Few congregate settings are more relevant to child and youth care perspectives than university campuses. These are settings that are overwhelmingly populated by youth. The typical undergraduate student is between the ages of 18 and 22, noting that most campuses have slightly older students as well, but still overwhelmingly in the under 25 age group. University campuses are often huge congregate settings. My university in Toronto, for example, has around 40,000 students, at least 75% of whom are youth. It is noteworthy, therefore, that much of the discussions about returning to campus after nearly two years of virtual learning has focused on the expertise embedded in public health perspectives, usually driven specifically by epidemiological considerations. The questions put forward are about safety, whereby safety is defined in terms of the risks of transmission and its consequences to the physical health of students, faculty members and staff. I do think these perspectives, and the knowledge embedded in public health and epidemiology, are important and should be considered in making decisions about whether to return to campus. At the same time, however, the privileging of these perspectives over others, and notably over a child and youth care perspective and the knowledge embedded within that perspective, is not only problematic, but also symptomatic of how quickly privilege, often tied to race, gender normativity, and socio-economic wellbeing, becomes the dominant moral priority.
I am, to be perfectly honest, somewhat shocked and embarrassed by the response of students and faculty members to current plans to re-open university campuses in my province, Ontario. For many, the planned return to campus has inspired letters, emails and petitions against such a return to campus based on the argument that it is not safe to return. In various forms of dramatic self-disclosure, people are objecting to being exposed to the risks that inevitably accompany the return to campus, indignantly asking how anyone could possibly demand of them to be unsafe. Universities have responded politely but are relying almost entirely on the very same perspectives as those opposed – public health perspectives recommending specific actions to reduce the risks of transmission. Both sides in this discussion are largely correct, at least within the limits of what we can learn from public health perspectives. The universities are correct in that they have taken many measures to reduce risks; they have imposed strict vaccination policies, there are mask policies and mandates, air filters have been upgraded and classroom capacities have been reduced. All these measures are based on the advice of local public health agencies, who are very much in favour of a return to campus. The opponents are also right; it is true that there are many ways in which a return to campus increases the risk of transmission for individuals. Whether it is sitting in a classroom with 100 other students, or the transitions between classrooms, or lunch time when people typically de-mask, there are elevated risks of transmission.
Yet I think this debate is absurd from a child and youth care perspective for three reasons, all of which suggest to me that our rhetoric about social justice, anti-oppression and anti-racism is far ahead of our actions. This is disappointing, particularly given that many of the students and faculty members opposed to the return to campus are social work, child and youth care, early childhood, and nursing students who profess, during better times, that they are unequivocally committed to prioritizing the lived experiences of the most marginalized in society. Turns out, that is not quite true.
The first issue is how we think of safety. To be outraged that a return to campus may demand of people to live in a context of risk and at best incomplete safety, as if this were a novel concept with no precedents, is to discard and invalidate the lived experiences of marginalized communities, and in particular Black and Indigenous communities for decades and centuries. These communities, along with Trans, LGBTQ2s+ and disability communities, have never had the experience of safety – they have never encountered a space in which they might have felt safe. Some spaces might feel safer than others, but no space is entirely safe, and the risks of just being alive include everything from experiencing insults and micro-aggressions to getting shot dead for being Black or Indigenous. From a child and youth care perspective, if safety is really the criterion by which we decide whether an institution should be open or closed, then I would certainly expect everyone opposed to the reopening of campuses to expand similar energy to the abolition of prisons, schools, child welfare, child and youth mental health, homeless shelters, hospitals, police stations and the military. And yet there is no such advocacy happening; to the contrary, most students opposed to the return to campus on the grounds of safety are specifically studying to become employed in the very spaces that render their Black and Indigenous peers unsafe. And most of the faculty members who teach their students day in and day out to apply perspectives and lenses reflecting the lived experiences of someone other than the dominant groups in society appear to be quite comfortable insisting on their right to safety in spite of full knowledge that there is no such things for many people in society.
