When I first started in the field of Child and Youth Care in the mid-1980s, I was told that the goal of my work was to make sure the kids behaved well. Other professionals would deal with any other needs of the kids, but this would only be possible if I did my job and ensured that the kids were well behaved, since the other professionals would not likely be able to do much for them if they were constantly ranting and raving about largely trivial things. In order to accomplish this task, I was given a behaviour management system that involved a rather complicated set of points and levels that when used effectively and consistently, would ensure that the kids knew who was in control.
Of course, I was also told that the kids were vulnerable and had experienced challenging lives, and that I was to be nice to them. I still remember very clearly the long instructions I was given about how to deal with the kids’ families. For the most part, I needed to understand that the parents were the problem, and part of my task was to protect the kids from these parents. I also was told to protect myself from any law suits and complaints by documenting any conversations I had with parents, and ideally by minimizing my exposure to them.
Once I figured out what the job actually was, I remember reflecting on why I got the job in the first place. After all, I had no prior experience working with young people, I was very young myself (I still am…), I had not been the most ‘successful’ kid (I knew many police officers by their first name), and I barely spoke English. I had absolutely no pre-service training of any kind (and I did not really receive any in-service training for several years). I certainly didn’t look very hireable (I had really, really long hair — I now choose to be balding) and at the time, I was protesting against the concept of shaving.
When I asked my boss why she hired me, I was told that I seemed very nice, and that kids might like me. I had a good sense of humour, and given that I had grown up in the midst of a (fairly violent) revolution, I might be able to relate to the issues of the kids. Initially I thought I had scored big, since this kind of job doesn’t actually exist in one of my home countries (Iran), and requires a University degree in the other of my home countries (Germany – a degree in social pedagogy). Here I was, completely unqualified and yet making six bucks an hour (twice the minimum wage at the time) hanging out with some kids who struck me as fairly cool and unproblematic.
Over time, I learned that my scenario was hardly unusual. As I got to know my team mates (in a residential program) I discovered that I was working with quite an array of individuals. My favourite was a British Lady with a thick accent from the Liverpool area, who had an obsession with cleaning everything with bleach. There was Brad, a clean cut guy whose goal it was to take over his father’s chemical company, Chris, a guy from way up north (Barrie, I think, about an hour north of Toronto) who, foreshadowing the coming fashion, sported a mullet, and another Brad, who at one time had been an assistant coach of the Canadian Olympic Karate team. And then there was the woman who was clearly the brain of the operation, which everyone agreed was no surprise since she was the only one who had actually completed the proper training for being a child and youth worker — she had a Social Services Certificate from the local College.
As a newcomer to Canada, this job was extremely helpful in overcoming my social adjustment problems. Every 3-11 shift started at 2 in the afternoon and ended at 1 in the morning, followed by an alcohol filled three hour de-briefing session at somebody’s house (basement apartment, more accurately). I vaguely remember there being some other goodies as well, but it is all a bit of a blur now.
And then I remember some of the things we did with the kids. There was the whole control thing — I would shout things like ‘that’s five’, which meant the kid lost five points that shift for swearing. I removed many stereos and other belongings from kids’ rooms as a consequence (punishment) for behavioural outbursts, and in extreme situations where kids were completely out of control and aggressive, I would perform my famous ‘airborne half twist to the floor’ restraint, which was much admired by my colleagues for its agility and artistic merit.
But I also remember some of the other things we did with the kids. We went on outings pretty much every day, exploring the region and beyond, usually with eight or nine persons in a seven seater minivan. We climbed cliffs, holding on to the ‘no climbing’ signs generously provided by the conservation authorities. We jumped into lakes wondering what the ‘Bacteria Alert’ signs meant, we did car washes so that we could afford to go camping, we played midnight games of capture the flag in a nearby forest, and we talked and talked and talked with the kids over hot chocolates and candy.
On special holidays, everybody would come to work to celebrate with the kids, we put on dances for the kids and danced with them, including to superhits such as Love Hurts and some of the great ballades of Triumph, and we played and played and played. When kids went AWOL, we’d just go with them, hanging out downtown and getting to know all of their friends. When a kid got a job at a gas station, we would all get gas only at that station, and when a kid got a job at a coffee shop, all coffee had to be purchased at that particular shop.
