As we enter the new year, I am struck by the ever increasing intensity of social dissolution, alienation, and despair that seem to mark our view of the future. Most of us are so much more cautious now and less willing to believe that what we do can actually change the way we live. There are of course remarkable exceptions in the young people fighting for justice, equity, planetary health at all levels, and for a new way of life premised in a vision of the world beyond global capitalism. I am humbled by their bravery and determination. The odds so often seem impossible to overcome and the velocity of corruption at all levels overwhelming, And so, I find myself in a profoundly ambivalent position. I am relentlessly optimistic about the revolutionary capacity of living force to overcome all forms of fascism that seek to contain and control life itself. On the other hand, it is hard to see beyond the fact that the most profound victories of the forces of human life are, at best, holding back the worst, rather than promoting the best.
For those of us interested in advancing the causes of joy, affiliation, creativity, and love, we appear to be fighting a rear-guard action to hold on to anything we can, as we retreat inch by inch. Under such conditions, I would argue that we have to ask, what sorts of social institutions do we need to triage the wounded and create spaces that promote alternative ways of affirming life. As we enter 2023, I am hoping that CYC might have some programs, institutions, academic initiatives that can take on the development of a new set of relations between young people and adults that affirms life as its primary mission. As I noted in my last column, I don’t believe that any of the existing mainstream models have the capacity to do this. In fact, I argued in that column that most of what we do in CYC is in support of the forces that are killing us.
When I look at our conference agendas, I see lip service to all sorts of work on justice and equity, but when we drill down to actual practice, we are still in league with the forces of discipline and control. We are still diagnosing and intervening, but now we know we should do it differently with young people who are non-white, non cis-gendered, non-male, non-binary and so on. In this sense we are replicating the social justice dynamics of the world of global capitalism, which is always willing to operate with greater degrees of justice and equity as long as it doesn’t fundamentally alter the system itself. In a term, we want to be the “good” adults so that whatever we do to young people, it can be seen as benevolent and enlightened action. But, we don’t want to seriously engage young people as equal partners in reshaping the field to the needs of the 21st century. That would be too much. After all, we say, they are just children.
So, as I muddle around in all of this, I am reminded of one of my earliest influences. Unlike many of my colleagues in CYC, I did not enter the field thorough residential care. I didn’t even know there was a field of CYC or learn about the wisdom of someone like Henry Maier until I had been working with young people for over twenty years. I came into the field during the period of deinstitutionalization in the 1970’s as a volunteer in one of the first mental health centers designed to provide care for those no longer being incarcerated in the asylums. Community care was brand new in the United States and to say that we really had no idea what we were doing is to understate the case. We had no model for caring for those experiencing madness of various types. The model of the asylum with the rigid psychiatric hierarchies was being abandoned and those of us working in the newly emergent world of community care were looking for a new way of care that was more collaborative and inclusive of patient’s experiences and rights. The anti-psychiatry movement was still influential in providing a social lens that attributed madness to the effects of a society gone mad. And the newly emergent field of family therapy was arguing that madness might be an effect of families gone awry. In both approaches, the focus was moved off of the individual experiencing madness and onto the system in which they were embedded. This was the model I was initially trained in and one that has profoundly influenced my work since.
The family therapists that were brought to the mental health center to provide workshops and trainings for us included Virginia Satir, John Weakland, Sal Manuchin, and Carl Whitaker. At the time, they were not particularly well known or well thought of by the rest of the psychiatric community. In fact, for many of them, they had just admitted that they were seeing families, a fact they had felt compelled to keep secret up until then for fear of censure and ridicule. They were, however, some of the few therapists willing to work with people diagnosed with schizophrenia in a way that wasn’t simply medication management or incarceration. They believed that madness could be treated by shifting the toxic conditions in which the identified patient was entangled. This kind of work required high levels of skill using language and relational positioning in highly innovative and creative ways. It also called for equanimity in the face of what was seen as craziness. What people did or said, was just what people did or said. People were people and all communication was just communication. In other words, these early family therapists truly did not stigmatize those diagnosed as being more pathological than anyone else in their family or community. Suffering was collective, although it could manifest through any given member of a social group. Such members were not ill but were manifesting the symptoms of a society that was ill. The trick was to shift the system, not treat the individual.
I was very taken with what I saw these family therapists do. I had the opportunity to observe them work with families at the center, at conferences, and with us as day treatment team. What they were able to do seemed almost magical. It was powerful work and as someone new to it all I was a bit awestruck.
