CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 156 FEBRUARY 2012

Naming Our Losses

Joanne Tamming

Child and youth care practitioners are generally prepared to recognize and deal with the issues of change, loss, and grief when they occur within the lives of their clients. Yet professionals are rarely encouraged to identify, examine, and work through these same issues when they arise within their own lives. This denial of personal experience is detrimental to the creation of open and effective relationships. In this article, the writer suggests that change, loss, and grief are integral aspects of professional practice and explores ways in which Child and Youth Care practitioners might acquire the permission, curiosity, and skills to bring their own experience into the equation.

In becoming professionals, Child and Youth Care practitioners are usually taught how to acquire things – not what to do when they lose them (James & Friedman, 1998). They are expected to acquire theories and techniques that will enable them to work effectively with their clients. And in the process they acquire a language that reflects their unique place in the scheme of things. For themselves, most seek to acquire the respect and recognition that will identify them within an established profession.

Above all, they must learn how to become involved in the lives of children and youth through something called a “professional relationship.” They are expected to know about “transference” and “counter-transference,” how to separate personal from professional issues, how to practice stress management, and how to identify and respond to traumatic situations (Ontario Ministry of Education and Training, 1996). As Catherine Andrew (2000) noted, “my training as a Child and Youth Care practitioner and counselor had taught me about neutrality and creating a healthy professional space between myself and their [clients’] pain” (p. 70).

From the outside, the practitioner’s ability to offer effective care and support for others, particularly those who have experienced loss and grief, is seen to be a reflection of his or her worth as a professional. Whatever a practitioner has acquired along the way is considered to be the resources he or she needs to do the job. Yet in Child and Youth Care, where the relationship is central, it might be argued that the richest professional resource is the personal experience of the practitioner. When it comes to the common difficulties associated with change, loss, and grief, this is a matter of critical importance.

This raises the question of the effectiveness of professionals engaged in loss and grief work who have not been encouraged and trained to deal with their own losses. This is not just a matter of acknowledging deep-rooted injury or trauma; it is also about acknowledging and working through the everyday changes that occur within the world of professional practice. In Child and Youth Care, these constant shifts and challenges are often known and predictable. By understanding the nature of such changes and the options for responding, the self-aware practitioner can bring valuable experience into his or her understanding of what might be happening within the life of the client.

Defining The Issues

Words such as “loss” and “grief,” in addition to the phrase" a significant life change," are key to the discussion. Webster’s Dictionary defines “loss” as “a decrease in the amount, magnitude or degree of something.” Loss is an unavoidable and natural part of life for everyone, regardless of age, gender, nationality, wealth, ethnic background, education, or intelligence (School of Population Health, 2001). Grief is “the normal and natural reaction to loss of any kind. Grief is the conflicting feeling caused by the end or change in a familiar pattern of behavior” (James & Friedman, 1998, p. 3). The grieving experience is a process of reacting emotionally, physically, psychologically, and relationally to life losses. In order for loss and grief emotions to emerge, a particular event or change needs to have occurred. A significant life change is “an event or occurrence, a loss or gain, positive or negative, but one which after it happens, a person’s life is never quite the same, and cannot go back to the way life was before the event” (Dyer, 1998, p. 1).

The interaction and degree of loss, grief, and significant life change are unique for each person, including each Child and Youth Care practitioner. In a broader sense, however, there are qualities and characteristics of this profession that often trigger such issues and influence how each person relates to the world, both inside and outside the workplace.

Significant Life Changes

The concept of loss might be framed within the equation: Change = Loss = Grief (Weiss, 1998, p. 31). Loss is triggered by a change of life events and circumstances. In Child and Youth Care, a practitioner’s personal relationships may change through the diminished time and energy available for family and friends.Structural downsizing, promotion, reorganization, and mergers within the workplace are reflections of an ever-changing context. Heavier or lighter caseloads, cutbacks, erratic work hours, wage adjustments, and client comings and goings all contribute to the day-to-day reality. At the same time, changes that affect the personal world – marriages, deaths, births, relocations – make their own contribution to the accumulation of issues that, if left unacknowledged, will never be adequately addressed. As a professional, the Child and Youth Care practitioner may be expected to grieve quietly and separately from the workplace, skillfully detaching personal from professional issues in accordance with some external principle (as in Ontario’s ApprenticeshipTraining Standards [Ontario Ministry of Education and Training, 1996]).

Losses

With each change comes a loss. In Child and Youth Care, the practitioner may experience a sense of loss around an infinite variety of circumstantial shifts, but the following have become common, if not predictable.

