority cultural expression, the right to bodily sovereignty, the ability to speak freely, and the right to dress and hairstyle (as an expression of culture or personal preference). These reactionary political and social formations very probably have no long-term viability, because history does not move backwards and the reassertion of a world past cannot stand against the pressing force of the future.

That said, reactionary forces can exact a tremendous toll, even in a short period of time. Nazi Germany only existed for 12 years, but killed and enslaved millions in their effort to reassert a mythical Germany that never really existed. So, in saying that contemporary political formations can’t be sustained over extended periods, I am not saying they cannot have severe and horrific impacts. They already are.

As frightening as the emerging threat of reactionary fascism might be, there is an even more threatening political formation that is emerging as we enter 2024. That is the call for a move away from democracy to a system of technocratic rule. This movement is potentially more dangerous, because it is firmly founded on the developments in technology that are rapidly and comprehensively changing the world in which we live. There are some thinkers and leading capitalists who are proposing that democracy has run its course and we should move to a system where we are ruled by an elite council of technocrats who understand the emerging world of things like AI, global technology, and virtuality. Rather than be governed by “the people” who cannot seem to manage their affairs without falling into descension, warfare, and paralyzing government dysfunction, technocrats would be rule, guided by the emerging wisdom of virtual intelligence and scientific innovation. This is a frightening possibility, because it builds on the world of the future, which is coming to be with a speed that is difficult to comprehend.

If this kind of governance gains force, young people would be marginalized based on their humanity. The fundamental precepts of relational engagement, living encounter, and even love which are central to the CYC project would lose significance in the face of a technology centered future. Of course, the fact that 2024 will undoubtedly encompass significant innovations in the growth and spread of technology is inevitable. The question is, does that mean that the messy world of living things is necessarily increasingly subordinate to those developments. I think that it is more than a resistance premised in nostalgia to argue for an ongoing assertion of subordinating technology to the necessities of life, rather than the other way around. I am always extremely dubious about groups of experts who get in charge of things and even more so with the narcissists I see emerging out of Silicon Valley, who are proposing to take control of our lives and ways of being.

So, as we enter the new year of 2024, the stakes are high for the young people we encounter in our work. The specter of a dystopic future, politically, economically, or ecologically weighs heavily on their minds. I don’t believe, that at a fundamental level of existential intuitive comprehension, they have any faith in the false comfort of a system that promises them mental health in the face of unconscionably deteriorating systems of care for all living things. They live in the world and they can see firsthand the ways in which adults are neglecting to create reasonable and sane responses to the escalating crises of our world today. Young people’s epidemic rates of depression, anxiety, suicidal ideation, and peer to peer violence seem to me to be obvious responses to a world in which what is happening to their lives doesn’t seem to matter to those in charge.

This is not to say that young people don’t seek a quick fix in the world of counseling, mental health, and psychopharmacology, just as they seek escape in the comforts of getting high, virtual worlds, and the allure of entrepreneurship. Two centuries ago, in a similar time of transition into industrial capitalism, Karl Marx said that religion was the opiate of the people. While there are many ways to read that statement, in our context, I would suggest that what he may have meant was that in the face of a system that appears to be violently impervious to our needs, we might seek solace in a rituals and beliefs that promise some personal comfort. In our age, certainly religion could be seen for some as still holding that kind of comfort, but too often religious belief these days is also one of the sources of violence and oppression young people experience across the world.

Perhaps, then the opiate for the 21st century is not so much religion as mental health. The promise that somehow we can surmount the turmoil of our times by adjusting our thoughts and behaviors so that what is happening around us doesn’t interfere with our sense of purpose or well-being. That we can seek comfort in a form of an internalized politics, where we don’t have to change the world, we just have to change ourselves.

Under this logic, we learn that we can’t really even begin to change the world until we have taken care of ourselves first. We are taught that self-care must precede our ability to care for others. Our needs come first and then whatever is left over can be shared with others. I would argue that this is a dangerous fallacy founded in a certain kind of privilege. The pursuit of mental health as an economy of self-valorization is profoundly limited when it comes to the millions of children living on the knife edge of the survival all over the world. For such children, there is no space of respite from misery that allows for a psychological or psychopharmacological remedy. The solution to suffering is utterly material.

While there are any number of things I don’t care for in the way Maslow’s hierarchy of needs is often used and interpreted, I do believe that he got it right when he foregrounded physiological needs, such as the ability to breathe, have shelter, water, food, clothing and sleep, followed closely by the need for safety and then love and belonging as essential components of human well-being. It is important to note that all of these come as necessities before even considering self-esteem as the premise for mental health. For millions of children and youth these basic necessities are at risk on a daily basis, even in the wealthiest of nations. From my perspective this cannot be disentangled from our collective emotional and psychological well-being as a people. True mental health is not an individual issue. It doesn’t originate from within any one of us. Our ability to be whole individually is a collective issue and any social discourse that gives the impression that we can separate ourselves from the suffering of others is the worst kind of delusional propaganda.

To shift the trajectory of social and ecological disaster that could well be the future, I would argue that such delusional thinking has to be avoided at all costs. If there is the beginning of a remedy to the dystopic projections I have been delineating as we enter 2024, it might well lie in our ability to shift from a model of internalized individual models of well-being to a model of collective care. We have the capacity for such a shift within the core principles of CYC if we just adjust our viewpoint a little.

Instead of reading our core principles as referring to the dyad of the worker and the young person, we could widen the scope so that we see our interactions as an extension of collective care. We already have conceptual models of the milieu within residential care. What if we cast the net beyond the walls of our programs and began to conceive of our work as a community endeavor. How about the possibility that life work is not just the activities we do with the young people in our programs, but could become activities we and the young people do to engage with the communities that surround us. We know the satisfaction and even joy that can come from doing things together successfully within the milieu. Can we begin to explore what might happen, if we began to work with young people to work together to take action to change the material conditions in their communities, or to mobilize politically to bring about a change that is important to them and those they care about, or to provide outreach to other young people in need.

I am well aware that some of these actions would threaten certain kinds of funding. But how long will we in CYC continue to make ourselves dependent on the very system that is harming our young people to begin with? Is it time to declare a new form of independence that would allow us to think outside the box and create new systems of collective care that could better meet the needs of young people in 2024 and beyond. 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App