Learning and the Self
Throughout the preceding articles in this series I’ve argued that the creation and expression of the Self is the central organizational and motivational force in our lives. From conception onwards, this inner sense of who we are draws our physiological, emotional and cognitive resources into its service, urging us to explore our qualities on the inside and carve out a place for ourselves in the world we share with Others. Given the support of our early caretakers and teachers, the Self becomes a place where information from the outside world mingles and integrates with what we know on the inside, creating a foundation for learning that keeps us solidly at the center of our own lives. In this way, our thoughts, feelings and actions become expressions of this integration – our own integrity if you like. Whatever might be happening on the outside, we come to know that we have the resources to create our own life in our own way – to act on our own behalf, take responsibility for our actions and create relationships in which we can become known, accepted and loved, for who we really are.
Well, this is the theory. It’s also a very idealistic statement. In reality, very few of us were unconditionally welcomed into this world by parents and teachers who recognized us as unique and separate beings with the inherent wisdom and ability to choose our own way of being in the world. To some extent, most of us found ourselves unseen and struggling to become what others wanted us to be. This doesn’t mean these significant adults didn’t care for us, love us, or have our best interests in heart and mind. It simply means that very few of them were supported in discovering and expressing the development of their own sense of Self – so how could they pass this wisdom on to their children, students and clients?
The good news is that, while our childhood may have fallen short of the above ideal, most of us received enough love and support to give ourselves what we didn’t get during those early years. If we stop to listen, we can still hear that stifled voice on the inside urging us on to be who we really are and, deep down, we know we have what it takes to become the creative authors of our own lives. The not-so-good news is that the same can’t be said for kids who come to the attention of helping professionals. In many cases, their inner voice has long-since been silenced and they find themselves struggling to cope with the incessant demands and expectations of an inhospitable world. Understanding how things came to be this way is our professional responsibility. Finding ways to bring the lost Selves back into the action is our professional challenge.
THE TWO ARENAS
1. Home is where the heart Is
In order to remain on course, the fledgling Self must somehow navigate through two critical and hazardous arenas – otherwise know as “home” and “school.”
In the first instance, we now have compelling evidence to suggest that this journey begins well before birth and the initial direction is set through the relationship with mother. Over the first year of life, infants learn about what the world has to offer and what must be done to ensure their survival at the most basic level. If they are offered unconditional caring and love, the emerging Self moves forward with confidence and without fear. If caring and love are strained or absent, the Self is abandoned as the infant attempts to provide whatever the world seems to want. If caring and love are replaced by neglect or abuse, the Self creates its own defensive armor as a protection against a hostile world. In both cases, the agenda of the Self is replaced by the infant’s overriding need to simply survive.
The more this pattern becomes entrenched, the retrieval and revival of the Self becomes increasingly difficult. In our profession we are often amazed by how kids can learn to survive in even the most diabolical settings, thereby contributing to the illusion that the family is somehow working in the best interests of its members. Practitioners often refer to this quality as “resilience” and seek to strengthen the youngsters’ defenses. But the most primary need of the Self is to be seen and heard — not to be hidden away behind yet another protective layer. This is one of the many reasons why we in Child and Youth Care have come to view relationships as the heart and soul of our work. Only through a close and trusting relationship will a fragile Self take the risk to become known to another Self. Only then is it possible to build strength from the inside-out.
Just for the record, I’m not only talking about kids in trouble. In fact, I’m convinced that there’s an element of this dynamic in most of our lives. Just ask yourself the question, “What did I have to do to ‘survive’ in my family?” and make a list. Now ask yourself, “In what ways did these strategies serve to take me away from who I really am and what I really wanted to do? If you find nothing to report, you are one of a rare breed. If you can identify self-defeating patterns that continue to influence your adult life and relationships, there’s work to be done. So get on with it – it will not only serve you but also the kids with whom you work.
In the pre-school years, the Self is seeking answers to the essential questions: “Am I wanted?” – “Am I loved” – “Do I have a place here?” During infancy, the answers are not received in words and translated into thoughts; they are sensed and experienced in the body. We are talking here about the deepest level of the Self, the foundation upon which subsequent self images and thoughts will be constructed. If this foundation is solid and accessible, it will evolve into an integrated understanding of Self that can move purposefully and confidently in the world. If the foundation is flimsy or inaccessible the unsupported core self will withdraw from the action, leaving the child to create an image of self from the appraisals of significant others. What they present to the world is not who they are but who they believe they should be. ‘False Selves’ constructed in this way may look solid but their dependency upon the outside world for sustenance and affirmation leaves the individual constantly seeking affirmation from others in order to feel recognized, accepted and worthy. Because there is no internal core to internalize the external messages, however, such feedback is never enough. No matter how powerful and successful the person may become, his or her achievements are for other others and the inside will remain empty.
