Behavioural issues and diagnosed attention deficiencies appear to be on the rise in young children. This article discusses the impact that an industrial model for classroom management has on behavioural issues. Changing the paradigm of a school system to enhance outdoor experiences, in effect, creating a connection to nature, has been shown to increase cognitive functioning while decreasing resistance to classroom deficiencies. A program designed for seven-year-old children examined the relational aspects of these children in outdoor activities meant to stimulate collective intentionality in play. It was discovered that by offering relationship opportunities together with opening avenues for involvement in inherently interesting activities, cognitive functioning increased and behavioural issues were mitigated. This article demonstrates a need for continued research into the creation of a school system reliant on community, environmental and social awareness.
Introduction
During the past couple of years the topic of children’s behavioural issues and how to deal with them has dominated discussions in my household; in particular behavioural issues stemming from my sixyear-old son. I have quickly gone from the position of confident, competent adult to one of complete irrationality as the parent of a six-year-old refusing to eat a carrot: emotional responses to attempts at control seem to be coming from both of us. At the heart of my behavioural expectation is a desire to instil into my child an internal motivation to do the right thing: to eat that carrot because it is good for him. But the line between acting out of responsibility and performing for reward is often murky.
What makes me choose one way of acting over another? How has my society, my culture, influenced my choices? Is my primary role as parent or educator necessarily one of discipline towards children? I often consider how I will teach my child to be independent while I view actions like not eating a carrot to be a punishable offence; what lesson is he truly learning if he actually does not like carrots? A simple example in the mine-field of parenting, but one which opens up explorations of how children navigate through the many complex social relationships and situations we expose them to and expect them to understand. Perhaps instead, if we engage with the ‘messiness’ (Newbury, 2011) that structures our motivation for choosing one thing over another in any given moment we might be relieved of the sense of obligation to solve situations; rather, it could allow us the opportunity to embrace moments of reality, take what we need from them, and move forward.
The central focus of this article is twofold: firstly I explore the observations and experiences of six-year-olds in a twoweek summer program which I both designed and delivered. Secondly, I take a look at the larger picture of children’s social responsiveness in the context of this program; how they develop an understanding of selfand social awareness. Our cultural dependence on reward and punishment and competition, together with a school system forged in the image of industry, challenges the assumption that education is the creator of critical thinkers. Does the system we perpetuate diminish children’s inherent capacities for individual thought and collaborative processing? Is it my intention to condition my six-year-old son to accept that which is unpalatable, eating the carrot; or can I simply teach him to choose an acceptable alternative? Is the carrot issue mine or his?School curriculums that include outdoor based learning and teaching strategies such as scaffolding (explained later) offer two examples of fashioning systems that encourage creative and critical thinking by optimizing cognitive processes. I will scrutinize the structure of the school system, a key determinant in regulating how children are socially influenced, in an effort to understand the motivations guiding this current system.Finally, how do I choose to move forward with this knowledge and create better avenues for my work with children while preserving that inherent sense of wonder within a child and myself?
Intention, Plan, and Expectation
Intention
The intention of this project, which consists of a two week summer program together with continuing research, is to examine relational classroom dynamics in elementary school. The motivation behind creating the summer program began from behavioural concerns in the classroom with my own six-year-old child. Report cards indicated that academically he was exceeding expectations, but socially he was floundering. A socialite from the outset, my son has struggled with social expectation in the school setting. School based team meetings, developmental specialists, behaviour information workshops, and terrible three-hour-long temper tantrums became our standard fare. It was very difficult to separate what I wanted as a mother and what I felt I needed to do as a Child and Youth Care worker.
From a Child and Youth Care perspective my research specifically involves investigation of extended outdoor learning as part of school-based curriculum to help fulfill a theorized need for better social skill acquisition and enhanced cognitive processing. I am interested in how children learn social expectations: how their behavioural responses relate to their environments. I will incorporate observations from my own involvement as the facilitator of the summer program to provide a platform for discussion and exploration.
Much of the direction for this research is rooted in a unique Eco-Immersion program in its’ pilot year at a local school. As part of the school system, this program specializes in French immersion with an emphasis on outdoor-based, Montessori-like education (see The Montessori Foundation, 2011). The program came with a great deal of support from the school board and like-minded parents intent on creating a better option foreducation. It was with a great sense of relief that we sent Liam into grade one.
