CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 275 JANUARY 2022

2022: Without a Title

Tuhinul Islam

Covid-19 has both directly and indirectly affected our daily lives. New variants, it seems, are forever being born. Yet the human genius has meant that we have managed to keep any mass culling of our species at bay. However, scientists warn that uneven vaccine coverage will make it more likely that new variants will continue to emerge.  

The last two years have brought us a glut of information about the negative aspects of the Covid-19 pandemic: the death of loved ones; the demand for social distancing; travel restrictions; social isolation; job losses; increasing rates of depression and anxiety, especially amongst the young and vulnerable; higher incidences of reported domestic violence while social services have failed to safeguard and protect vulnerable individuals. The list is endless! In 2021, I participated in over 20 ‘international’ online conferences where the main agenda item was Covid-19 and the negative impact it was having on everything from funding cuts to job losses, from mental health issues to inadequate provision of services for our young people, both in and out of care.

While negative stories may be dominant, the pandemic has had some positives too. Stories abound within the global child and youth care sector, but unfortunately, they have not readily been brought to the fore, even by those attending child and youth care conferences. Why is that? Is it because these positive stories are not deemed newsworthy enough by those setting the agenda of our child and youth care publications? Or is there a fear that talking about the positive aspects of the impact of the pandemic could in some way jeopardise funding pledges made to aid agencies, thus affecting the economic survival of those employed by those agencies?  

Thom Garfat’s article in CYC-Online Issue 260 came as a balm during this bleak time. He has written about the positive impact Covid-19 restrictions has had on the lives and relationships of children in care and their care workers. How the forced slowness of pace has enabled staff and children to build firmer bonds of companionship. Thus, enabling children to think differently about their life journeys, often in a more positive way.  We have witnessed incidents on how the restrictions have forced us to be ever more innovative and creative – rethinking, reshaping and reforming our existing systems, policies and practices for children in residential settings, their families, and the workers who care for and heal them. Similarly, in Residential Child and Youth Care in the Developing World: African Perspective (Volume 4) book, Lee Loynes has talked about how conscious relational practices have begun to emerge during the Covid-19 pandemic, offering a more accessible sense of belonging and attachment, transformative awareness of responsibility, and generosity of spirit through our shared global crisis. However, our present challenges remain learning curves for all of us, teaching us critical ways to keep our children and youth safe.   

During this challenging time, it has again been proved that child and youth care workers are the dominant element in the lives of children and youth. They are present during the child’s highs and lows, aiding them to build their futures, day by day. This includes those living in high-risk situations such as refugee camps and in developing countries where material resources are limited yet courage, responsibilities, sincerity and love are found in abundance. With their innovation, resilience, creativity, local knowledge, care, compassion and dedication they continue to turn each challenge into an opportunity in these ‘new normal’ times. They offer refuge to the children in their care, doing everything humanly possible to save them during this crisis, just as they did previously. 

Each child and youth care worker/practitioner from the Global South has a unique story to tell about why they chose to work in this sector. The West may portray them as uneducated, unqualified or incompetent. Yet, this is far from the truth. Often it has been a story of love and self-sacrifice that has brought them into this field of work. They want to be changemakers for the better, seeing their role not as a job but as a vocation.  Their mission is to make positive changes in the lives of children and young people, planting seeds of hope for a better future. By ignoring their contribution we do a great disservice to them.

Covid vaccines have reduced the infection and death rates, giving wealthier nations citizens a feeling that all will be well. However, the situation that we see right now is unacceptable because a large part of the world remains unvaccinated. Currently, less than 1% of people in low-income countries are fully vaccinated, while a mere 10% are in lower-middle-income countries, compared this with over 90% in high and upper-middle-income countries! And in comparison, looking at the percentage of doses that have been administered in low-income countries, it's a shockingly low 0.3%, yet this is where most of the the world’s population live. Rich countries have given out far more booster jabs in the past four months than poor countries have given total doses in the whole year. Some richer countries have announced the desire to administer the fourth dose if needed while others are planning to impose fines on those who chose to remain unvaccinated.  This is exacerbating the stark inequalities in vaccine coverage, as was always the case in other areas.  

It was disheartening to learn that wealthy nations only started donating their surplus vaccines to the developing world once they realised that if they didn’t protect the developing world they would suffer from new variants. Covax was set up in 2020 to help secure vaccines for the developing world. The scheme has delivered 582m doses to date - some of these doses had passed their expiry dates! It has suffered from a lack of transparency from pharmaceutical companies export bans and hoarding by richer countries. Looking at the data coming from Duke University, as an example, the USA paid for enough vaccines to cover its population twice over, the UK four times over, and Canada five times over its population. So although the world with its 8 billion population, 11 billion doses was produced by the end of last year, 9.9 billion doses were earmarked for the higher and upper-middle-income countries. 

Though we do not precisely know the situation of our child and youth care workers, especially those in developing and resource-poor countries, in terms of Covid-19 infection rates and death, we do know for sure that they are not sitting idle, even if they are not vaccinated. These self-sacrificing changemakers have dedicated their lives to putting a smile on the face of young people. If any of them by chance gets infected or lose their life due to this discriminatory practice favouring richer countries who will be held responsible for the loss of such critical changemakers? 

Discrimination is not new of course. However, what the wealthy nations are doing now to the developing world is morally, ethically and religiously wrong. It shows a clear ‘master and slave relationship’. What about the human rights of such changemakers? Putting at risk the lives of billions of people’s is discrimination and a violation of human rights. Yet, shamelessly, these neo-colonialisers are lecturing the global south stating that ‘Covid-19 does not discriminate’. That may be true, but wealthy nations do discriminate, people in power do!  

We know wars, political upheaval, intertribal strife, and pandemics all influence constructive attempts to provide high-quality child and youth care. No matter the words used by wealthy nations, international communities and local governments, the reality is frequently different. Could it be that we could engender a sense of reawakening and assertiveness among the child and youth care community that could guide us through this difficult journey our predecessors started aeons ago? The importance of good relationships between residents and carers and the value of maintaining connections are the root of child and youth care work.  

Let us pray for our child and youth care practitioners, acknowledging their tireless contributions towards supporting the future of the millions of children and youth they hold in their care. As well as hoping that those living in developing countries are vaccinated soon so that they too can keep their dreams alive! 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App