It was in my introductory psychology text–a section about experiments conducted in the late 1920’s at the Hawthorne Western Electric Plant in Illinois. The plant assembled telephone equipment for Bell Telephone. Some industrial psychologists from a university were curious about the effects of working conditions on productivity.
First they quantified the output of the workers on an assembly line. Then they began making changes in working conditions to measure the effects of those changes, if any, on productivity. First, they made changes to the lighting. Productivity went up. Then they made other changes–I don’t remember what all they were. Each change they made resulted in an incremental increase in productivity. Finally, they returned things to the way they were and were surprised that, once again, productivity increased. They concluded that it was not improved working conditions that affected productivity, but rather the perception of the workers that someone cared about them and was paying attention to what they did.
What I learned was that, if I as a manager found ways to improve things for staff, morale improved. Later, I learned that, if I found ways to improve things for the children, then their attitude improved. It’s difficult to measure ‘output’ in residential treatment. Results take a long time, during which time many things change. There is a turnover amongst the children — there are discharges and new arrivals. There is also staff turnover. (Sadly, staff sometimes change more rapidly than the residents.) It is not possible to control for those changes, so it is most difficult to determine which changes may be responsible for any improvements.
Further, it does not seem ethical when changes in the facility or the program seem to be indicated to change only one thing at a time while keeping everything else constant simply to measure the effects of each change. Our work is not about gathering data for studies; it’s about caring for children. For example, when coming into a new program, I liked to change the lighting. But I also saw needs to make changes in point and level systems and other policies and procedures. And I didn’t think any changes should wait. It wasn’t about making changes and measuring outcomes; it was about helping people. Consequently I was never able to measure the effects of any given change.
Things to improve for the kids
Lighting
There are those who believe that standard fluorescent lighting is problematic and may contribute to or cause symptoms associated with ADHD. I’m one of those people. I like to replace regular cool white fluorescent tubes with daylight or full spectrum tubes. They cost considerably more than standard tubes, but when you change part of the building, such as client activity areas, and leave other areas unchanged, such as staff offices, the difference is dramatic. Within only one or two days, office staff start lobbying administration to have the new lighting in their offices. It was not long before the administration would ask me to upgrade all the lighting. Colors change. Moods brighten. Standard cool white fluorescent tubes produce light that is high in the blue and yellow-green spectrum, low in the red spectrum. Full spectrum or daylight tubes, like natural light, produce all the colors of the rainbow. It is my belief that full spectrum light stimulates a part of the brain in a way that cool white fluorescent lighting does not, so that artificial stimulants such as Ritalin may not be so necessary. We are diurnal animals. We need full daylight, not just a part of it. I can’t prove it. Whenever I changed lighting, I was also making other changes that were clearly necessary, so it was not possible to attribute any improvements to the lighting or anything else. Given the Hawthorne effect, that any change may be perceived as someone caring and paying attention, it is quite possible that changing from daylight to cool white fluorescent tubes might also produce some improvements. I doubt it and never tried. I wasn’t conducting experiments, I was running treatment programs.
Recreation equipment
How many programs have I seen where the recreation equipment was not in top condition? How many where it was in deplorable condition? Billiard/pool tables with worn out covers and broken bumpers. Cues with no tips. Ping pong paddles with torn or missing covers. Basketball goals with no nets. Stuff worn out from use rather than misuse or abuse.
When they can’t play a proper game of billiards or pool, they find other things to do–dodge ball with the balls, sword fighting with the cues. Ok, they may sword fight with the cues anyway. And it’s basketball, not hoop ball. There’s quite a difference between shooting at a goal with a net on it and shooting at a hoop with no net. And playing ping pong with proper paddles and playing with paddles of bare wood.
It really doesn’t cost much to put some of this stuff back in shape–but it does require effort. And when things are not in good condition, neither are the kids, so the kids require a lot of effort. The extra effort to get things in shape pays off. It shows the kids that you care. And gradually, things change. Some of these things cost so little that staff can make the changes at their own expense if they cannot get funds from the agency.
Menus
Got to have dieticians. Got to have menus approved. Some dieticians believe in healthy foods and create healthy menus chocked full of healthy foods. That few kids eat. Other dieticians are creative in developing menus chocked full of healthy foods that kids will eat and enjoy. Is there any reason they cannot have a great steak once in awhile? Or even lobster? Too extravagant? They don’t deserve it?
Feed them well. Very well. Throw in a special meal once in awhile. Take them out to eat at a restaurant once in awhile.
Activities
Kids need excitement. Don’t we all. If they don’t get it in legitimate or constructive ways, they are likely to create or seek their own. Either by creating some in the program or by running away to find it.
Provide some exciting activities. An outing to a go cart track or amusement park. A stimulating hike in the woods. And don’t ever make such supervised activities contingent on points or behaviour.
More, having kids visit educational, business, and cultural sites provides them with exposure to many diverse things, improving their knowledge and providing them with a background that facilitates their education. I think part of the problem with kids who are somewhat deprived is that they don’t have exposure to things that their classmates take for granted. Consequently, they have fewer things to which to relate the things they are learning in school. Makes it difficult for them to integrate it. It’s as if their minds do not have a place in which to place some of the things they should be learning. More, when knowledgeable and caring staff prepare them for such visits in advance, they know what to expect and what will be expected from them. They behave appropriately. They earn respect and even compliments from people at the place they are visiting. Then get invited to return. A boost to their self esteem. These children are often not used to being well-received and complimented by adults.