However, the issues with Liam not only continued, they seemed to get worse. It is possible that the class make-up (mainly boys) contributed to Liam’s number of ‘accidents’, as in playing pinball tag and ‘accidentally’ injuring another child in the rough-and-tumble physical-contact way boys tend to play. But more likely the answer lies in discovering his individual developmental needs: how he processes psychological needs, how he interprets relationships, how he keeps track of his growing body, and how all that fits in a classroom environment. Liam is just as liable to accidentally choke someone as the Superhero saving the day as he is to glue his hand to his hair while sharing quality time with Grandpa. As I was to eventually learn through other parents, this behaviour was echoed among the boys in his class. I created a small summer program to see for myself.
Plan
The plan was to offer educational opportunities through social activities, in contrast to a traditional model of learning which teaches social expectation through educational avenues; this is a subtle but important distinction when trying to understand the intent and motivation behind kids’ choices. Dr Greene’s (n.d.) theory that kids do well when they can is evident in children like my son who excel socially when the pressure of over-stimulating classrooms is taken away.
The program incorporated individual and group challenges. The kids built a shelter, went through a ropes course, practiced yoga, learned about a berry farm, interviewed seniors, explored tidal pool habitats, and learned the art of whittling and lighting fires. We talked about leadership, friendship, working together, good choices, and flatulence. Conversations occurred naturally, discussion was encouraged, and any questions were welcomed and answered. As much variety and as many self-directed individual and group activities as possible were offered within the time slot of ten morning sessions.
Of primary importance to me in planning this program was to allow avenues for the exertion of energy. The extraordinary energy levels of young children are not to be ignored. Dewey (in Warde, 1960) asserted that the energetic side of a child’s nature should take precedence in early education because that is what they need. Cognitive ability is stunted when physical activity is curbed.
Expectation
Through the course of the summer program, I expected to gain more insight into how groups of children form together, define their relationships, accomplish different tasks, and function in a variety of environments. Specifically, I wanted to observe how these children experience their development of self-awareness and how it relates to their experiences as a group in order to better understand what was happening in their classroom. What is it that we need, as educators and role models, to effectively translate the expectations of classroom, and ultimately, social engagement? We do not have behavioural issues when we are alone. Someone other than us in the room decides that a certain way of behaving is acceptable or unacceptable to them. Again, are perceived behavioural problems my issue or the child’s?
I expected that through the use of inherently interesting activities – activities that engage involuntary attention (explained later), activities that encourage movement, and activities that are student led – I could gain insight into avenues that might improve the classroom experience for students and teachers. I needed to take a big step back and examine systemic deficiencies inherent in classroom environments that can block the educational needs of young children by assuming that the deficiencies exist in the children as individuals. I expected to observe that supporting the relational components of early childhood learning can be a step towards cultivating critical thought and social capacities in young children.
I anticipated little to no behavioural issues and increased positive social behaviours during my two week summer program. I expected some resistance to rainy days and predicted high physical activity levels. I planned the sessions in the morning as my assumption is that typically children function better in the morning. I expected to change direction with activities if the situation warranted; in effect, to engage a relational approach to Child and Youth Care.
Snapshots of Reality
This section examines two specific events during the two week program that demonstrate the type of activities the children engaged in. These examples will serve as concrete anchors throughout the remainder of the article.The first day of the program saw four happy faces ready to experience a plane crash (imagined) and be tasked with building a shelter. The kids gathered materials and helped each other carry objects during the twenty minute hike up to the site. The kids were handed two packages: one with food and one with supplies. The boys immediately got stuck into eating while Lily examined the clippers and twine and began to prepare a site for a shelter.
The boys, unsure of what exactly Lily was doing, left to find their own site nearby. They went off in different directions and experimented cutting branches off a fallen tree with the clippers, tied twine around branches to drag, and fired imaginary machine guns at imaginary foe. Interventions to assist their collective thinking and offer ways to proceed with the shelter, three at about ten minute intervals, proved unhelpful. Lily completed her own shelter.
