CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 275 JANUARY 2022

It’s 2022: New Ideas for Child and Youth Care Education World

Kiaras Gharabaghi

Happy New Year everyone! Pandemic notwithstanding, I hope we can use this coming year as a starting point for new approaches and ideas for a new world. I want to start that process by contemplating new things for child and youth care education, recognizing that much of what I will say this month will be more relevant in the context of North America, perhaps the UK and Europe, and Australia and New Zealand, than elsewhere. In contemplating new approaches to child and youth care education, I started re-reading some ‘old’ stuff from our field. I have to say that re-reading articles from the 1970s to the 1990s, with all the familiar writers represented, was a real pleasure. From VanderVen to Garfat, Phelan to Charles, Maier to Krueger, Stuart to Ricks, and of course the always provocative Fewster/Cedrick, I found great value in getting myself lost in the ideas, stories and analyses produced twenty to forty years ago. I also surprised myself in concluding that much of this material is more relevant today than ever before.

Sure, there is the problem of whiteness; it is true, and the list of authors above confirms, that we built the field on a largely white lived experience, perhaps with additional doses of ableism and gender normativity on top of that. In this way, child and youth care as a field is not very different than other fields in community-focused service provision, such as social work, health care, psychology and criminology. Although all those fields did have diverse voices providing different perspectives, those voices were pushed to the side, taken up as interesting divergencies, but never really engaged particularly meaningfully. Still, those who built our field intellectually contributed something that I think could inform new ideas for education in child and youth care. Specifically, they contributed a focus on play, dialogue, listening, tending to the relationship, care, and at least a mild disregard for rules, structures, and sometimes even laws. In fact, as I re-read articles from such a long time ago in quick succession, I noticed that much of what they were collectively doing is creating an alternate universe. They describe a social realm in which the ways we are together not only are different but are intentionally adjusted to be relevant to the world(s) experienced by young people whose lives feature exceptionalities to the socially and normatively constructed patterns of childhood and adolescence.

The authors themselves are not exactly normal. They come across like a group home crew with attitude, but beneath that attitude is a beautiful, authentic and deeply touching care for community. And within their versions of community are young people who matter both to the wellbeing of the community and to themselves. As I was reading, it seemed to me that the power dynamics we often talk about today are much less prevalent in their writings than I remembered them to be; their vision is one that is far more participatory and non-hierarchical than the visions articulated in much of the critical child and youth care literature today. More importantly, imagining less hierarchy and more inclusiveness seems quite effortless and self-evident in their writings.

All of this made me think about child and youth care education, and how we might re-visit older ideas and translate them for child and youth care practice in an emerging new world. There are a few things that come to mind that I think child and youth care education programs could usefully engage. I offer the list below as starting points for discussion, not as finished recommendations.

Identity in the context of social structures and on-going oppressions – this is of course a major shortcoming of past ideas in our field, which were based largely on an identity prototype that is white, able bodied (at least to the extent that it can communicate verbally and has neuro-normative features) and cis-gendered. These shortcomings, that are reflected in almost every human service field, cannot be glanced over in child and youth care education. But that doesn’t mean that we remove or simply ignore the concepts and practice approaches articulated decades ago. What it does mean is that child and youth care education must be reimagined through the lenses of multiple and often intersectional identities, experiences, and narratives that center in particular those that are adversely impacted by the systemic and structural features of helping systems and of society at large. Instead of a theoretical exposition of anti-racism or anti-oppression, I think a more practice-focused re-storying of child and youth care is in order. This means taking all curriculum in all child and youth care education programs and re-telling it through the lenses of Indigenous, Black, Queer, Disabled, Trans and other ways of being in the world. Every introductory course in our field should consider our core concepts through multiple perspectives: what does care mean in the context of white privilege? What does it mean in the context of systematic racism in schools? What sorts of stories do we explore with students to ensure that all students have access to the cultural assumptions of the story? For example, when Mark Krueger wrote about ‘farting in the group home van’, is that a story that provides all students with similar access to its meaning? Or when we use the metaphor of dance or rhythm, does this work the same way for everyone? Or what does power-struggle mean and how might it be experienced differently depending on who the staff member is and who the young person is?

Moving from institutional practices to community practices – child and youth care education continues to make many assumptions about where people’s lives actually unfold. We have developed the field through an institutional language, which is not surprising given the roots of the field in residential care settings. Institutions, such as residential settings, schools, hospitals and custody facilities, are in fact important and this is where a great deal of child and youth care practitioners are employed. At the same time, however, community is where young people are connected, where their peer groups live, where they imagine their lives unfolding. I think child and youth care education must move much more explicitly into centering community as life space, which necessarily introduces a level of fluidity and interaction with broader social structures and processes as core elements of the practice.

Developing online relational practices – the current pandemic has accelerated what was inevitable: an increasing focus on using current communications and social network technologies and platforms as life space settings. Child and youth care education has been very slow to integrate technology and social media as core elements of how we engage with young people. We do not, for example, have a translation for Krueger’s dance metaphor in cyber space. One of the great ways in which people like Garfat and Fewster inspired a whole generation of child and youth care practitioners was to tell stories about particular young people and their interactions with particular practitioners. The stories are always phenomenal, but they assume a physical, face to face interaction. Child and youth care education must move with the times and enrich such stories with a combination of in-person and virtual engagements. It won’t be long before virtual placements, for example, will no longer be a response to pandemic circumstances but simply a routine part of learning to be a child and youth care practitioner with an entirely virtual job.