The second issue is that of self-determination, and personal responsibility, perhaps with a sprinkling of rather precarious notions of caring and love. A common argument I am hearing from students (youth) is that they are worried about safety (meaning transmission) because they live with an elder family member or someone who has health issues that would increase the risk of harm if they were to infect that person after attending to campus. On the surface, this sounds very responsible and reasonable. Why would one ask people to come to a setting where there is an increased risk of transmission, simply by virtue of the large number of people who will congregate in indoor settings? But this is misleading. In fact, no one must return to campus. There are no punishments scheduled for those who don’t return. If indeed a young person is worried about the wellbeing of someone more vulnerable in their home who they care about and perhaps love, they should not return to campus. This means having to make hard and inconvenient decisions that may delay their graduation, perhaps result in financial loss, and certainly a change from the hoped-for timelines with respect to moving on in life and starting a career. It’s as if being confronted with having to make difficult and unwanted decisions is somehow extraordinary and reflective of being wronged. Never mind that many of their peers have had to make decisions that are inconvenient and difficult every day their entire lives. Some of those peers have had to accept malnourishment to attend university in the first place. Others have had to live in homeless shelters to pay their tuition. Some students are forced into street work to finish their degree. Never mind that people locally and globally are forced to exercise their self-determination and personal autonomy such that compromises, hardships and inconveniences are incurred, often with life-altering consequences rather than inconvenient delays or disappointment over unmet expectations. I am deeply worried about the lack of critical reflection on the part of students and faculty members. From a child and youth care perspective, it seems absurd to have a conversation about the misfortune to have to risk the lives of those we care for and love so that we are not inconvenienced in our goals to graduate or to stay at home and teach virtually. What kind of caring and love is this? Are caring and love so fragile that being inconvenienced means we are willing to risk their lives so that we are not inconvenienced? This does not bode well for our society.
But the third issue, which underpins the previous two, is the one that has me most embarrassed and even ashamed of the privilege embedded in these conversations. We casually choose to forget about the lived experiences of students for whom this pandemic is not really about a virus or the risk of infection. At my university, they number in the hundreds and perhaps thousands. Examples abound. Many of our students, and in particular female racialized students, live in family and community contexts in which they are subject to enormous violence, including sexual violence. During the pandemic, they have been prohibited from leaving their homes and are subject to a regime firmly based on patriarchal and even misogynistic standards. These young women, who I encountered regularly when working in homeless youth shelters some years ago, attend university specifically because it is their only opportunity to not be at home; it is the only pretext for which they have permission to leave without constant supervision. For them, coming to campus means spending a day not being abused and sexually violated. When campus is closed, they are stuck in unimaginably traumatic circumstances with no escape. Many other students are currently in psychiatric wards across Ontario hospitals, overwhelmed by their social isolation brought forth by campus closures. Black and Indigenous students, who have been disproportionately impacted by campus closures, and who are experiencing the greatest academic disadvantages because of the closures, are suffering the consequences quite differently than others. For the first time since such data has been tracked, the suicide rates of Black Youth, which traditionally has been very low, is higher than the Canadian average. For Trans students and many students identifying as LGBTQ2s+, self-harm, substance use, suicide and mental health crises resulting from an absence of positive spaces have had disastrous and life-altering consequences.
For many students, and especially students not benefitting from privileges often associated with race, gender normativity and socioeconomic wellness, a university campus is much more than a place of learning and the pursuit of degrees. It is a diverse community in which they find relative safety from family violence; it is where they can find peer groups of similarly positioned individuals, opportunities for self-advocacy and the exercise of collective power, and, quite frankly, a stronger probability of surviving the day.
Universities, their students and faculty members, often have a longstanding claim to a deep commitment to anti-oppression, anti-racism, equity and inclusion. Such claim obliges us to think about the members of our community who have the least power and access to the least resources. Their need for a campus, for being able to escape family violence, for finding connection and belonging as an antidote for suicidal thoughts and psychiatric meltdowns, necessarily must be our priority. This is not the time to ignore social and structural inequities and injustices. This is a time to live up to our rhetoric of caring, and to walk the talk. For most of us, that means showing up. For some of us, it means making hard decisions and accepting that like many communities have had to do for decades and centuries, the world does not always deal us a perfect hand.
We cannot continue to rely solely on an expert lens reflective of particular social positions and serving the wellness of particular social locations in thinking about what a return to campus really means. Our universities are spaces where youth either learn about solidarity and play their part, or where they are supported in abandoning any pretext of a commitment to social justice in the name of preserving their privilege. My version of child and youth care has always demanded risk in the name of creating spaces and relational connections that are meaningful to those otherwise living on the edges of our societies.