Tummolini, Castelfranchi, and Rakoczy (2006) examine Piaget’s theory of the pre-operational stage (ages two to seven) and the development of collective intentionality in play. Further, they explain that it is unclear how the development of an understanding of another’s pretence, a requirement for joint play, develops from solitary pretending. Piaget theorized (in Tannock, 2011) that by practising the social aspect of play, skills learned will lead to the concrete operational stage (ages seven to eleven) and the development of games with rules and structure. From this, group acceptance begins to take hold. My sense was that these children needed more group direction, not necessarily individual direction: a socially oriented answer to a social problem – achieving a shared social pretence.
In contrast to the observed lack of shared social pretence of the shelter building exercise, the following day thekids were presented with a Zunga activity: a suspended rope with a big knot on the end to swing on. On either side of the clearing were platforms, in between which was an imagined poisonous pit. The task was to swing to one platform, pick up a ball and bring it back to the original platform. Unlike the shelter building exercise, the kids decided on their own whose turn it was, how to retrieve the rope from the middle when it was dropped, and how to carry balls between the platforms. They showed empathy when one child dragged himself, organized more space to land on the platform, assisted each other in landing, and cheered each other on: all examples of a shared social pretense or collaboration.
Of particular note was their choice not to choose a leader. No child inherently stood out and accepted total responsibility; rather, they each contributed to the accomplishment of the task in different ways. Interestingly, in the shelter exercise, a clear ‘leader’, by adult standards, existed: Lily knew how to build a shelter. But the boys were more fascinated with what Erikson (in Santrock, MacKenzie-Rivers, Leung, & Malcomson, 2008) describes as developmentally recognized interests such as experimenting with the tools provided. We examined the roles of leader and follower at a later time and all of the children expressed that they wanted to be leaders, and we discussed what this meant for them in a group.
Initially I felt that the shelter exercise was not as successful as the Zunga because there was a clear accomplished outcome in the Zunga by my standards. However, viewing these two exercises as either failure or success simplifies the real nature of play and the implications of what was learned by the children: that shared social intent is like any other skill acquisition. Through scaffolded learning we can also learn how to engage collectively.
What I Actually Ended up Learning
“I can’t wait until I grow up”. Why? “Because then I will have lots of responsibility”.
I have learned a great deal from my two weeks with the kids and my research. This section will offer an account of how schools are structured and how we can improve on the teaching methods used by employing strategies such as scaffolding. I examine the systemic use of reward and punishment. Finally I highlight the theory of group-think. Our collective ability to ensure an educational process free from behavioural labels and standardization begins with an understanding of why we ascribe to that model in the first place.
The model of industrial education
To understand how the school system affects learning, I needed to understand the motivations behind choice of content and delivery within that system. School is an integral part of our culture and an undeniable influence on how we behave and socialize. Dewey (in Wikipedia, 2011) believed that the ideal school is not just a place to gain a predetermined set of skills, but a place to learn how to live: a realization of a student’s full potential and the ability to use acquired skills for the greater good. But the school system was created at the turn of the last century by the needs of industry, not formed by social consciousness (Robinson, 2010).
Robinson (2010) describes the formation of the educational system as being focused primarily on academics; however, he further explains that critics at that time argued that education would be wasted on under-privileged kids because they were incapable of learning. Robinson’s view is the educational system therein became a dual-purpose system in which it served a purpose in the workforce and made assumptions about social structure and capacity: that there existed academic people and non-academic people and the system, not the student, decided which were which. Intellectual attainment was distanced from practical everyday occupational tasks (Warde, 1960). Evolution of that industrialized, business-minded model still sees the role of education as predominantly preparing our children for entrance into the economies of the 21st Century; but how do we effectively educate our children, if this is our goal, given that we are unable to predict what the economy will look like next week (Robinson, 2010; Klein & Lewis, 2011)?
Economic and industrial reasoning play major roles in structuring the formula for deciding school content and delivery. Computer time has been mandated for elementary students in my district: by grade four they will be responsible for creating a Power Point presentation. Weizenbaum (in Armstrong & Casement, 1998) views computer use in the classroom as “a solution in search of problems” (p. 3); an assumption that intelligence begins with the solution and not the process to it. I was unable to locate evidenced based practice studies to indicate the validity of technology use by nine year olds in elementary school. Quite the opposite.
