Henry Maier wrote about this issue many years ago (Maier, 1987) and I
believe it may be a useful topic
for this month. When we work with
youth we often experience them not meeting the expectations we have
prescribed for them. It could be attending school, or completing a task,
or just getting out of bed. When we focus our attention on the ignored
expectation, we feel a loss of status or self-esteem, because our
behavioral goal was not met, and the typical reaction is to use power to
create the desired behavior.
Child and Youth Care staff can take a different, more developmentally focused view, and highlight the value of the expectation rather than the violation. Focus on the violation ultimately comes to revolve around authority issues and a power struggle, while continued concern with expectations maintains the original concern with what we value to be important.
We can emphasize supporting a youth to fulfill expectations in terms of their actual appropriateness rather than dealing with the non–compliance through punishment. Concern can center on the critical learning and creating support for mastery rather than the worker’s self-esteem. Learning strategies instead of control strategies become the focus of attention and this is easiest for workers who do not doubt their authority or power position.
When workers say things like “I don’t have to put up with that” or “these youth need to learn who is in charge around here”, the focus has shifted from the value of the task to the workers’ hurt feelings.
Our task in a developmentally based program is to support growth, teach new competencies, and reduce external control wherever it is useful. Punishment responses based on the need of the staff members to feel like they are in charge is an indication of a less experienced and somewhat fearful staff.
Child and Youth Care supervisors can support the team to focus on the value of the specific task and how it is necessary for the youth to learn useful things, rather than the power dynamics that arise through non-compliance or poor performance.
The challenge is to use a developmental lens rather than a behavioral lens to interpret and strategize when our expectations are not met.
Reference
Maier, H. (1987). Developmental group care of children and youth: Concepts and practice. (pp 78-79). New York: Haworth Press.