By the time you read this we will have entered the year 2022. The beginning of the new year is always fraught with both possibility and dread. After all, 2021 was no picnic, although it had some quite good moments mixed in with what might well be seen by some as harbingers of the apocalypse.
That said, the end of the year, for those who live in hegemonically Christian countries, is filled with the cultural trappings of Christmas. Among these are stories of sacrifice and generosity. As someone who aspires to the spirit of generosity and good will towards others, these stories have always had moral appeal and a sentimental pull at my heartstrings. But they also have an ambivalent edge, not unlike the sense of discomfort and worry that I experience whenever I see a feel good story about young people in need, or service recipients who are publicly praised for excelling in our programs, or those faces we see on flyers asking us to give to this cause or that cause.
My ambivalence is fueled by a sense that there is something amiss in using the stories and pictures of young people in order to advance the work and institutions of the adults who administer their care. It isn’t as though I believe that such institutions of care, and the adults who work there, are not deserving of support. Cleary their work is designed to provide for young people in turn. No, my issue is more about creating the spectacle of the child, the face of trauma, the story of redemption through institutional care, the heroic portrait of individual triumph by one of the good ones.
So, there are several elements here that trouble me. One is the deep association of capitalism or the money sign with our ability to serve others well. Another is the valorization of one individual child’s success as emblematic of what all the others “could” do. In this latter instance of the individual heroic child who rises above their circumstances, I can’t help but wonder what that means for the majority who we know statistically do not. What does it do to our sense of what anyone living in dire circumstances should be accomplishing? I am concerned that it indirectly, but powerfully, reinforces the idea that each of us are individually responsible for resolving our traumas and lifting ourselves out of poverty and trauma by our own sheer determination. It is as though we are implying that those among us who are homeless, hungry, stateless, poor, and living on the edge of a society that has immeasurable wealth and resources, are there because of our inherent flaws, moral or biological. It is the individual who is accountable, not the collective society in which we participate and support.
I was struck by this, as I read one of the innumerable stories about the Gift. Stories about the Gift vary from the religious assertion that we as human beings are gifted in various ways by God or Jesus, to the more mundane stories of human generosity under duress. It is this latter set of stories about human-to-human generosity that caught my attention this year.
I was reading various Christmas related threads and came across a story about a young boy who desperately wanted a rifle for Christmas. The setting was rural, and his family was poor but not without food, shelter, or warmth. On Christmas eve, the young man looked everywhere he could think of and saw no sign of his desired rifle. Bitterly disappointed, he was getting ready for Christmas dinner, when his father came home and announced that he had gone past the home of a woman who had recently lost her husband and was in desperate need of help. To make a long story short, the father enlisted his son in collecting wood from their woodpile, a portion of their Christmas dinner, and a bag of gifts for the widow’s children. The two of them went to the widow’s home and when the young man saw the joy and relief on the faces of the widow and her children he was deeply moved. At that point, his father took him aside and told him that the only way they could have afforded the gifts for the children was to sell his rifle that they had gotten him for Christmas. The young man suddenly understood why it is often better to give than to receive.
Being a bit of a sucker for sentimental morality plays in which generosity and sacrifice are key themes, I got a little lump in my throat and bit of a tear in my eye as I finished the story. But almost immediately, I pictured the circumstances of both families living in poverty, while most certainly there were other families in that very community living very well and sacrificing very little of their own comfort to aid others. And I thought, why are we celebrating a story like this, in which the poor sacrifice whatever little bit they have, in order to give a bit of respite for someone even poorer. And what happens the day after and the day after that. Most certainly, the widow’s situation will not improve, and the boy’s family won’t be able to indefinitely support them. And the grinding poverty that both families are experiencing will go on relying on the whims of a society that may or may not offer them a way out.
One of the underlying lessons being offered in the story is that each of us as individuals or families are responsible for looking out for each other whenever we can. And it is a seductive and attractive idea. I certainly try to live that way in my neighborhood and with my circle of friends.
But there is a subtler message underneath the generosity of friends and neighbors, and that is that these stories don’t ever address the broader social conditions that make it necessary for people to live in such conditions to start with. Why would we organize ourselves as a society in such a way that we have friends and neighbors suffering, when there more than adequate resources collectively available to address all levels of suffering and trauma. Why do we valorize the individual or family who looks out after their neighbor, but ignore our accountability to change the way we have structured poverty and trauma into the very bedrock of our social contract? Clearly, we can do far more collectively for each other than any of us could do individually.