Working relationally with children at the core self level requires considerable understanding and patience. What needs to be understood is that the missing element is deeply rooted. Positive feedback may appear to reinforce acceptable behaviors, increase self-esteem and enhance relationships, but unless the hidden and protected Self is brought into the equation this approach will only serve to increase the youngster’s dependency on external rewards and contingencies. By the same token negative feedback will simply confirm what the kid already believes – he or she is empty and worthless. The challenge for professional practitioners is to find ways to encourage these youngsters to turn their attention inward – to slowly open up the channel to the silenced voice. And this is where the patience comes in. The journey inward is not generally seen to be a very attractive proposition and the pathway is certainly beset with hazards. The secret is to move slowly and sensitively, accepting and reflecting whatever lies in store. If you’re interested in how do this, I refer to my earlier piece – Commandment 6.
2. Self-less Schooling
Beginning school usually coincides with a critical phase of cognitive development – a time when objects become separate entities, constructs replace fantasies and ideas are created from complex associations — perhaps it was planned this way. Kids who have established a solid core sense of Self are ready to receive and process complex information about the world without losing themselves along the way. What they know and experience on the inside is important to them and remains a constant point of reference. They are motivated from the inside-out, pursuing their own inherent curiosity, taking in information, assimilating what fits, and questioning, or rejecting, what doesn’t. In short they are highly participatory self-motivated learners ready to explore the world around them. They should be outstanding students participating in a stimulating and respectful learning environment.
Unfortunately, public school systems don’t usually see things this way. For whatever reason, most operate on the principle that learning is essentially an ‘outside-in’ proposition that must be imposed on a reluctant and potentially unruly congregation. Beginning with the ‘basics,’ information is presented in the form of rigid curricula that is blatantly unresponsive to the particular interests and sensitivities of individual learners – so much for curiosity. It is generally delivered in packages, as facts to be learned and regurgitated, rather than possibilities to be considered and questioned – so much for internal integration. In the interests of efficiency and consistency, every effort is made to ensure that the recipient’s internal experiences don’t interfere with the objectivity of the enterprise – so much for Self involvement.
In effect, the Self is systematically removed from the learning process and placed in cold storage at a time when it most needs to interact with the fascinating world of ideas and abstractions. In its place we have a learning system designed to encourage kids to compete with one another for external appraisals and rewards. Only those with the most solid core sense of Self survive this assault without the loss of self-direction; the others will be pulled off base and left to flounder in a whirpool of academic flotsam and jetsam. Within the confines of the classroom, it’s highly unlikely that their teachers will ever want to know about how students feel about their predicament. It’s all about performance now and any problems not directly associated with that objective can be referred to the Counseling Department.
The more teachers, counselors and parents focus their attention on academic achievement and behavioral compliance, the more the essential developmental needs of the Self are ignored or repressed. And it doesn’t get any better as time goes on. Step by step, the system sorts out the successes from the failures and slots them into their assigned categories on the performance scale. For those who defy such classifications, a growing list of alternative labels is readily available to assist in the processing: ADHD, Attachment Disorder, Oppositional Defiance Disorder and — are you ready for this one — School Refusal Disorder are just a few of the concocted options. For a growing number of kids, such labels are being offered these indelible identities as a replacement for what they are being so tragically denied – the opportunity to become who they really are in a society that really cares.
Is there any wonder so many kids are displaying their discontent about being imprisoned for six tedious hours, five days a week in these oppressive institutions. Acting-out, dropping-out, bullying, gang-warfare, apathy, drug abuse and violence, are all symptomatic of a system that has lost all meaning for those who are caught in its clutches with no way out.
And it’s getting worse. As our social, economic and environmental woes escalate, this archaic conspiracy we call education becomes increasingly embedded in the decay. For more and more kids, the future offers the dismal prospect of being unemployed on a planet that can no longer sustain the illusions that created the mess in the first place. Reactionaries cry out for schools to go back to basics and teach the old values that once supported the illusions of a world that never really existed. But, however hard they might try, they are fighting a losing battle against a generation that no longer buys into the mythology. We can drug them, incarcerate them or distract them with false promises, but the days of unquestioning obedience are coming to and end. Thank God!
A Child and Youth Care Response