Children are already getting, on average, approximately seven hours per day of screen time with a combination of technological devices (Harper, 2011). Technology overuse – TV, videogame, cell phones, hand held devices, computers, and the internet – is contributing to increasing levels of psychological, physical, and behavioural disorders in children which in turn is increasing prescriptions of psychotropic medication (Rowan, 2011). Further, Robinson (2010) indicates an alarming increase in diagnosed attention deficit disorders. He links this increase to intensely over-stimulating environments, under-stimulating school experience, standardized testing, media, and technology use. There is overwhelming evidence that technology is detrimental to the development of a child and we are giving them more.
Berman (2008) explains that technology over-use is a stress on children’s cognitive control processes, or directed attention: directed, or voluntary, attention resolves conflict while suppressing distracting stimuli such as crossing a busy street or solving a math problem in a noisy classroom (Berman, 2008). Directed attention also plays a role in cognitive function and a child’s ability to self-regulate things like short term memory, attention span, and memory retention which can determine success at school.
Berman (2008) further explains that involuntary attention, on the other hand, is used when we interact with environments that are inherently stimulating such as nature or the Zunga pit in the snapshot described earlier. This enables directed attention mechanisms to take a break allowing for better cognitive functioning when demanding environments are re-introduced. From personal experience, as a parent and Child and Youth Care worker, I have found that nature based learning can address many concerns currently affecting classroom environments: too loud, too bright, too crowded, too noisy, too busy or too much. This finding is echoed in Well’s (in Lang, 2003) study that linked better cognitive function with increased connection to nature. Directed attention is not being given a chance to replenish, particularly when the school yards are simply extensions of the classroom with few areas free from concrete, play structures, or other kids. (It is interesting to note that while governments offer money towards technology purchases in the school, parents are responsible for raising money to improve school playgrounds, furthering the agenda of business models for education.)
Participating in activities that allow for rests in directed attention indicates that one could increase the ability to focus and concentrate on tasks later that depend on directed attention abilities. An interesting observation with the kids in the summer program was that their cognitive functioning increased in the afternoon, contrary to my assumption, once the activities were done. Reports from the parents echoed my realization that the kids were happy to self-direct in the afternoon. They socialized better, they listened well, there were few behavioural issues, and their ability to focus on tasks was improved. Perhaps a classroom system that is designed to take advantage of learning outdoors in the morning with more intense cognitive tasks in the afternoon is worthy of study.Contrary to the industrial model of education that focuses on concrete outcomes such as standardized testing, nature based educational models focus on “giving students the necessary skills to think critically about personal choices and the relationships between society, economy, culture and the environment” (Barfoot & Westland, n.d.). And contrary to the lack of testing that would indicate more technology in education is better, nature based learning has vast examples and evidenced based practice to support its’ place in today’s schools (see Barfoot & Westland, n.d.; Harper, 2011; Saskatchewan Eco Network, 2011; Willis, 2008).
The simple fact that currently nature based programming exists as therapy for kids who are unable to cope in the school system, primarily with attention disorders, should be enough evidence to support incorporating it into the school system proper. We do not send children with attention deficit disorder to video game therapy, we engage them with nature.
Documented effects of interacting with nature show improved cognitive functioning and an over-all sense of well-being; from a therapeutic perspective, there are no side effects, it is readily available, and there is no cost (Berman, Jonides, & Kaplan, 2008). My son lost recess privileges often because of his rambunctiousness in the classroom; instead he attended Problem Solving in the Library and was made to write out his mistakes. Is there logic in denying a six-year-old child the chance to work off accumulated energy? This is a very good example of how the current system places the deficiency on the child rather than the classroom.
Scaffolding to greater heights
The industrial model of education leaves little room for apprentice-type learning, or scaffolding. Grouping children by age alone does not address the many barriers to learning: learning styles, teaching styles, cognitive ability, physical and mental challenges, compliance patterns, and temperament (see MacDonald, 2005;Robinson, 2010). A highly effective answer to this dilemma, one that can be applied proactively to young children, has been to teach students tasks using the technique of scaffolding.
Predominantly a child-initiated process at home (Gauvain, 2006), scaffolding is a learner focused progression of acquiring new skills. This differs from school-based learning which tends to be teacher focused. Gauvain identifies that scaffolding is a social learning process which, when taking place at home, includes many partners: parents, siblings, and grandparents.