Of course, because we are trained in an either/or mentality, there is a tendency for us to imagine we must do one thing or the other. That is to say, that we might argue that in order to address the larger social contract, we might well be less attentive to our obligation to look out after each other at the local or personal level. We have certainly seen this argument over the years in CYC work. Various CYC workers and leaders have suggested that if we become too interested in social justice concerns, we will lose the ability to care in profoundly personal ways for the child in front of us. As I have written before, I don’t find such arguments compelling. For me it is a false choice. Both are necessary if we are to do the kind of work that truly cares for young people.
Without a doubt, it can be daunting to make the effort to imagine a radically different society in which we bring all of collective resources to bear on alleviating each person’s individual suffering and pain. Although, if we were to do so, we may have far less need for each of us to look out for each other individually. It is possible, that there would be considerably less pain and suffering. Perhaps, we might have more opportunities to share more joy and less pain. We might be able to focus on collective problem solving sourced out of the newfound richness we each bring, when we are not hampered by inequitable and unjust social conditions.
But there is always the worry that changing the world requires impossible levels of effort that is beyond what we can bear under the already demanding conditions of life in the 21st century. But this thinking is also rooted in a sense of alienation and individualism. Of course, if we each had to lift this load alone, it would be immeasurably difficult. However, the point is that we can only change society collectively by working together.
This simple shift in our thinking from the idea that we are individually going to have to change the world by carrying the weight of it ourselves, to the notion that we are already collectively organizing the world right now, is remarkably challenging. To let go of the idea of the hero who changes the course of history is very difficult to do. After all, we have been saturated in such mythologies for our entire lives.
We forget that revolutionary leaders, visionaries, and cultural icons never do it by themselves. Their acts are shaped by the productive force of a multitude of other people working daily, minute by minute to create the possibility of change. Those that we hold up as having changed the world are merely conduits for the living political force that is forged in the day-to-day interactions of people living together in community. It is the dreams and aspirations of millions of people that shape the destiny of political projects and the symbolic articulation such movements are given in those identified as leaders.
The idea of the individual leader operating autonomously to shape the political will of a people is a dangerous fabrication. It obscures the actual workings of our collective political force. Society doesn’t change because such change is willed by a powerful visionary or revolutionary leader. Such leaders are only possible because the multitude has created the conditions necessary for that role to exist. In this sense, it might be useful to take to heart the words of the activist Grace Lee Boggs who tells us that perhaps we need to rethink the very idea of leaders, because leaders imply followers. She suggests that instead of thinking of ourselves as followers, we might imagine that we ourselves are the leaders we have been waiting for.
In this idea, that we are the leaders we have been waiting for, is a possible resolution to the contradiction of individual change vs. collective change. In the individualistic model, the idea of a million leaders leads to chaos and anarchy. In that way of thinking, we can’t have a million people each trying to lead, because there would be no central defining ethos or ideology to guide our actions. There would be no central defining social identity.
However, if we think about this dilemma ecologically, we might begin to see that each individual act of leadership is always intimately connected to all the living bodies that form the environment for that action. We never act alone, although what we bring through our actions is unique and idiosyncratic and can only be derived out of our body and mind.
Put simply, we are both individuals and parts of an overarching ecology to which we contribute, but from which we can never be separate. This is the secret of a million leaders. Each of us leads by creative contribution to a rich diverse and vibrant ecology of living force or what under another name we might call society. In this sense, every act is political and opens new lines of capacity and possibility. We cannot separate our own individual acts from the overall shaping the social system we are creating moment by moment.
If we take seriously the idea that every act is an act of leadership that propels a line of possibility forward into the broader milieu of social relations, then we must take full accountability for the gravity of our actions. To do this, we must be as aware as possible of the ways in which our society operates in ways we find brutal and miserly. When we begin to open ourselves to this way of thinking then the story of the Christmas gift is a small act of leadership that both ameliorates the suffering of the widow and her family, while pointing to the necessity for greater acts of force that will shift the social relations that created the crisis in the first place, It is both/and not either/or.
If we apply this logic to the CYC work we do within the institutions where we work, as well as within our personal lives, we can begin to see how these worlds are profoundly interrelated. We are leaders all the time in ways that make the separation between work and life an impossibility. In this sense, a work life balance is forged by a consistency of action across all the domains where we encounter other living beings. For those of us in CYC, this includes the young people we encounter one by one in our work, but also all the other humans and more than humans that comprise the environment that produce us and which we produce.
Concretely, this would mean, that to be competent leaders, we need to be conscious of the effects of all of our actions everywhere. We can provide for the young person in front of us only to the degree that we are constantly working to shape the future in ways that will provide them more freedom to live fully and completely. If we do this together, through a loving awareness of our interconnectivity, the burden is not so large and the sacrifice negligible. This is the Gift we are given that we have the opportunity to pass on to everyone we meet in 2022. It is the only way we will survive the next century.