Reflective non-compliance with rules, procedures, and professional norms – this is perhaps one of the most challenging aspects of child and youth care education. We have moved largely to a conformist model of child and youth care education in which students are taught to either abide by the commands of evidence-based practices and normative professional norms, or they are taught to be critical and deconstructive and to focus on the oppressive context of much of their employment settings. Both aspects are reflected in the earlier writings of the 1970s, 1980s and 1990s, but the core focus in those writings is neither conformity nor critical rejection of everything, but instead a mischievous charting of pathways to practice that are fit for the moment, the young person or people involved, the positionality of the practitioner and the institutional loopholes that can be exploited. To be sure, people like Garfat, Phelan and Stuart did not advocate for overtly and blatantly breaking or violating rules, policies, or procedures, and all of them did in fact value the presentation of child and youth care practice as a skill-based and knowledge-based professional practice. But they did, each in their own way, promote a practice that unfolds alongside of existing structures and norms, but that never quite conforms to these. Relationships, they argued, come with their own set of rules, and these necessarily must be flexible and fluid enough to fit the moment and context. I don’t see anything in child and youth care education today that helps students find their own ways of living within and outside of the existing structures and norms. I think it is critically important that we engage our students on issues of reflective non-compliance and that we do that in ways that incorporate some of the earlier comments on identity and oppression issues.

Anti-psychiatry and non-clinical practices – child and youth care came into being specifically as a critique and countermovement to the psychiatric and clinical hegemony in the care setting. This is evident in the earlier writings from decades ago. VanderVen, for example, explicitly resists all forms of pathology and instead uses play as a framework for therapeutic practices. Garfat pre-empted the whole trauma informed practice discussions by talking about relational safety. Fewster, who was after all trained as a clinical psychologist, spent most of his time arguing that being normal is more of a problem than a benefit, suggesting that ‘treatment’, especially when driven by pharmacological means, is harmful. We have much more detailed and deep critiques of the psychiatric hegemony in slightly more recent work by Hans Skott Myhre, but I would suggest that we can learn a lot from the older versions of presenting child and youth care practice as resistance to these things. Child and youth care education has not really engaged these discussions explicitly, which, in turn, has opened a confusing and decidedly un-child and youth care-like attempt to partner with the clinical movements. I think this is out of step with what is needed from child and youth care as a field of practice; what is definitely not needed is a group of ‘wanna-be-but-didn’t-have-the-grades’ child and youth care self-proclaimed clinicians. There are furthermore many contradictions in the attempt to on the one hand offer an anti-racist and anti-oppressive curriculum while on the other hand, training students in the clinical and psychiatric mechanisms of racism and oppression.

Fluid skills and resilient vulnerabilities – finally, I think child and youth care education must begin to focus on delivering concrete skills and creative approaches to practitioner resilience that are fit for the fluidity of 21st century life. For one thing, uni-lingual child and youth care practitioners ought to be a thing of the past. The challenge of childhood and adolescence is directly tied into migration patterns, immigration and settlement issues, and complex personal lineages. It is also tied into disability networks and communication patterns of deaf communities, autistic communities, and others, all of which require access to multiple languages. Child and youth care education ought to take seriously its obligation to meet people where they’re at, and very often, they are not within the practitioner’s language and communication comfort zone. Beyond language, however, I note that the most exciting things happening in the field are things related to performance arts, art more generally, music, podcasting, story-telling, land-based practices and more. These are not esoteric contexts of practice; they are skill-based contexts of practice that essentially carry on the traditions of play and engagement that are so evident in past writings. They are also practices that require an entirely different kind of practitioner resilience. While we have done well to teach self-care in child and youth care education, we have done so in response to the risks associated with vicarious trauma and burnout. We have done almost nothing to ensure practitioners emerge from their education with the kind of resilience necessary to do improv with young people, or to sing, dance, record, tell stories or otherwise engage with young people in ways that may accentuate personal vulnerabilities.

I have deep respect for the work of child and youth care education, and the many individuals who have contributed to it, and the incredible care that goes into delivering learning that reflects the complexities of the world. At the same time, I wonder whether we are slowly missing some core elements of the world we live in today and that is quickly emerging as the world of tomorrow. When I read the work of all those who wrote extensively in our field twenty to forty years ago, I am reminded that what they wrote then was ahead of its time; they understood the pressures placed on the emerging professional field of child and youth care by the powers in charge of the formal world of institutions and social norms, and they provided the means to resist those pressures in the name of staying with young people on terms that were meaningful to young people at that time. When I look at child and youth care education today, however, I see much more of an attempt to fit with the powers in charge of the formal world of institutions, and to conform to language, practices and ways of being that have for many decades produced gross inequities based on race, gender, ability and disability on the one hand, and to conform to critical perspectives that work hard to discourage engagement with young people lest such engagement perpetuate the power and equity issues generated by systems on the other hand. And then I wonder where the child and youth care practitioners will be who can actually join a young person or a group of young people whose ways of being in the world aren’t captured by clinical imposition or critical deconstruction. I think 2022 will be good year to have some discussion about child and youth care education, if only to ensure that we maintain some relevance beyond our imagined self-importance as educators. 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App