Most CYC agencies have case conferences which are intended to review progress and discuss futuregoals for youth and families. These meetings occur somewhere between one month and three month intervals, and involve the team of adult professionals. We have also invited the youth and family members to these meetings, so that they can be fully involved and empowered to give input. Often the youth is coached by a CYC practitioner beforehand so that he/she can be able to say something meaningful to the assembled professionals. Family members are also invited to attend.
My experience in sitting through many such conferences is that youth rarely disagree or even interact with any enthusiasm, often just mumbling a reply when asked a direct question, such as “Do you agree with us?” Family members are rarely in attendance. Yet we continue to pat ourselves on the back for empowering youth and families to participate in developing treatment goals.
One amusing and challenging example is a youth who was coached for several days prior to the meeting to use “I” messages during the conference. After the one hour meeting, he was asked by his CYC worker how he felt, and he replied, “It was really hard, my eyes are killing me”.
A colleague from Scotland, Judith Furnival, had been part of a project which attempted to empower youth in this type of case conference to be able to speak without being intimidated by all the surrounding adults . This SIRCC study found that even with everyone focused on doing this, the result was similar, the youth felt overwhelmed. The format was too intimidating, even with maximum adult cooperation.
The reason that family members do not attend is also fairly obvious, and I would like to suggest one more reason, when we schedule these conferences we accommodate the convenience of all the professionals, in descending order of professional stature, and then announce the time to the family.If you asked the youth who is the most important person to accommodate, they would not do it the same way — perhaps not even choosing to invite some people to attend.
One excellent example of taking control of the meeting by a youth, who effectively managed to get all the team to focus on what she needed and to work for her goals, is an example I have used before. I attended this case conference in 1998, this is a true story.
A 12 year old girl went into residential care because of her mother’s alcoholism. She had a younger brother at home about whom she was very worried and felt that she needed to be there with him to keep him from being neglected.
Her social worker told her in December that if she attended school regularly and passed all her subjects, she could go home for good in June. At the April case conference the social worker changed her mind because the mother was not motivated to work with her, and stated that this girl was going into foster home care in June. This was a surprise to everyone at the meeting, but the girl did not react at all when it was announced. As the meeting was ending, the girl was asked if she had anything to say. “Yes, I do”, she said and turned to the steno and asked her to write it down, “If I do not go home in June I will kill myself” she said, “Do you know how to spell suicide?” . The meeting was hastily adjourned. There was another case conference without the girl in a week, and everyone agreed that they needed to figure out a way to motivate the mother, etc. The girl went home in June.
This is an extreme, but effective example of young people being empowered to get what they think they need. I regularly hope that we can figure out a better way to accomplish this for all our youth and families.