I have to say that being trained this way, did not translate well when I went to graduate school. In my first class on how to do counseling, I worked with a professor who supervised us using one way mirror to observe our work. In my first observed session I applied many of the skills I had seen being used by the family therapists I has watched closely over the years. I had been using them in my work at the center and had seen they were effective and so I didn’t think anything of it. After the session, my professor debriefed me and told me that what I had done seemed to work very well. I had built a strong rapport with the client and there had already been some movement. He then told me that he couldn’t give me an A for the session because what I had done was not counseling or therapy. At best, he said, it appeared to be some kind of shamanism, like what he had observed growing up in India. I was taken aback, but we had many rich conversations about the difference between the work I did and conventional counseling or therapy. Later, I would come to understand this as relational work.
Certainly, one of the major influences on my early work, was a family therapist whose work was also called shamanic, Carl Whitaker. Whitaker was unusual even in the world of highly idiosyncratic therapists of his day. Indeed, shortly after his death one of his critics referred to him as the “crazyman.” He took an approach to the families he worked with that had no particular formula or evidenced based treatment plan. Instead, he took the time to get to know them and responded to the unique aspects of their struggle with as much authenticity as possible. He was known for getting down on the floor during a family session and playing with the kids, while talking to the parents seated above him. He saw his work as spiritual in the sense of his work with families holding the possibility of touching the deepest core of who we are and share together. In a recent book, based on Whitaker’s approach, David Keith calls for a us to be more nuanced, playful, and creative in our use of language in all its forms from irony to metaphor. He argues that Whitaker’s work was never regulated from the outside by pre-determined methods or cookie cutter approaches. Keith condemns what he calls the heartless empire of overregulation which squashes the spirit though life denying language focused on statistical outcomes, business models, and bottom lines. Instead, he offers Whitaker’s work as being more like a living forest always growing, changing, and co-evolving with all of those involved in the therapeutic encounter.
Of course, this has powerful resonances with the ecological thinking I have been advocating for in developing a 21st century approach to CYC. Perhaps, it wouldn’t hurt us to be a bit crazier like Whitaker. But, what I am particularly interested in here, is one specific act that Whitaker became known for, and that was holding and rocking young people suffering from the agonies of madness. In a way it was a simple gesture. To take someone in pain and hold them, rock them, and hopefully soothe some of the pain. But the idea that a therapist would breach the physical distance established by the ethics and conventions of psychoanalytic practice was unheard of. In fact, it was one of things that got him called crazy. And yet like joining children on the floor, holding and rocking people in psychic distress became a hallmark of his work.
I am struck by this simple gesture of care at this moment as we enter 2023. As I noted at the beginning of this column, it is a time when perhaps we can begin to see clearly that the trauma and suffering we are experiencing as we live in this world, is not founded in some individual pathology. Instead, it is a symptom of what Whitaker and the other family therapists, anti-psychiatrists, and even humanistic psychologists were identifying fifty years ago. The society we live in is toxic and we are manifesting the symptoms.
At the root of our malaise is a society that throws us out into the world alienated and alone. Loneliness is epidemic, sadness is ubiquitous, and anxiety is everywhere. And the treatments we offer more often than not seem to miss the most elemental aspect of the equation. That is: we need each other more than we need our biochemistry adjusted, our moods regulated, or our behavior modified. We need real material connection to life itself.
So, what might we do in 2023 to begin to reconnect us to us? Perhaps we might begin with the act of holding. Whitaker did that with individuals in psychic pain and perhaps there is still a need for that. But I wonder if we might need institutional spaces that have the capacity to hold us safely until we are strong enough to imagine other ways to live? What if, instead of institutions that treat us, intervene on us, diagnose us, and modify our behavior, we developed programs that were dedicated to spaces to collectively hold us? Holding in this sense is a collective act of mutuality. We hold each other and so we would need to seek staff that could do that. If our job is to hold and be held at all levels, physically, psychically, emotionally, and intellectually, then we would need to discover (or remember) how to do that well together.
Of course such an idea is crazy in the context of a world dedicated to intervention. But to be crazy for care in a crazy world that doesn’t care perhaps isn’t so crazy. One of the terms used to describe my early work and the work of Whitaker was shamanic. To talk in such terms is a very delicate thing because of the misappropriation of the Indigenous shamanic traditions by settlers desperate to find anything to believe in. So desperate they would steal. So let me take one element of how a shaman might be described and make a very careful application of it here. In some shamanic traditions, the shaman is someone who has been to the other side of life and death only to return with knowledge of both as well as the pain and suffering involved in the transition. I might suggest that spaces of holding might be initiated by those who have been to madness before and returned with a knowledge of both sides and the pain and suffering involved in the transition. There is a certain kind of magic here that has powerful capacities for transformative healing. But it is important to go slowly here and with a high degree of sobriety. Let’s start with seeing if we can hold each other’s suffering and then …