CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 144 FEBRUARY 2011

What Do You Expect?

John Stein

One of my education professors opened class one day with a parable.

On her first day, a few days before school ould start, the new teacher found a list of her students on her desk. Behind each name was a number ranging between 120 and 144. She thought to herself, “My what high IQs these children have. I will have to prepare lessons carefully to maintain their interest.” After a few months, her colleagues were remarking about how well her students were doing. Her principal asked her one day how she managed to motivate these children to come to school each day and perform so well. A bit taken aback, she replied that she thought working with such gifted children was a privilege, not a challenge. The principal asked what she meant. She told him about their IQs. The principal was now taken aback – he didn’t understand. She went to her classroom and returned with the list. “Oh that,” he said. “That’s their attendance for last year.” While 120 may be a respectable IQ, it’s a terrible attendance record for a school year of 180 days. Even 144 indicates 36 days’ absence–a day a week. As a new teacher, she had been given the worst students, not the best.

OK. You saw that (or something like it) coming. I doubt it was a true story, but there is truth in it. The moral is that children, like other people, tend to live up to (or down to) expectations – provided that the expectations are not out of reach.

I had planned to write about goals. One of the things I noticed about so many of the troubled kids with whom I worked over the years was that they had no goals, either short term or long term. They had little or no concept of the future. I would sometimes ask an adolescent where he saw himself at the age of twenty-five, what he thought his life would be like. I always got a blank stare. I would ask questions such as, “Where will you be living?” “What kind of job will you have?” “Will you have a car?” “Will you be married?” It seemed to me that their not having any goals was a significant aspect of the problems they were experiencing. Then I read the article on expectations by Kiaras Gharabaghi in January’s issue of CYC-Online , Small and Stupid. It made me think. The problem was not with goals but rather with expectations. Why would you have a goal if you had no expectation of achieving it?

I would have had trouble with those questions as a teenager. I had no goals. What I had were expectations. I expected to graduate high school and go on to college. I expected to get married and have a good job. I expected to have a nice apartment and a car. These were not goals, they were things I expected. More importantly, they were shared expectations – not just expectations that I had for myself, but expectations that my parents and my teachers had for me. More, even my peers had these expectations of me, as I did of them. We all expected these things.

It was not goals that governed my life in those days, it was the shared expectations of my community. My goals were simple day-to-day things – get a good grade on the physics exam, get a date for the dance, beat my best friend at basketball. It was my expectations that were more important, not only the expectations I had of myself but also the expectations I had of others and of the world in which I lived. I expected to behave well and to do well. I expected my peers to behave well and do well. I expected adults to treat me fairly. When I made a mistake, I expected adults to “correct me,” to explain what was wrong with what I did and what I could have done. If I studied for an exam, I expected to get a good grade.

So what about the expectations of troubled kids? What expectations do others have of them? Others like their peers, their parents, their teachers? Child and youth care workers? What expectations do they have of themselves? Do they expect themselves to go to school every day? If they do go to school, do they expect to learn? If they study for a test, do they expect to pass?

Do they expect to graduate? If they graduate, do they expect to be able to got to college or get a job? What kind of boyfriend or girlfriend do they expect to have? What do their peers expect of them? Do their parents expect them to do well in school? Their teachers? Their peers?

Perhaps even more importantly, do they expect to be safe? At home? At school? With their peers?

When I worked in the housing projects, I saw too many children who did not expect to succeed, children who did not expect to grow up to have a good job, no matter what they did in school. They did not expect it, their friends did not expect it, their teachers did not expect it, their parents did not expect it. Indeed, everyone might have wished for their success, but no one expected it. Wishes and dreams are only fantasies when there is little expectation of success.

Years later, when my wife worked with children going through the court system, she met kids who did not even expect to live to the age of twenty-five. How about that for expectations? What goals did they set for themselves?

When troubled children come into a residential program, do we explain what the rules are and what is expected? Do we then expect them to be compliant and docile? To stop being oppositional? To stop having temper tantrums? To stop lying? To stop stealing? To stop running away? Or do we realistically expect them to continue to have many of the same problem behaviors that brought them into treatment? And if we do, how do we begin to change expectations?

I always thought of the kids with whom I worked as “normal.” Their behavior, their feelings and emotions, perhaps their beliefs, values, or attitudes may have been outside normal limits, but I always believed that they learned quite normally. I believed that they learned all of their “problems” quite normally, given the circumstances presented to them. Consequently, I didn’t expect them to behave, but I did expect them to learn, provided we could arrange the necessary circumstances.

