CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 288 FEBRUARY 2023

Burnout and Care of the Self

Hans Skott-Myhre

Every so often something really gets under my skin. Generally, I resist the impulse to either pontificate or preach (well, that’s not entirely true). But when I do, I generally make an effort to follow up with a more reasoned and thought out response. This column is that response.

The other day I found myself responding to a question from a student about the inevitability of burn out. Apparently, the students in my Child and Youth Care class had the impression from others in the field that if you do direct service work you will burn out. You can put it off by engaging in self-care, but sooner or later it will get to you. They asked me if I ever experienced burn out as a Child and Youth Care worker. I told them that I had not and then went on to explain that I found the work energizing and exciting from beginning to end. I used strong rhetoric to denounce the idea of burnout as an inevitability and was equally forceful in expressing how dubious I feel about self-care as a remedy for burnout. In fact, I may have been a little over the top, but this is not the first time I have fielded this question and it always triggers a strong reaction on my part.

I find the question of inevitable burnout problematic at several different levels. In the first place, the question implies that the young people, their families and communities that we engage in our work are somehow toxic to our own well-being. It is as though continued exposure to them and their lives will gradually erode our own emotional and psychological well-being. I find this offensive.

We are not so terribly different than the young people we encounter. I have not found us (CYC workers) to be in any way more emotionally healthy than anyone we meet while doing this work. As human beings we all share the same kinds of hardships and struggles to varying degrees. For some of us, those struggles might appear to be mitigated by economic circumstances, or the lottery of where we happen to be born or raised. But, when we take a closer look, all of us struggle and all of us suffer. I am not suggesting that the circumstances of a life lived in abject poverty, subject to the vicissitudes of racism, sexism, homophobia and other forms of violence can be dismissed. I am saying that living under those conditions does not make one more or less toxic than someone who has lived a more privileged life.

Of course, one might well argue that it is not the people who are toxic to be around, but the chaos and trauma of their lives. The argument here is that we, as workers, experience what has been called bystander trauma. To be immersed in the lived relations of disenfranchised and marginalized young people is just too much to bear. CYC workers will inevitably experience some level of PTSD from entering the world of abuse and neglect in which young people live. The worker enters this world from the outside and then leaves it to go back to a healthier life free of such trauma. The residual effects of having been exposed to bystander trauma must be remediated once the sanctuary of the worker’s home and community have been reached.

Inherent in this account is the idea that the world of the worker and that of the young people are radically distinct. It seems to me that this distinction is built on two faulty assumptions. The first is developmental and is premised on the idea that workers are adults whose lived experience is no longer the same as that of the child or adolescent. Young people have issues and struggles that adults no longer have. In this account, the CYC worker has moved into a life of stability, free of trauma because they have learned the skills necessary to negotiate life successfully. Their lives are free of the chaos they encounter at work.

The second is contextual. For anyone who has known CYC workers, the idea that their lives are free of chaos is simply ridiculous. Given the low wages, long hours, and age proximity of most workers, their life away from work is seldom the kind of space that is a respite from the world they encounter at work. Most of the CYC workers I have known are often motivated to do this work specifically because their lived experience resonates with the work they do. They have a history of struggle that is very closely aligned with the young people they encounter in their work.

When we think of the work in this way, we often seem to assume that what we went through is firmly in the past and we have moved on in ways that allow us more objectivity in our work with young people. What I think we may miss here is that many of us are still working through that past in our current lives. When I worked in the field, I knew colleagues struggling with abusive relationships, loneliness, drug and alcohol abuse/addiction, complex and difficult family relations, issue with their own children or siblings, depression, anxiety, grief, struggles with homophobia, racism, misogyny (some of that in the workplace), homelessness, economic challenges, health care issues, and the rest of human suffering. In my experience, this does not make us less effective as CYC workers, In fact, some of the most troubled workers were some of the best workers I have ever known.

Let me be clear, not all troubled workers were great. For some, their personal troubles affected their abilities in ways that led them to leave the field, or act in ways that were quite problematic. That said, I have never observed a correlation between what our society considers a stable emotionally/psychologically regulated lifestyle and being more effective in building relationships with young people and their families or communities. I certainly never noticed that such workers had lower rates of burnout.

But what is burnout exactly? The term is used generically to refer to a wide range of dysphoric reactions to the workplace. For those of us interested in working relationally, we might define it as an inability to connect or engage with our co-workers and the young people in our work. In this sense, we could think of it as a kind of alienation in the Marxist sense of the word. Marx argues that one the key features of the workplace, is the growing sense of alienation from one’s own labor. Put simply, as workers, we increasingly lose control over both how we perform our work and also access to the products of what we do.