The loss of a work schedule compatible with the schedules of significant others: Child and youth care practitioners may be expected to work, or be available, for any period of time within any given day. In addition, they may be required to work at night, over weekends and during traditional holiday periods. As Krueger (1986) has said, “schedules can become very taxing ... if they are filled with overtime and if they interfere constantly with their personal lives” (pp. 43-44). The long-term effects of this loss of predictable contact with friends, family, and others is difficult to assess, but there is no doubt that there is a price to be paid.

The loss of supervision due to the time constraints of the work: Traditionally, supervision is a time for any professional to receive feedback, be affirmed, identify problems, review goals, and grow personally and professionally. But in Child and Youth Care, as Krueger (1986a) points out, “something always seems to be ready to impinge upon supervision (a crisis with the kids, a shortage of coverage, the supervisor is called away, etc.)” (p. 47). In his book Careless to Caring (1986a), Krueger observes, “a significant number of caregivers never fulfill their role potential because the care-giving system is unable to provide them with the status, financial incentives, supervision and training needed” (p. 16). Later in the same text he notes, “It is not uncommon to hear caregivers state that ‘the only time I see my supervisor is at staffings, after a crisis situation, or at my annual evaluation’ ... not many administrators can honestly state that their caregivers receive adequate supervision” (p. 34).

The loss of a supportive team experience: In training, many practitioners become accustomed to a learning environment that is supportive and nurturing. This is considered to be essential where the experience involves considerable personal challenge and risk. Unfortunately, in many work contexts, where the pressures are even greater, the practitioner may well find herself or himself working in relative isolation, despite the illusion of being a member of a team. To return once again to the words of Krueger (1986b), “the lack of time and resources have also been identified as the major deterrents to team work. Add to this the job stress which is inevitable when workers must confront, assert and compromise and it becomes apparent why some people struggle more than grow with teams” (p. 62).

The loss of identity, self concept, and permission to express feelings: While those who design professional standards might insist that practitioners learn how to detach themselves from other people’s problems, the fact remains that many issues raised by clients are similar to those experienced personally by the worker. If the practitioner is unable to acknowledge and express the thoughts and feelings associated with this connection, then he or she is effectively cutting off from the experience of self. The effects of this repression or denial can have severe consequences for both parties in the relationship. Again, Krueger (1986a) has identified the problem. He states, “managers and team members often assume or pretend they are not affected. This is a terrible burden to put on the agency and the individuals. No-one can perform effectively in an environment where personal problems are repressed or denied” (pp. 77-78). Similarly, Levine and Doueck (1995) report the story of one practitioner who, having listened to a client disclose a situation of family abuse, declared, “I was angry. I was exhausted ... I had to work really hard to keep those [feelings] in check” (p. 98). In their analysis they concluded, “therapists may even reject clients in the same way that an angry client might reject a therapist” (p. 98).

The loss of being vulnerable: In his book Being in Child Care: A Journey into Self, Fewster (1990) states, “personal vulnerability is the most potent state for all learning. We fear the judgments that others might make and we run back behind our disguises. Babies offer an openness that we [professionals] lose as we ... grow up” (p. 52). The implication is that a practitioner who cannot take the risk to become vulnerable loses the capacity to experience the fullness of relationships. Since Child and Youth Care is essentially about relationships, the loss of vulnerability has profound implications.

The loss of personal values, beliefs, and world view: In many situations a worker may feel coerced into compromising values and personal beliefs in order to remain with a particular agency and work within its mandate. According to Krueger (1986a), “every team member brings a unique set of beliefs and values to the team. Some of these can be compromised and others can’t. Team members can’t function in an environment where most of their basic beliefs are inconsistent with the prevailing beliefs at their center” (p. 79). Even the most deeply rooted structure of values and beliefs – a world view that stems from our earliest formative experiences – can be challenged, .. if not compromised, when working with clients and colleagues who see things very differently. Beliefs and strategies concerning “discipline,” for example, can create considerable explicit or implicit tensions that affect relationships and the working environment. When a person’s world view is threatened in some way, the potential for loss is pervasive and profound.

The loss of status, decision-making power, and respect: In many organizational designs, Child and Youth Care professionals are considered to be on the lowest rungs of the decision-making ladder. A loss of personal efficacy, a loss of voice, is detrimental to the well-being of any individual, but for those who work with clients who themselves feel disempowered, like children, the consequences are particularly tragic. Yet as Krueger (1986b) points out, “youth care agencies often consciously and/ or unconsciously perpetuate situations which make it hard for caregivers to become more involved in the organization ... Most agencies still place an inordinate amount of decision-making power in the hands of individuals with the highest employment standards, but the least opportunity to spend time with youth” (p. 44). The hierarchy reflects the status quo, and those in the most powerful positions (e.g., administrators, psychiatrists, psychologists, social workers) are rarely willing to relinquish their powers to those of lower rank. In such contexts, Child and Youth Care practitioners may have every reason to believe that their voices are seldom heard and their opinions count for little in the overall scheme.