As a team, we were both a work team and a social unit. Everybody knew everyone’s else life stories. When someone had problems (which was a daily occurrence) we would plan ‘interventions’ (back to the alcohol and other goodies…). We didn’t really have team meetings, because every day was a team meeting of sorts. When we thought it would be good to meet, we quickly learned that we had already discussed everything informally and had nothing left to say.
In fact, when I reflect on my job experiences through the course of my adult life, there is no better one than those first four years of being a ‘child and youth worker’. I still know and am friends with some of my team members from that group home, and occasionally I hear about a kid from those days. My professional life came full circle about ten years ago, when I joined a child welfare agency as the Manager of Residential Resources. Ironically, that very first group home I had worked in years prior was one of several owned and operated by my agency. When I first re-entered the group home it felt oddly unfamiliar. Most things looked the same, but nothing felt the same. The staff were sitting in the office, the supervisor in his office, and the kids were either not present or they were sitting by themselves. There was a huge board in the hallway with posters from the Ministry about Children’s rights and responsibilities, and how to complain, and there was another bulletin board about Health and Safety rules. I noticed that there was no music and the house smelled neutral — no smell of bleach, smoke, or food! I also noticed that the phone was ringing pretty much all the time. I asked the supervisor who would be calling, and I was told that it might be a Child Protection Worker, a probation worker, a medical person, a community worker, a parent, someone from the psychologist’s or psychiatrist’s office, or a Ministry person chasing down a Serious Occurrence Report. Or it might be the police taking the information on a Missing Person, or maybe the HR or Finance people from the agency chasing down a document or a receipt. I started to wonder whether twenty years prior, the phone really didn’t ring or whether we just didn’t hear it because CCR’s “Fortunate Son” was in the house, or we were on a “Stairway to Heaven”, or we were doing the “Blitzkrieg Bop” with our friends, the Ramones.
So much has changed in what we have come to refer to as Child and Youth Care practice. As I encounter residential child and youth workers today, I am painfully aware that much of their time is spent doing things that have absolutely nothing to do with taking care of children. They are busy writing reports, making appointments, answering the phone, justifying their expenses, and consulting their union about employment issues. Sure, they absolutely care about the kids in the program as well. Many of the workers spend a great deal of time talking with the kids about their problems and offer endless solutions and approaches to making things better. Often workers bring in information about other services, or they call and make referrals on behalf of the kids. Certainly there is no shortage of engagement per se; child and youth work continues to be fundamentally about child and youth workers interacting with kids, notwithstanding ever-increasing administrative demands, ever higher accountability standards, and ever more complex situations arising out of the coexistence of employers, unions, and legislation such as the Occupational Health and Safety Act.
The standards related to the care provided in residential settings and elsewhere have also increased substantially. The licensing regulations for group homes contain rules about staff qualifications and certifications (none related to pre-service education), restraints are subject to a great deal of scrutiny and have to correspond to Ministry approved techniques, and policies and procedures are not only examined by licensing officers, but staff and kids are interviewed to see whether the activities correspond to such policies and procedures.
All of this is probably good. On the other hand, as I look at what actually transpires through the eyes of the kids, I am not at all convinced that this regulated, much safer, and generally better coordinated way of working with kids has improved anything through the eyes of those kids. I am quite certain that kids are experiencing a much more effective intervention with respect to the provision of targeted services, treatment, counselling, and other types of skilled or evidence-based approaches. But are they experiencing childhood or adolescence?? Are child and youth workers encouraged to do things with the kids that correspond to what most high functioning, socially competent, emotionally stable individuals would have experienced during their younger years? Things like impulsive decision-making, unplanned trips and activities, learning by trial and error (as opposed to an evidence base), breaking some rules, sidestepping adult expectations, developing their own language and method of communication, and generally practicing their comfort level within a disposition of non-conformity. What I am learning through my reflections in this context is this: progress, although necessary, is surprisingly unsatisfying.