Gauvain explains that socially we set the boundaries of learning: physically we define where and how children can explore; intellectually we limit or direct requested knowledge; and emotionally we focus their enthusiasm and interests.
When used in a school setting, scaffolding resembles the teaching style of an apprentice model (Schwarz, in Weber, 2010, p118). Students are shown how to accomplish a task then the instructor provides feedback that allows the student to do the task independently. Unlike apprentice positions that focus on immediate job training, scaffolding aims to present the students with a wide variety of avenues of interest. Where scaffolding differs from traditional teaching styles in the school system is that this model is student led.
Success is determined by both the abilities of the student as well as the instructional methods of the teacher. If the student is not succeeding, then the student and teacher determine why – a relational approach rather than blaming. This process requires addressing the deficiencies in the system rather than the deficiencies in the child.
During the course of the summer program there was very little social interruption. The kids were afforded the opportunity to join at their own pace and experience in their own comfort level. Resistance to situations, whether from fear, apprehension, or lack of understanding, can manifest itself in many forms such as anger, aggression, tears, or anxiety. For example, during the program, one child needed extra time before engaging in events that required physical demands. He watched the event and eventually indicated readiness to join in. Again I am reminded of Greene’s (n.d.) mantra: kids do well when they can. When you allow a child to assume some control over demanding environments, such as delaying participation, they learn new skill sets to overcome anxiety with certain tasks. Scaffolding enables the child to determine readiness; an important skill in learning how to manage risk.
Another aspect of incorporating scaffolding into early childhood education is the developmental readiness to master knowledge and intellectual skills. With an intense enthusiasm for learning, children will initiate many opportunities for new experiences. Erikson (in Santrock, MacKenzie-Rivers, Leung, & Malcomson, 2008) presents this theory of development as the fourth of eight stages: industry versus inferiority. In this stage Erikson posits that a child’s interest in how things work and a natural preoccupancy with making, building, constructing, fixing, and solving leads to a greater sense of self. When adults interpret this industry as making a mess, or failing, it leads to a sense of inferiority within the child. An emphasis on collaborative approaches, rather than competitive approaches, and scaffolding rather than task-oriented learning, was at the heart of this summer program. If a system is designed to emphasize building together while supporting each other, I believe that self-confidence rather than a feeling of incompetence can be fostered.
Taking the two scenarios from the summer program described earlier, one could view the first group exercise (the shelter building) as a failure and the second (the Zunga) as a success; after all, one outcome was productive while the other seemingly haphazard. But by identifying elements of progress that embrace scaffolding, the outcomes yield better results. These kids knew how to work together in the first exercise, not just the second; they did not magically learn how to work collaboratively overnight. And there was inherent interest in both, that is, both scenarios engaged them. Perhaps one difference was that the majority of children knew how to tackle the Zunga activity while only one knew how to tackle the shelter. The kids inherently relied on scaffolding amongst themselves, not adult leaders, to produce the collaborative effect of the Zunga. These are pretty cool results for a group of six-year-olds. By creating a program that was designed to emphasize building together, I inadvertently supported the development of a shared social intent. The kids learned to foster their own sense of self-confidence without competition and without reward and punishment.
The story of reward and punishment
A spontaneous comment of “I can’t wait to grow up” from Liam begged the question: why? Perhaps one of the most significant learning moments for me during this process of research was Liam’s reasoning for wanting to grow up: “because then I will have lots of responsibility”.
Liam has made a link between responsibility and privilege; when you are able to make good choices, when you are able to manage risk, you are able to participate in more and bigger things on your own.The school system’s reliance on punishment and reward structures, right and wrong answers, and first and last competitive thinking negate assumptions of functionality by encouraging a child to perform for reward rather than desire.
Pervasive in our traditional interchanges are the assumptions of universal logic (Gergen, McNamee, & Barrett, 2001) and the single story (Adichie, 2009). For example, a child is motivated to do the right thing for fear of consequences or anticipation of reward. Why would that child not be motivated by the desire to do the right thing because it is the right thing to do? If we teach a child to perform for reward then when does she become independent? Are we not teaching dependence?
Reward systems fly in the face of intuitive motivation that desires autonomy, mastery, and purpose (Pink, 2010). If schools maintain a bureaucratic model of hierarchy then students will learn compliance instead of independence.