The loss of energy, self-esteem, and personal autonomy: According to Krueger (1986b), “many [Child and Youth Care workers] enter the field with innovative ideas and a strong desire to improve treatment conditions. Instead of receiving support, they face resistance to change. Caregivers in these situations lose their energy for the job very early” (p. 28). Along with this loss of energy, practitioners may come to doubt themselves and their competency. They find themselves facing impossible odds in bringing about change either in their work environment or within the lives of their clients, and end up feeling defeated and worthless. In describing the experiences of one worker, Fewster (1990) explains how “she continued to attribute a youngster’s lack of response to her own lack of skills” (p. 82). In the same text, Fewster reflects upon the commonly destructive image of the practitioner as a “people pleaser,” being obsessed with the expectations and judgments of others. The task is hopeless since, however much the practitioner may struggle to match such expectations, the goal of changing other people’s lives or meeting their expectations can never be accomplished. The loss of energy, esteem, and autonomy that arises from this struggle is often referred to as “burn-out.”

The loss of equitable remuneration and life-style choices: While few Child and Youth Care professionals begin with vast accumulations of wealth, it is not unusual for them to experience a diminishing balance between income and expenditures. Compared with other human service professions, wages and salaries in Child and Youth Care are notoriously low. This often means that Child and Youth Care professionals are unable to keep up with their friends and acquaintances in supporting a desired life-style – a loss of equivalency and even contact. Wages also have ramifications for the practitioner’s longevity within a particular agency and within the field as a whole. As Krueger (1986b) points out, “the average salary ... is hardly enough to support even a very moderate life-style and certainly not enough to raise a family ... salaries are not commensurate with role potential [so] caregivers often leave the field long before they are able to reach the potential that is inherent in the role” (pp. 43-34).

The loss of opportunity for education and training: Lack of training within an agency is often attributed to lack of financial resources and time. This lack of training might also reflect a lack of valuing of and recognition for the practitioner, who has every reason to expect ongoing professional development. Either way, the opportunities that many workers enjoyed in school and in their training are no longer available once they step into the world of professional practice.

The loss of health and innocence: Child and youth care professionals are constantly exposed to the distress of others. Without the necessary support, it is not unusual for practitioners to sense that the world is no longer a safe and innocent place to be. Facing this loss, they may become desensitized to the traumas of others, displaying the signs and symptoms of having experienced and internalized these losses but lacking the tools to deal with them. Symptoms may manifest themselves in conditions of emotional or physical burn-out, secondary trauma, clinical depression, post-traumatic stress disorder, or poor coping strategies such as drug or alcohol abuse, nicotine addiction, overeating, or lack of exercise.

The loss of relationships and a sense of belonging: Shift work, low wages, and job stress, if not managed and balanced, can become toxic to relationships. Partners or spouses may not understand the stressors associated with the work, and relationships may change drastically. The high turnover within the profession creates additional losses of relationships with co-workers, children and youth, and families. In such circumstances, the practitioner may sense a loss of belonging and security. Additionally, there may be a loss of trust within relationships with clients. There are many situations in which practitioners are obliged to make “reports” on their clients, which can cause an irreparable rift in the connection. In the words of Levine and Doueck (1995), “clients who are reported by their therapists frequently feel a sense of betrayal and loss of trust. Many will refuse to continue treatment with the therapist who made the report” (p. 92).

Grief

Among Child and Youth Care practitioners, reactions or responses to any of the above losses may vary considerably. Practitioners might express emotional symptoms of helplessness, sadness, depression, or shame. They might experience grief at a spiritual level, losing faith in God or other beliefs, having witnessed the pain of their clients’ lives. The grief might be dealt with cognitively by dwelling in a confused state, wrestling with short attention span or suffering from short-term memory loss. Grief might manifest itself in physical symptoms like headaches, nausea, or lack of energy.

Behaviourally, they might become immobilized or display severe mood swings, become tearful, withdraw socially, experience a shift in sleeping patterns, become disorganized, or become restless in the workplace (Outreach Grief Services, 1999). Any or all of these responses are normal and natural. In the final analysis, it is their own knowledge of these responses that will enable practitioners to recognize the diversity of experiences that are evident in clients and co-workers who experience grief.

The Journey Towards Healing

By identifying their own personal and professional life changes, Child and Youth Care practitioners are able to come to terms with the grief process. By opening the dialogue and mastering the language of grief and loss with clients and co-workers, they are able to find the sameness within the diversity – without losing the person in the process. As Wholey (1992) points out, “while the events of each individual’s life may differ, the process of life is the same for all of us” (p. 6). It is important for practitioners, along with their clients and co-workers, to connect with each other, understand, and give space for each other’s grief rituals and cultural expressions of loss.

