CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 276 FEBRUARY 2022

Ups and Downs/You and Me

Hans Skott-Myhre

And I have come to see things clearly again — things that seem so simple to me now, but that somehow I couldn’t see then: that life is a series of peaks and valleys, and it is a fool’s errand to try to flatten them out. That beauty is in the connections we make, to self, to family, to friends, to the earth. That we don’t judge the quality of a life by the volume at which we live it. That I deserve to be kind to myself. – Charles Blow

In a recent column in the New York Times, Charles Blow talks about how his brother’s death, opened him to a reevaluation of  his own life and struggles with depression. The column was written in the hopes that a public expression of the contradictions and tangles of the relationship between the self we present to the world and the experience we have of ourselves when it is just us, might let others know that they are not alone in their struggle with feeling at home in our own lives.

Over the years, I have read a quite a number of these public confessions that are designed to let pretty much anyone who feels marginalized or alienated, because of their emotional instability, neurological difference, involvement with drugs or alcohol, sexual identity or preference, or other kinds of things we hide and come to believe separate us from everyone else we feel is “normal.” And, when I read them, I am touched by the foundationally good intentions of such public declarations. I hope that that, as the Beatles said, all the lonely and broken-hearted people living in the world will see, there will be an answer. That, all of us who struggle, and that is all of us, will feel a little less alone and a little less fearful about being outed as strange or inadequate.

In his piece, Blow writes about how he compensated for his private relationship with depression by living a life of public intensity and high production. We know this pattern to be true of so many highly prolific writers, musicians, academics, and others of the creative class. There is a relationship between the creation of highly evocative, sometimes stunning beautiful work and a private world of deep melancholy and periods of debilitating sadness. I know this at a personal level because my mother struggled in these ways. Everything she did that involved creativity came at a cost. She directed community plays for our church that kept her up for days at a time and would invest hours and hours into a small presentation to her book club. Each of these activities would involve intense periods of activity that could keep her up day and night for months at a time. I remember, as a small child spending any number of nights falling asleep in front of the stage at a late night rehearsals or hearing my mother upstairs walking back and forth in the wee hours of the morning working on a script that wasn’t up to her standards. Of course, since it was the 1950’s and 60’s she also cooked all the meals, did the dishes, laundry, helped us with school and so forth. She was a whirlwind, or as someone once described her, “a force of nature.”

But when the play was over or the book club presentation given, she would collapse. She would literally take to her bed for several weeks, during which time my father would bring her food and check on her in the evenings when he got home from work, and during the most intense parts of the collapse, in the first week or so, I would be kept home from school to look after her. None of us talked about this. It was just a part of life and a cycle that we managed. It is not particularly surprising then, that I centered my life, work, and scholarship around care as I grew older. As with many of us in CYC, our work and commitments stem from deeply held personal investments.

My mother’s cycles would undoubtedly be diagnosed now and she would very probably be put on medications that would flatten and regulate her energy. Our family life would have possibly become more conventional. But, I wonder about the cost of that in terms of my mother’s profound love for the creative projects she put so much of herself (and us) into. What would the effect have been on her creativity and sense of herself as an artist of sorts? Certainly, the intensity of her investments were costly to her and to us as a family, but is there another cost that would have been levied on her if her intensity was moderated? The balance between sheer creative force and what we think of as healthy living is quite complex and not as easy to parse as contemporary discourses of mental health might have us believe.

That said, there is another aspect to my mother’s story that ties back to Charles Blow’s column and that is the question of connectivity. My mother was a suburban housewife, and like many women of her era was isolated and I think very possibly lonely. The production of the suburbs and the nuclear family after WWII massively disrupted multigenerational webs of community and family that made up the both rural and urban networks of women who shared in the social production of family life. Moved from communities, in which a number of generations of women lived literally in the same house or within walking distance in urban neighborhoods, the suburban housewife was interred within the nuclear family household with only one generation of women; themselves. The geography of suburban homes was such as to separate each family cocooned within the confines of the family home. And that home was claustrophobically centered on the triangular set of relationships composed of the heterosexist, patriarchal roles of husband, wife, and children. There is a great deal to be said about the devastating effects of this arrangement on the women who took on the role of wife. We know, for example that during this period, which is sometimes thought of as the golden age of the family, there were epidemic levels of domestic violence, alcoholism, and prescription drug abuse. As Rolling Stones put it,

Men just aren't the same today, " I hear every mother say

They just don't appreciate that you get tired

They're so hard to satisfy, you can tranquilize your mind

So go running for the shelter of a mother's little helper

And four help you through the night, help to minimize your plight

Doctor, please, some more of these

Outside the door, she took four more

What a drag it is getting old

The rest of the verses in the song refer to dissatisfaction with women’s relationships with their children, their lives, and caring for their families. Each refrain remarks on how life is different today. Perhaps one of the most telling verses is,

Life's just much too hard today, " I hear every mother say

The pursuit of happiness just seems a bore

And if you take more of those, you will get an overdose

No more running for the shelter of a mother's little helper

They just helped you on your way, through your busy dying day.

