CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 288 FEBRUARY 2023

Technically Skilled Yet Witless: Research about Foster Care

Doug Magnuson

There is a knack to producing research that has a grain of truth, appeals to prevailing opinions about a topic, and may have a glossy sheen, yet is false and even harmful. Such is the state of much research about foster care and what is taught about foster care in social work and Child and Youth Care programs. Everyone “knows” that foster care is bad, that youth removed from their homes and placed in foster care are doomed, and that youth always do better in their families. The “research” confirms it. “Research says” is the phrase used even by those who otherwise do not believe in research. A couple generations ago foster care was the shiny new object proposed to solve the problem of “bad” group care that was harming children unnecessarily. Today “keep the children in the family” is the shiny new object, and again we are doing so without assessing whether it is actually a good idea for any particular child. Twenty years from now researchers will be “proving” that families are bad for kids (at least some kids), and there will be a new shiny object. Consultants, therapists, and university professors will get rich telling eager and desperate audiences what to do and inviting young people harmed by their parents to tell sad tales.

In 2008-2009, I was seconded to the Ministry of Children, Youth, and Families in British Columbia, and I could not convince anyone to study what seemed to work, nor was anyone willing to talk about the foster youth who were doing well. Instead, it seemed that the Ministry preferred to describe the sad tales of children, even if it were true only of some of their clients. The same was true of the Representative’s Office, which then never described anything or anybody who was doing good work.

A core flaw of these absolutist claims is that the premise of the argument is always simplistic, concrete, and superficial. I have in front of me a research article, published in 2021, that demonstrates this on every page, beginning with the choice of foster care as a predictive variable. Foster care is measured as yes/no, even though we know that there are numerous types of foster care: short-term to long-term, family-based to intensive, professionally trained and para-professional. The age at which youth enter foster care varies from infancy to just short of adulthood, so the “treatment” length varies. The amount of contact between youth and biological parents varies from zero to as much as possible. Additionally, we know that the quality of foster care varies widely, and we know that the intensity of problems that youth bring with them into foster care has sharply increased from the early days. Researchers can “control” for these and/or incorporate them into the measurement of foster care, if they know about them. These studies usually use administrative data, so they do not ask youth if their foster care experience was good or poor. 

If they do not know, they ought to, and if they do know, they usually ignore it.  In this article, the researchers compare foster youth to a “matched-group sample” using something called propensity scores. They matched youth on family income, ethnicity, and gender. They did not match the groups on any variable that might be relevant to foster care: abuse, especially. Propensity scores is a fancy method, but it is no better than picking kids out of a hat, if what they are using to measure the propensity of youth to be similar to another group is fallacious, as in this article in which what is compared are gender, ethnicity, and socioeconomic status—not abuse or neglect.  I know you will be shocked to learn that the researchers found that being in foster care was more likely to produce adults who committed crimes, became pregnant young, dropped out of school, and so on, since they are comparing youth who were abused to youth who were not abused.

A second flaw is assuming that there is a cause and that the only possible causes are what we know about right now. The work of figuring out the chain of events or the mechanisms that lead from foster care to adult troubles has not been done. Even worse, the size of the effects in this study and in many studies are small and account for a minuscule portion of the connection.  This is a high degree of technical competence and, at the same time, witlessness.

There are some technically easy ways to fix this. Obviously, fix the measurement problem with foster care or drop foster care from the equation and measure the concrete influences on peoples’ lives.  It will take some skill, effort, and testing of measurement instruments. Second, instead of measuring the problems of foster youth, measure success. This is more than focusing on strengths. It is using the same methods, but it turns a study inside out so that you notice different things. In this case, it might help them notice that the majority of youth in foster care do succeed, even if it is challenging; by the way, so do most youth who experience trauma, racism, poverty, and abuse. We could then devote attention to improving the quality of care for those who struggle the most. Additionally, we would be less inclined to slander those foster care parents who are doing good work, and before them front-line practitioners in group care, and maybe we can do better than to slander the future practitioners in whichever model of youth care is the next victim of researchers’ laziness. 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App