Acknowledging loss is empowering, not crippling. It is a process of healing. The space of healing must be one that allows the individual to laugh and to cry, giving permission to forget about the grief when the mood fits. The space should allow the person to acknowledge feeling scared at times. The space should allow for fun amidst the grief without external judgment. The healing space should encourage the person to talk and talk, until he or she feels the emotions of grief lift (Specialist Education Services, 1998). And all of this applies as much to the practitioner as it does to her or his clients.

James and Friedman (1998) have outlined the universal healing strategies for people dealing with loss and grief. Their suggestions include keeping a journal, getting lots of rest, eating healthily, focusing on physical activity, accepting the reality of what happened, going through the pain, and recognizing that the loss is final.Above all, they suggest, it is important to remember to celebrate the small steps and the small victories in moving through the grieving process. People in general, and professional “helpers” in particular, should be encouraged to be very aware of not getting lost in intellectualizing losses and ignoring the associated feelings.Child and youth care workers who are willing to identify and explore their own feelings of loss and grief are more able to deal with the same issues as they arise in the lives of their clients and even their co-workers. From their own understanding, they are able to respect the grieving person’s need for privacy. They are prepared to create opportunities for others to share feelings and to give permission for the expression of emotions, whether tears or laughter. In their own place of grief, they are able to share with others and let their own needs be known. They can acknowledge their own tears, anger, sadness, and disappointment without looking to others for the solution. They will understand that such feelings of sadness and loss will recur, even after the intense period of grief is over, and that is quite natural and acceptable (University of Michigan, 2001).

Insights for Child and Youth Care

Loss and grief work is about sharing what one knows about the issue with the assurance that whoever is listening can understand from their own experience without judgment. In the words of Mark Krueger (1986b), “knowledge sharing is one of the most important facets of personal growth and in development in the care giving movement as a whole. There is nothing more inspiring or powerful ... the rewards are plentiful” (p. 104). Along similar lines, a practitioner in Fewster’s Being in Child Care: A Journey into Self (1990) is reported as saying, “Child and Youth Care must develop on the basis of its own experience ... at the most fundamental level, Child and Youth Care workers must begin by valuing their individual experience and subjecting it to personal reflection and analysis. Unfortunately, most of my colleagues seem to invalidate their own direct experience” (pp. 140-143). In the same text, Fewster concludes, “among all the helping professionals, only Child and Youth Care workers have the courage and the privilege to immerse themselves in the everyday life world of their clients. If they can take the risk to be themselves and acquire the skills and confidence to speak directly to the youngsters in their care, they can become therapists par excellence” (p. 133).

To conclude, it is evident that all Child and Youth Care practitioners encounter personal and professional losses while travelling the professional pathway. The professional journey is about embracing both the losses and the gains encountered along the way. The sense of loss and grief is not only about people who leave or die; it is also about things and events that are no longer available. By acknowledging and exploring these experiences a practitioner learns how to be with others – clients, family members, friends, and co-workers – who share the same life-process. In this way, ongoing personal and professional growth is assured and the potential for all future relationships is enhanced.

References

Andrew, C. (2000). Walking the talk through tragedy: A story about presence and loss. Journal of Child and Youth Care, 14(1),69-74.

Dyer, K. (1998). Journey of the hearts. http://www.kirstimd.com/Change.htm

Fewster, G. (1990). Being in child care: A journey into self. New York: Haworth. James, J., & Friedman, R. (1998). The grief recovery handbook (rev. ed.). New York: Harper Perennial.

Krueger, M. (1986a). Careless to caring for troubled youth. Washington, DC: Child Welfare League of America.

Krueger, M. (1986b). Job satisfaction for Child and Youth Care workers. Washington, DC: Child Welfare League of America.

Levine, M., & Doueck, H. (1995). The impact of mandated reporting on the therapeutic process. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

Ontario Ministry of Education and Training. (1996). Child and youth worker: Apprenticeship training standards. Ottawa: Queen’s Printer for Ontario.

Outreach Grief Services. (1999). http://www.ogs.com.au/text/programs/go od-grief

School of Population Health. (2001). http://www.sph.uq.educ.au/cphc/lossgrief

Specialist Education Services. (1998). http://www.ses.org.nz

University of Michigan. (2001). Grief and loss in the workplace: Resources. http://www.umich.edu/~hrra/griefand

Weiss, S.1. (1998). Dealing with losses. New York: Rosen.

Wholey, D. (1992). When the worst that can happen already has: Conquering life’s most difficult times. New York: Hyperion.

From: Journal of Child and Youth Care, Vol.15 No.1, pp 53-61.

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App