Self-direction engages students and encourages creative and critical thinking. I have found that autonomy from adult direction is a sought over commodity for six-year-olds: Liam’s recognition of privilege through responsibility. Mastery of something, such as riding a bike, feels great; kids inherently master things with no need of a reward. This is supported by Erikson’s (in Santrock, MacKenzie-Rivers, Leung, & Malcomson, 2008 p.45) theory, that six to twelve year olds are preoccupied with mastering physical and intellectual problems. A great example of collective autonomy, mastery, and purpose theory at work was the Zunga activity.
The kids were not rewarded for working together, not punished for making wrong choices, and they were not motivated by candy to complete the task. And yet, they were inherently motivated to accomplish the activity together. They were self-directed, they learned from their mistakes – an element of scaffolding – and they engaged each other in creating solutions. Nature based learning and teaching strategies like scaffolding remove our outdated, single story mentality that competition is a necessary part of learning. Resisting the reliance on right answers creates opportunities for discovery of new answers.
When we change the single story as the adult we also influence our own perspective on the situation. White’s (2008) approach to understanding situational awareness provides us the opportunity to view intent as an important component of an action: not simply our own adult version of intent, but a child’s personalized interpretation of an event. Rather than punish a child for accidentally kicking a ball into the stomach of another child during a game, we gathered as a group, listened to the injured child, empathized, and discussed the need for control of our bodies and objects when we are near others. The single story of punishment which assumes malicious intent which in turn fosters isolation and shame was avoided in favour of solving the issue collectively. In effect, I took advantage of scaffolding learning by socially constructing emotional boundaries: I demonstrated compassion for each child regardless of the situation.
Group Think
An important aspect of learning to work together is the understanding of the power of “group-think”; in effect, evolution has taught us that those who cannot recognize and heed emotional cues of others cannot survive long (Perry, 2006). Those cues are vital to our ability to achieve social success despite our own intelligence, common sense, or education. Dr. Seuss (1961) presents this concept of social conformity using Sneetches: those with stars on their bellies versus those without. The struggle to gain acceptance with the perceived popular group in itself creates an unpopular group.
For the boys in the summer program, a lovely expression of friendship, a comment of “you are my best friend, John” elicited a tearful response from Liam: “you said you were my best friend, Gabe.” What followed was an examination with the boys of what it means to be a friend, the power of words, and how relationships can change. I believe the need in adult society to fit in is misconstrued as a need for conformity – external – rather than a need for acceptance – internal. As I saw with the Sneetches and with Liam, when they learned to accept each other for who they were instead of what they thought they were, the need for competition evaporated. A quirk of human nature, we make choices based on our own inner feelings; however, we tend to discount what others feel and say and instead rely on their actions (Csikszentmihalyi, 1997).
Learning as Forward Motion
Allowing kids to self-direct and master skills through strategies such as scaffolding ensures their ability to create purpose through good choices. Our assumption that as adults we know the true path and hold all the answers only limits our own growth and possibility – and theirs. How do we really know that what we are doing is helping; if there is a better way, what is it? Mahoney (1991) contends that change is not in itself the answer because we seek change ‘for the better’ and not ‘for the worse’. Human psychological development is influenced by emotionally charged relationships and the relationship with self. Mahoney seeks to explain that we must respect the influence of the individual on the system just as the system influences the individual.
I view the educational system as a component of Child and Youth Care, not a stand-alone institution. Our compulsion to separate out the very elements of social interaction that influence our responses within that system reduces our ability to affect change on a systemic level. Situational awareness within the school system allows for an understanding of the dynamics at play (Newbury, 2011) rather than discounting the influence of contexts such as home life and vice versa. We are all integral components of the system, of the culture, of the community that sways our decisions in how we choose to participate. Child and Youth Care practice should be a necessary component of the educational process, not just the therapeutic answer when the system lets the kids down.
Dewey (in Warde, 1960) proposed almost one hundred years ago that the school system should be a place for the development of social consciousness. Schools have adapted, succumbing to determined, persevering parents, to embrace community needs such as the inclusion of Aboriginal classes and by allowing programs such as the Eco-Immersion class to exist in my district. But they are still an integrated part of the industrialized system which measures outcomes in a standardized way. If these programs fail to make the grade,so-to-speak, their existence is threatened. Technology, on the other hand, has failed socially for young children (Rowan, 2008) yet its existence seems to be guaranteed and is nurtured in our culture. Why not make the computer courses the extra-curricular activity and instead mandate five hours per week of outdoor instruction?