In terms of CYC work, our labor is establishing authentic relationships with young people, their families, and communities. To the degree we are given the space to learn and grow our capacities for such work, then our labor belongs to us. We get to decide how best to do our work in collaboration with our co-workers and young people, while feeling that our contribution is valued and respected. In this scenario, the living labor of relational work is shared collectively by all of those engaged in the work.

On the other hand, when our labor is controlled by institutional forces whose agenda is either the ongoing existence of the agency or the financial interests of outside funders, our labor is taken from us and turned to other purposes. When this happens, our own sense of what constitutes good relational practice can be constrained or even denied by the regulatory mechanisms of the institution. This is alienation in the Marxist sense and can play a powerful role in a disconnect between feeling connected to one’s own labor and a sense of satisfaction in the work one does. The loss of a living connection premised in collective creativity about how to work together with co-workers and young people can provoke deep antagonisms and resentments.

Not surprisingly, the deeper and more profound the alienation, the more chance there is that there will be a climate of anger and despair within the institution. I would suggest, that in any given social configuration, those with the least to lose will act out the repressed outrage and resentment of those who dare not speak for fear of losing their position in the power structure.

In CYC institutions, the group with the least to lose are the young people. They are already profoundly alienated from the institutions which, in many if not most cases, have failed them repeatedly. They are also a faultless barometer of the emotional temperature of the institution in which they are embedded. They know when things are not working and the adults are at odds with one another. They know because it has been a survival mechanism to know.

When the CYC staff are blunted in their ability to express their own growing alienation and antagonism towards their bosses, the expression of that anger and despair is increasingly likely to be expressed by the young people. When we see programs with high levels of violence and despair among the young people, we might want to turn our attention towards the relations between workers and their bosses. How powerful are the top-down dictates about what a worker can do or not do. How strong is the implied imperative that a worker’s primary job is crowd control. How much voice do CYC workers have in how the program is run and how individual decisions are made about young people. If the answers are that CYC workers are just cogs in a machinery of discipline and control, then we can predict a program in which violence and trauma will be a regular feature of the work and increasing levels of alienation will quite likely lead to burnout and disaffection.

I would argue that when we focus on the individual worker in their interactions with young people as the site of burnout we are missing the key element in what creates the conditions of alienation and despair. Without a doubt, trauma plays a key role, but the trauma experienced by workers is a subset of the ongoing traumatic experiences of young people subjected to a society that consistently erases their needs and the needs of their families and communities. What occurs to workers and young people in institutions of discipline and control is simply an extension of the logic that robs large segments of society of their labor and leaves them emptied of their purpose and the drive to express all that they are and can become.

This is why I don’t believe that any amount of yoga, exercise, meditation, good diet, or quality time with friends and family will reduce burnout. Mind you, I think all these things are worthwhile. However, at best they increase our ability to tolerate the intolerable. They create a space outside the work, and perhaps even inside of us, that seems safer and more secure from the predation of the workplace. This is not a bad thing, but it will not change the world or the places where we work. That requires something else that we cannot do by ourselves.

If we really want to decrease burnout, we need to collectively insist on building new kinds of institutions where our labor belongs to us; to all of us. I said that I never burnt out when I was working in the field. I think this was because I always sought common purpose with like-minded colleagues who were working towards just and equitable practices. Some of these colleagues I found in the workplace, while others I met at conferences or through their writings. Some of my allies were adults, but quite a number were young people. In any case, we supported one another in understanding that the struggle to maintain control over our labor was key to sustain the field as a site of life affirming work. We certainly didn’t always win, but the spirit of comradery got me through some pretty tough times.

I also attribute the fact that I didn’t burnout to the energy I got from working in relationship with the young people I encountered. I somehow never found their pain and suffering overwhelming, Perhaps, that was because I was more taken with who they were as people, rather than what they were as exemplars of trauma. I certainly did not deny their pain and suffering, I simply saw them as more than that. I wanted to get to know them in all of their complexity, in the same way I would hope others would want to know me. At the end of each day, I went home with more energy rather than less, because truly relational work is nurturing. It is a mutuality of care between co-workers and young people who come to trust each other to be there. When that works it is magic and the best kind of self-care.

So why did I leave the field if I wasn’t burned out? After 25 years in the work, I realized that we were losing the fight. Alienation, despair, and cynicism were rapidly closing the options for establishing networks of living relations within most institutions that worked with young people. Control and discipline were more and more becoming the impetus for the work, driven by shrinking funding and the capitalist imperative of the bottom line. For me this meant it was time to rethink the project and to work to develop new strategies. And so I retired into academia to take the space to rethink the project and to refine our analysis of the system that was robbing us of ourselves. But that is a column for another day. Or perhaps, it is all the columns I have written here so far. Or both. In either case, the work now belongs to the next generation, and it is to them I hope to pass the baton. Burn out is not inevitable and effective self-care is always made up of collective action that affirms the politics of struggling together to retain control of who we are and what we do.

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App