Look around. There are many things that can be improved, many of them fairly simple. Adjust the schedule. Change some rules. Minimize some “consequences.” (In my experience, consequences usually mean punishment, and punishments are often more severe than necessary.)
Things to improve for the staff
Forms and reports and reporting
There are always forms and reports and requirements to report. They develop over the years with changing needs and regulations and such. Often there is duplication and old forms still in use in spite of new forms. Often, things can be simplified, forms combined or eliminated, giving staff more time to do other things that are more meaningful, such as spending time enjoying the children.
Locks
I worked in several programs where each door had its own lock and key.
Meanwhile, other areas were secured by padlocks, each different. Staff had a huge key ring with all the keys that they passed from one to the other. They had to get the key ring, then fumble through the keys until finding the right key for whatever lock. A real mess in an emergency. Having the locks keyed to a master key system and buying padlocks that are all keyed alike to one key reduces the number of keys to two and allows individual staff members to each have their own keys. It saves them time and trouble and improves their efficiency.
Leave policy and time off
Many agencies I have known, before approving a request for time off, require staff to find someone to work their shift. Good staff often make personal sacrifices for the needs of the children or the agency. They will not leave at the end of their shift if a child is distraught. They will not leave if their replacement is late, or if things are a bit rowdy. I expect these things. I also believe that the agency leadership should be willing to make some sacrifices for staff, granting reasonable requests for time off without question or hesitation, and taking the responsibility for scheduling a replacement, even if it means working the shift themselves.
These same agencies, in order to be sure that staff had taken care of every foreseeable circumstance before leaving for vacation, required so much of staff in the week before they left that they were exhausted by the time they went on vacation. In such cases, it takes people a few days to ‘get into their vacation’ as it were. Doesn’t leave much time to relax and enjoy when it is only a one week vacation. Then, when they got back, they found such a pile of work that they had to work long hours to catch up and get things in order. They were often more worn out than they were before their vacation.
The only reasonable request for time off is when staff need it. (Good staff will not make an unreasonable request.) Grant time off when they need it. Then keep their work caught up while they’re away so they don’t come back to a mess and find themselves exhausted immediately upon their return.
In Conclusion
It really doesn’t matter what you do, so long as children or staff perceive that you are doing it because you care about them. When they realize that you care, they will often offer suggestions. Listen. When they realize that you listened and see you act on their suggestions, it makes them feel a part of the team. Even when you can’t implement a suggestion, taking the time to think about it and getting back with them to explain fully and clearly why you cannot do it lets them know that you listened and considered it carefully. They still feel a part of the team This applies to both staff and children.
In my experience, most changes are top-down changes, imposed by administration and management, often for their needs or the needs of the agency. Often mandated by funding or regulatory agencies. Decided by management unilaterally, with little or no input from staff or children. Staff and children simply have to comply and live with the changes. It appears to them that no one cares. Simply telling staff and children what has become necessary and why and asking them for ideas on how to comply helps to make them feel a part of the team.
Perhaps the most classic example occurred in a large residential program for boys. It had with multiple units on a large campus. Each unit had it’s own kitchen and cooks. Boys awoke in the morning to the aroma of breakfast cooking. They returned in the evening to the aroma of dinner being prepared. There was interaction between the boys and the cooks. The cooks knew when the boys appreciated their efforts. They got feedback. Consequently, they worked diligently to prepare meals the boys appreciated. They liked doing it.
A new financial director determined that the agency could save money by using a centralized kitchen to prepare the meals, then transporting the food to two cafeterias on different sides of the campus. Staff then had to escort their boys to the cafeteria. The meals were not quite fresh. The cooks who prepared the food were not the people who served it. There was no aroma on the units. More, two vans had to be reserved and equipped for transporting the food, reducing the number of vehicles available for activities. There was no payoff for the children or the staff. The savings did not result in increases in allowances or activity funds for the children, nor increased salaries for the staff. The only benefit was an improved bottom line for administration. The message to kids and staff? You are not all that important.
People who feel a part of the team, including staff and children, work together to help the team succeed. People who do not feel a part of the team...Well, that’s where the us vs. them dynamic comes from–staff vs. management, kids vs. staff, ‘professional’ treatment people vs. child care staff. It’s ugly. It’s dangerous. And it doesn’t have to be that way.
Many things require only minimal money from typically limited agency budgets to improve things for staff and children. Rather, most things require significant effort. But the effort pays off.
The initial investment of time and energy results in lower turnover and less effort down the road to recruit, hire, and train new staff. Staff who feel a part of the team do not leave quite so readily. I have found it is worth the effort. It’s an investment that pays off in much less effort being required down the road.
More, it can lead to increased revenues. Getting donations is challenging, but people or groups or businesses are much more likely to contribute for specific things for the children, or perhaps even to recognize the staff, then they are to just contribute funds for the ‘mission’ of the agency. They will raise money for new recreation equipment or activities more readily than for the budget that includes things like salaries and food and office supplies–things either for the children or as a bonus for staff members who need to be commended, such as a gift certificate at a restaurant for dinner for two for valued staff members.
It is fun to improve things. And it pays off.