Warde (1960) contended that children are a marginalized group by virtue of their inability to formulate collective grievances or organize for improvements in their conditions or mode of education. Further, he advocates the assistance of adults who are sensitive to these impairments to act as spokespersons resolved to remedy the situations. I worry that the work of Child and Youth Care practitioners connected to the school system has evolved, in large part, into a reactionary stance. With so much evidence that clearly indicates outdoor learning to be an effective accompaniment to education (for example Abrams, 2001) and evidence that clearly indicates technology to be detrimental (for example, Armstrong & Casement, 1998), we are still locked in a system that we perpetuate. A Child and Youth Care praxis-oriented approach to collective change is an ethical, self-aware, responsive, and accountable (White, in Bellefeuille & Ricks, 2008) collection of skills necessary to affect change processes for the benefit of young children.
Forward motion is in creating awareness. As Newbury (2011) explains, situational analysis will not necessarilyyield new practices to deal with the issues plaguing our school system, but it can offer a platform for discussion. For example, rather than continuing the conversation surrounding attention deficit disorders from a child focused viewpoint, perhaps the conversation can include a wider understanding of proactive interventions, such as those I explored in my summer program. When we look at behaviour disorders as a result of societal dysfunction we can understand the issue from a systemic perspective and begin to look at organizational changes.
Conclusion
I run a daycare, but I am not a teacher; my only experience lately in the school system is as an involved parent. My observations that outdoor learning can be a valued daily component in the educational system is based on an understanding that schools are needed to teach community, environmental, and social awareness. This is also the same understanding that led to the emergence of the new Eco-Immersion program in which Liam is enrolled. The industrial and economic agenda that determines content and delivery of knowledge and shapes the face of many social interactions is not working. Klein and Lewis (2011) advocate taking a big step back to return to the grass roots, as it were, in education. They suggested that local solutions to local problems be sought: such as the continued support of the Eco-Immersion program. I am looking forward to increasing my knowledge of the school system as I journey through with my son. As well, I hope to examine the process and the impacts of locally organized programs such as investigation of funding sources for an environmentally based playground at Liam’s school.
Finally, I would be remiss if I did not take an opportunity to recognize and acknowledge the people who volunteered their time and efforts to helping make the activities for the summer program come alive. Social consciousness and a sense of community exist because we create it despite the industrialized notion that says ‘money makes the world go around’.
References
Armstrong, A. & Casement, C. (1998). The child and the machine: Why computers may put our children’s education at risk. Toronto, Ont: Key Porter Books Limited.
Abrams, I.S. (February, 2006). People, plants, and kindness: A model horticulture science project. CYC-Online , Issue 85. Retrieved August 19, 2011 from: https://www.cyc-net.org/CYC-Online /cycol0206-abrams.html
Adichie, C. (October 7, 2009). The danger of a single story. TedTalks: Youtube. Retrieved July 20, 2011 from: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D9Ih s241zeg
Barfoot, R. & Westland, K. (n.d.). Sustainability and ecological education [webpage]. Retrieved July 23, 2011 from: http://www.outdoors.sd47.bc.ca/
Berman, M.G., Jonides, J., & Kaplan, S. (2008). Cognitive benefits of interacting with nature. Retrieved July 22, 2011 from: http://web.ebscohost.com.ezproxy.librar y.uvic.ca/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?sid= a00a9502-7c59-4cf8-88b3-35444dd2caf9%40sessionmgr115&vid=2&hid=126
Brown, J. (July 21, 2011). The Current: Soft playgrounds [CBC radio broadcast]. http://www.cbc.ca/video/#/Radio/The_Current
Csikszentmihalyi, M. (1997). The content of experience. In Finding Flow: The psychology of engagement with everyday life (pp. 17-34). New York: Basic Books.
