I recently survived my daughter’s sixth birthday party. The whole thing proved very challenging, and not only because I was recovering from the flu. Watching these girls communicate, cope with feelings, get along, and alternately, not get along, was educational and highly emotional, especially for me.
It all started innocently enough. Twelve little girls arrived, most with pretty tea party dresses on. The first game we played is “Cake Walk”, which is like Musical Chairs, except that everyone has a “place” so there is no need to push and shove. The person who is “out” is determined by drawing numbers. The girls loved dancing and jumping around to the music. We declared a winner and then I made my first (almost fatal) mistake.
I awarded a prize to the last one standing. The rest all literally turned on me demanding to know where “their” prize was. I was actually a little frightened by this response. Quickly, they were diverted by the offer of another game (and another prize). They roared their approval and raced to “Pin the Flower on the Teapot”, a cute version of pin the tail on the donkey. The blindfold goes on but something tells me we should have test run this one. The first one up put the flower squarely where it was required to go. Hmmm. The second one up did the same. Double hmmm. Then I heard someone whisper, “I’ll tell you the trick”. A more impenetrable blindfold was immediately located. “But I can’t open my eyes!” the next one protested. “Precisely the idea” I replied.
When everyone has had a turn, in my infinite wisdom, I award two more prizes (as there was a tie) and hope to move on. The protest is deafening. The two who have won are fighting over the (wrapped) prizes and those who have lost are howling their indignation. “Where’s my prize!” they wail. I consider raiding my daughter’s piggy bank and giving them money. At this point my husband feels it necessary to point out that he had “wondered about” my decision to award prizes at all, since there weren’t enough for everyone. Thank you ever so much but next time, could you please “wonder” out loud and prior to the event?
Apparently we are raising children who don’t win or lose, are never first or last at any cost. If you are going to have one prize, you must have a prize for all. We are to treat it like a golf tournament, where everyone wins something no matter how horrible they do at the game. Personally, I always win the crappy prize at the golf tournament and would rather go home empty handed than with the cooler bag shaped like a golf bag or the XXL golf shirt emblazoned with giant logos from motor oil companies. But that’s just me. I remember birthday parties when I was younger where I did not win a prize and I don’t recall suffering any kind of emotional breakdown that scarred me for life.
As we sit down for “tea” and cake, someone sits at the head of the table where my daughter wants to sit and won’t move. Tears are threatened. An intervention ensues and eventually, after much negotiation, peace is restored. The girls have juice in my mother’s precious demitasse cups, which is marvellous, except all the cups are different and there is much bickering over who gets which cup. The Barbie cake (the actual edible cake is the Barbie skirt and the plastic doll emerges out the top from waist up) is brought out and we all sing. My daughter is beaming, truly thrilled in her moment. Then I hear one girl declare, “I don’t like Barbie’s hair”. “Me neither”, agrees another, “and her dress is ugly too”. I want to cover Barbie’s ears so she isn’t offended. Only two girls bring up their dishes and say thank you (one of them being my daughter, only because she can probably see how frazzled I am).
I don’t know why I’m so shocked by any of this behaviour. Both of my children have often displayed undesirable behaviour, as have I and many other adults I know, come to think of it. Maybe because I remember how nasty girls can be and maybe because my daughter is so innocent and so far fairly uncorrupted that it has yet to occur to her to be nasty to someone just for the sake of being nasty. Watching all of this makes me quiver with fear and trepidation. How will she cope with the intricate balancing act of making and maintaining relationships throughout her life, let alone throughout elementary school?
Who these little girls are and how they connect with each other
depends on so much; their birth order, if they have siblings, the
parenting styles of the adults in their lives, their innate nature, what
they see modeled on a daily basis just to name a few factors. My
daughter is a first born, so her innocence seems to be lasting longer.
Those with older siblings are taught things much earlier, and I can
attest to that from personal experience. My daughter only learned the
alternate lyrics to Jingle Bells last year when she was five. My son is
just two and can already sing (with glee) “Batman smells, Robin laid an
egg”. So some of the girls with older brothers and sisters appear to be
more jaded and savvier while the ones who are the oldest are more apt to
be bossy and used to having things their way. Watching them all interact
and socialize is fascinating and extremely painful. I find myself
horrified yet unable to look away, like driving by a bad car wreck. They
learn by doing and whatever doesn’t kill them will make then stronger I
guess.
My daughter had opted out of having gifts and instead had a
“toonie” party.
Each child brought two toonies, one for the birthday girl (to buy something special for herself) and one for a charity (in my daughter’s case Habitat for Humanity), so we were spared the gift opening ceremony. Instead she opened cards that were made or signed by her friends and she took great joy in that. The girls all crowded around and watched with anticipation until their card was opened and then beamed with pride as it was admired and passed around. She still has all the cards in a special drawer and picks them up and looks lovingly at them.
In the end I may have been exhausted and a little shell shocked, but my daughter was beyond happy. To her, the party had been a huge success, and that, essentially, is all that matters. If she can come through a social event where some of the guests behave poorly, cheat at games, steal her seat, insult her cake, and she doesn’t win any prizes, then maybe, just maybe, she’ll be able to handle a grown up social gathering or life in general. I’ve been to many social gatherings where grown ups have behaved much worse than these amazing girls.
This experience has reminded me how wonderful and complicated being six can be. These girls are on the edge of the world, about to tumble in and experience it in all its ragged, nasty, astonishing glory. I imagine seven is just as awe inspiring, so I’d better get used to it. If my daughter takes after me at all (and I’m afraid she does), she’ll find herself to be hyper sensitive to the people she’s in relationship with in life. This will prove to be sometimes difficult, but should also make her empathetic and compassionate, not necessarily bad qualities. And if we want to bring out some killer instincts we can always play party games for piggy bank coin. “A work in progress”, as they say.
Originally published in Relational Child and Youth Care Practice, 19/2, Summer 2006