The lived experience of women in the domestic sphere of the nuclear family is described as too hard. Pursuing happiness is an impossible goal, ironically dismissed as a bore. The level of despair is such, that overdosing seems a viable possibility of escape. We need to remember that these are women with what most of the world would define as a more than adequate income, housing, and creature comforts. Their use of drugs is not tied to poverty or homelessness. It is a drug epidemic that we never really talk about in the same way we talk about the opioid crisis or the crack epidemic. One has to wonder if that is because the myth of the golden age of the nuclear family needs to be preserved at all costs and the casualties of that actually rather brutal system of patriarchal control erased. The valorization of the mothers of that period, as the best mothers ever, presiding over the best childhoods is perpetuated in so many memes on social media. The idea that this is a time we need to return to is, like all reactionary projects, built on a lie. The truth is that the brief period that the nuclear family was an actuality was immensely damaging to everyone involved, but particularly the women.

In terms of my writing here, I am struck by the devasting effects of alienation and disconnection. That period was, of course filled with loving and caring people within the nuclear family structure, but their individual acts of care were not sufficient within that claustrophobic geography to overcome the underlying and overwhelming sense of despair in the midst of plenty.

Blow, in his column refers to the need for connection to “self, family, friends, and the earth.” Our disconnect from all of these things within the framework of settler capitalism is profoundly destructive. To live within the conventional social structures of the world we inherited from the late twentieth century is so radically alienating. It is no wonder that we show signs of a society literally suiciding at all levels from ecological self-destruction, to mass shootings, drug overdoses, and individual acts of self-destruction. Indeed, it would not be an exaggeration to say that we are failing to thrive. 

I wonder about this when I think of how we have organized the structure of so many of our programs on the geography of the nuclear family. We gather the young people within houses or semblances of houses supposedly embedded within a community context. But in truth, so many of these programs are self-contained claustrophobic spaces, closed off from the actual community. We generally don’t invite our neighbors into our programs to visit or hang out. The young people seldom make connections outside the program and the structure of relations in the programs is saturated with the patriarchal hierarchy of top down management of behavior and affect. The staff (both male and female) take on the role of the big papa when enforcing rules and the big mama when providing support. We have taken the structures of the nuclear family to heart and replicate them ad infinitum. Indeed, in many cases we valorize them and claim that we are giving young people the “parenting” or “family they never had. It doesn’t seem to occur to us to wonder if this kind of “family: is good for young people.

But, I wonder if this way of organizing our programs isn’t at least a little iatrogenic. It is so hard to provide a structure with so many similarities to the family and avoid the unintended effects. Is there something pathological about sequestering young people away in faux nuclear families, made of “professional parents” who are prohibited in many cases from overtly expressing love or in some cases expressly forbidden from physical touch, other than the occasional physical restraint? What does this lack of connectivity, at both the micro and macro level, do to young people who are all already refugees from the “family?” Do the smatterings of mad behavior that we see in our programs arise from within the damaged psyche or neurology of the child, or are they a logical, if unintended effect of the way we have organized our spaces of healing? Is this the reason that young people flee (runaway) from our centers of care and healing? Is such flight a sign of health rather than pathology? Are the ongoing small acts of rebellion and defiance the effects of an exaggerated developmental stage we call adolescence, or is it a healthy assertion of human dignity against a system determined to dominate and control their lives “for their own good?” In any case, it seems to me that the kinds of collective isolation we perpetuate in our programs don’t offer the kinds of connectivity that Charles Blow is suggesting that can soften the effects of powerful flows of emotion.

I wonder if it would it behoove us to rethink the frameworks of healing in our programs. Perhaps, we could begin to wonder if there were ways to be truly community based. Could there be a model that is less hierarchical and corporate? Maybe a bit more “us” and a lot less “you the kid and us the staff.” Could we move away from being parents  to being co-conspirators in a project to affirm life and creativity? To love fearlessly and collectively.

In his introduction to the book Anti-Oedipus by Deleuze and Guattari, Mark Seem states that,  

Deleuze and Guattari call for actions and passions of a collective nature, here and now. Madness is a radical break from power in the form of disconnection. Militancy, in Deleuze and Guattari’s framework, would learn from madness, and then move beyond it, beyond disconnections . . . to ever new connections. A politics of desire would see loneliness and depression as the first things to go . . . If [one’s] roots are in the current of life, [they] will float on the surface like a lotus and blossom and give forth fruit. The life that is in [them] will manifest itself in growth and growth is an endless, eternal process. The process is everything.

I await the day that we can move beyond the madness, alienation, disconnection, loneliness and depression, that we unwittingly perpetuate every day in the ways in which we replicate systems of domination and control in the name of healing. I look forward to a new kind of healing center for young people that can take the politics of desire as an affirmation of life itself as the key element of their mission statement and strategic plan. In the midst of the growing forces of fascism that surround us, that may seem like a crazy thing to hope for, but as John Lennon (who also suffered extreme bouts of up and downs) said, “You may say I am dreamer, but I’m not the only one, I hope someday you’ll join us.” 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App