Davidson, L. (2007). Qualitative research and making meaning from adventure: A case study of boys’ experiences of outdoor education at school. Journal of adventure education and outdoor learning, 1(2), 11-20.Retrieved July 21, 2011 from: http://www.tandfonline.com.ezproxy.libr ary.uvic.ca/doi/pdf/10.1080/14729670185 200041
Gauvain, M. (2006). Scaffolding in socialization. Retrieved on July 21, 2011 from: http://www.sciencedirect.com.ezproxy.li brary.uvic.ca/science/article/pii/S0732118 X06000183
Gergen, K., McNamee, S., & Barrett, F. (2001). Toward a vocabulary of transformative dialogue. International Journal of Public Administration, 24(7), 697-707.
Greene, R.W. (n.d.). Lives in the balance [webpage]. Retrieved May 4, 2011 from: http://www.livesinthebalance.org/.
Klein, N. & Lewis, A. (July 17, 2011). Global warming [talk]. Hosted by CJMP Radio Station, Recreation Complex, Powell River, B.C.
Harper, N. (2011). Active and outdoors Child and Youth Care practice: Hardly innovative, highly effective. As presented by Dr. Harper at the Child and Youth Care in Action III: Leading Conversations in Research, Practice & Policy at the University of Victoria April 28-30, 2011.
Lang, S. (2003). A green scene can help rural children endure stresses, researchers find. Retrieved September 2, 2011 from: http://www.news.cornell.edu/Chronicle/0 3/5.8.03/nature_rural_stress.html
MacDonald, B. (2005). Boy smarts: Mentoring boys for success at school. Surrey, B.C.: Mentoring Press.
Mahoney, M. J. (1991). Can humans change? In Human change processes: The scientific foundation of psychotherapy (pp. 258-266). New York: Basic Books.
The Montessori Foundation (2011). Retrieved August 19, 2011 from: http://www.montessori.org/
Newbury, J. (2011). Situational analysis: Centerless systems and human service practices. Child & Youth Services, 32(2), 88-107
Perry, B. & Szalavitz, M. (2006). The boy who was raised as a dog. New York: Basic Books.
Pink, D. (2010). Drive: The surprising truth about what motivates us. RSA Animate: Youtube. Retrieved July 22, 2011 from: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u6X APnuFjJc
Robinson, K. (2010). Changing education paradigms. RSA Animate: Youtube. Retrieved July 21, 2011 from: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zDZ FcDGpL4U
Rowan, C. (2008). Zone’in: News and Media [webpage]. Retrieved July 21, 2011 from: http://www.zoneinworkshops.com/press/ learn-about-videogame-addictions-at-new -foundation-series-workshops/
Santrock, J., MacKenzie-Rivers, A., Leung, K., & Malcomson, T. (2008). Chapter 2: Prominent approaches in life-span development (pp. 40-65). In Life-span development (3rd Canadian Ed.). Toronto: McGraw-Hill Ryerson.
Saskatchewan Eco Network, (2011). Retrieved August 13, 2011 from: http://econet.ca
Seuss, Dr. (1961). The Sneetches and other stories. New York, New York: Random House.
Tannock, M. (2011). Observing young children’s rough-and-tumble play. Australasian Journal of Early Childhood 36(2). Retrieved August 19, 2011 from: http://web.ebscohost.com.ezproxy.librar y.uvic.ca/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?sid= 9c3cd368-87a5-4756-98ab-5805b8aba44 8%40sessionmgr15&vid=2&hid=12
Tummolini, L., Castelfranchi, C., & Rakoczy, H. (2006). Pretend play and the development of collective intentionality [online article] (p115). Retrieved August 13, 2011 from: http://email.eva.mpg.de/~rakoczy/pdf/pr etense_CollINT.pdf
Warde, W.F. (1960). John Dewey’s Theories of Education [online article]. Retrieved July 21, 2011 from: http://www.marxists.org/archive/novack/ works/1960/x03.htm
White, J. (2008). Chapter 4: The knowing, doing and being in context: A praxis-oriented approach to Child and Youth Care (pp. 109-134). In G. Bellefeuille & F. Ricks, Standing on the precipice: Inquiry into the creative potential of Child and Youth Care practice. Edmonton, AB: MacEwan Press.
Willis, J. (2008). Founder and principal consultant of Creative Toolbox and Fireside Adventures. Retrieved August 13, 2011 from: http://creativetoolbox.ca/ct/workshops/facilitators/