Recently in Florence Italy, Jody and I toured the Contini Collection in the Uffizi Museum. Our guide, Guido, spoke Italian in rapid fire sentences, and I realized I could not keep up with him, so I wandered around on my own to see what might be discovered.
Soon I was standing before the familiar painting of The Madonna and the Bambino. I must have seen hundreds of them as various versions are everywhere in Italy. What did surprise me was a similarity in how all these artists portrayed Mary and her baby. In every portrayal, Mary holds her son Jesus on her lap or against her shoulder, not looking down at the child but away from him. Her body is rigid and her face looks troubled, and there is no sense of joy or fulfillment. She appears sad and detached from her infant. In attachment theory, there is a clear lack of bonding between the two of them.
The accepted interpretation of this scene is that Mary is gazing into the future and sees her child will someday be persecuted and crucified, accounting for her detached appearance. I was reminded of all the troubled and alienated children and youth we try to nourish in today’s Society, and those who seem destined to live a life of rejection.
I walked away from this painting feeling discouraged and depressed. But two rooms later I saw another picture of the Madonna and Bambino painted by Farrarra from the 1400s. This Mary holds her baby to her breast nursing, and her face glows as she looks down at her child lovingly. This is an ideal picture of emotional bonding, the way a trusting bond begins. The care-giving bond forms the foundation for all future relationships.
Connecting with Troubled Students
The core of our work is developing a trusting relationship with a troubled student. We have written and lectured for decades on the significance of connecting in times of crisis. If we are not successful in developing this interpersonal bond, then all the subsequent treatment and pedagogical techniques are mechanical. It is like racing a car engine without any oil. It is not going very far before it heats up and shuts down.
We believe all interpersonal change with troubled students evolves and revolves around an adult relationship. But, what kind of relationship? How is this relationship described? How is it similar and different from all the other relationships in our life?
The Helping Alliance
Adults have many different kinds of relationships: social acquaintances, work relationships, family relationships, a few intimate relationships, and one or two significant life-long relationships with persons who know us at our worst and still are there for us. Not all of our relationships are healthy; some are toxic to our well being.
Our relationship with a troubled student is different from all the other relationships we have in our life. As messengers of mental health, our goal is to develop a professional relationship whichis therapeutic without being personal. This is a healthy, helping alliance with clear boundaries. It is a meaningful relationship although we do not plan to invite a troubled student over for dinner or share our daily and emotional historic issues with him. The relationship is based on the young person’s needs and not ours! To further complicate matters, the student often does not even seek our help and may not even want us around. The child in crisis has an overwhelming concern of stopping the pain. As a result, we initially are faced with a one-way relationship and not reciprocal altruism. We want to help, while the youngster is often reluctant to let us help.
Navigating a One-Way Relationship
I do not recall having any course in psychology, counseling, or social work that provided skills in working through one-way therapeutic relationships. Our Life Space Crisis Intervention [LSCI] work with troubled students gives us a deeper look into this process. There is still much more to learn, but this is what we have learned so far. This is advice for a person who wants to build a helping alliance with a youth in crisis:
Being trained for crisis does not provide the same experience as living through one. The analogy that comes to mind is Chuck Yeager’s 1947 flight in the X 1 attempting to break the sound barrier. It had never been done before. Yeager was well trained, but there were many unpredictable concerns. How long would it take to break the sound barrier? What impact would this have on Yeager’s plane? How would it affect his judgment and performance? What would happen to him and the plane after the sound barrier was broken?
As Yeager’s plane reached the speed of Mach 0.94, he described strange events that started to happen. Shock waves were shaking and buffeting his plane around.
The wild turbulence was causing him difficulty in concentrating. Then the needles on all the gauges started dancing back and forth. Everything he was told he needed to fly the plane was not working. All of his training appeared to be in vain-everything except his belief that he should persist ... not give up. He had to believe his situation would get better without knowing if it would. He had to overcome his state of distress in order to focus on his current task. Then it happened. He suddenly broke through the sound barrier. The shock waves disappeared and he was flying at Mach 1.2. The resistance was gone. There was no sound except for his accelerated feeling of success, an experience never to be forgotten.
Such is our experience in developing a therapeutic relationship with a troubled student. We persist without knowing if the student’s resistance will ever stop. We believe our caring, acceptance, and skills will win out over time. And when this barrier of resistance is overcome, the winds of suspicion diminish and trust begins.
From: Reclaiming Children and Youth (Spring 2008) pp. 56-58