The challenge, then, is to create an environment where learning is expected, where everyone (not only the staff but also the kids) expects staff to teach and children to learn, to learn the how’s and why’s and skills associated with appropriate behavior.

I never saw anyone do this better than James Rogers. James was the program manager of a group home for twelve boys that relied heavily on a social skills curriculum – not making friends and such, but skills such as respecting adults, respecting peers, expressing anger appropriately, and accepting criticism. Seven skills were broken down into specific steps and staff were trained to teach the skills and coach the boys in their use. James supervised the staff and the living environment. When problems would occur (or erupt), and they sometimes did, James would stop everything. Sometimes he would take a boy who was having a problem to his office. Other times he would assemble the group in the dining room. He would talk a bit about the problem. Soon he would get to his classic routine, which all of the boys learned pretty quickly:

James: Who’s the adult here?

Adolescent: You are, James.

James: Who’s the child?

Adolescent: I am.

James: What’s the adult’s job?

Adolescent: To teach.

James: And what’s the child’s job?

Adolescent: To learn.

James: Am I doing my job?

Adolescent: Yes, James.

James: Are you doing your job?

Adolescent: (quietly) No.

(James recognized only two types of people, children and adults. These tough adolescents accepted this from James because he always treated children like adults, with the utmost respect, except for this one distinction.)

Then James would begin teaching. Although capable of delivering a powerful lecture, his strength was in the way he asked questions to make the boys think “How do you think Bobby feels when...?” “How do you feel when...?” “Do staff ever treat you like that?” “How would it look if I did that?” He made the boys think about things such as feelings and values and the results of their behavior. Then he would walk the boys through the steps of the social skill that was the problem. All the boys learned the steps of all the skills within their first few weeks. They could recite them verbatim. The problem was not in learning the skills but rather in learning to use them in the day to day challenges of daily living. James helped the boys to learn how to apply their skills, coaching them in their use of the skills. Then James would return the boys to normal activities.

James did not use his “Who’s the adult?” routine every day, just often enough to establish and maintain the shared expectations that adults would teach and children would learn. At times, James would use the “Who’s the adult?” routine in support of staff, or to process something that happened in school:

James: Who’s the adult here, you or Suzanne?

Adolescent: Suzanne.

James: Who’s the child?

Adolescent: I am.

James: What’s Suzanne’s job?

Adolescent: To teach.

James: Is Suzanne doing her Job?... And so on.

But James and his staff used the teaching part daily.

The other expectation that is necessary is the expectation of success. Many of the children who come to the attention of Child and Youth Care workers have had little experience with success, beginning with their relationships. More likely, their success had to do with ending relationships, with leaving one placement after another and one school after another, starting with their own homes. Or success with deviant activities, sneaking cigarettes or drugs, shoplifting and theft, bullying others or manipulating adults and avoiding consequences, rather than success in school, athletics, music.

The first step is creating an environment where children feel safe, even to fail, an environment where they expect to remain, an environment that will not quit on them, no matter what. This requires developing a history of not discharging children for their behavior, where all kids expect to finish the program, whatever that may entail. The second step is making sure that children experience success by helping them set small goals for themselves that are realistically attainable, helping them to succeed, then helping them to recognize and appreciate their accomplishments. It must permeate the milieu, from helping them to do their chores well, to making sure they win once in a while in games and contests, to helping them plan and carry out an activity for the weekend, not just giving them goals on their treatment plan.

There were rarely consequences other than the teaching routine, except for the expectation that boys would do whatever was reasonably within their power to make things right. Consequences in the form of rewards and punishments in an attempt to coerce compliance contribute little to the creation of a learning environment. These things do not teach, at least not the things that children need to learn. Behavior is not controlled so much by the consequences that people might arrange as it is by values and beliefs and feelings and attitudes. These things determine what behavior is appropriate and important. It is these things that children must learn. These are the things adults must teach. More, coercion does little to help children feel successful.

There can be little satisfaction in making good choices when the choice is based simply on whether or not to get a reward or avoid a punishment. And so James created an environment where everyone expected adults to teach and everyone expected children to learn. The staff expected it and the boys expected it. The better the boys became at using the skills they learned, the better their lives got, in the group home, in school, and at home. People began to expect good things from the boys, and they began to expect good things of themselves. They began to experience success, especially in their relationships. Experience with success leads to increasing expectations of success and to self-confidence.

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App