This column is another in a series of columns in which I have written about writing and morality in Child and Youth Care. I was moved to write it in a recent discussion about meaning making, reflective research, and a phenomenological approach to our work.
For many fiction writers, poetry is the truest way to portray an image or express a feeling. For example, prize winning novelist Roberto Bolano considered poetry the highest form of expression. He wrote poems when he is not working on his novels. Even though it was very difficult, he could say something in a few words than he could not say in the longer narrative form.
Some poems are written spontaneously like jazz. In general a poet works a poem until he or she feels it is just right or rings true. It can take days, months or years before it looks and sounds right. The author writes a first draft and returns (even to the ones written spontaneously) to it many times to try to capture the essence (hear it deep) of what he or she wants to say, or the picture the poem is intended to portray. The reader reads the situation in the moment as part of the larger whole, or their world view as shaped by their experience.
Similar to the way I wrote in October in this column (In the Spaces Between) about a Sam Shepard, playwright and poet of dialog in his own right, in most poems the spaces between the words are as important as the words. The poet attempts to invite the reader into the poem to contemplate and relate the images related to the readers own experience. The hope is that it will ring true for the reader as well, and this will make them curious enough to engage in a personal dialog or discourse with the work. Or to say, “Yes, that’s the way it is. I never thought of it that way, but that is the way I experience it. I understand. Or I want to understand more.”
The movement of words and the rhythm of a poem are crucial to its
success. The tempo has to be consistent with the mood the writer wants
to convey otherwise the poem does not read true.
So is the ability to
see a situation for what it is to the writer. When German poet Rilke
lost his way, sculptor Rodin told him to go to the zoo and look at the
animals until he could see them. Rilke went and looked at a panther for
days then wrote this poem which I have presented in this column in the
past (translated by poet Robert Bly):
The Panther
From seeing the bars, his seeing is so exhausted that it no longer holds anything anymore.
To him the world is bars, a hundred thousand bars, and behind the bars, nothing.
The lithe swinging of that rhythmical easy stride which circles down to the tiniest hub is like a dance of energy around a point in which a great will stands stunned and numb.
Only at times the curtains of the pupil out a sound ... then a shape enters, slips through the tightened silence of the shoulders, reaches the heart, and dies.
In this poem, which is about a panther not youth work, Rilke captures the experience of the caged panther in a few words. When I read it I am overwhelmed by its clarity and power. I can almost feel what the panther must have been feeling. I am unable to go to the zoo and not think of it. When I first read it, I compared it to the experience I had with troubled youth who lived caged in their community and how we had to create experiences and activities that would make the light shine from their eyes in our activities and interactions.
The line “Properly weathered places” in William Carlos William’s poem
Pastoral resonated almost immediately with my calling to escape the
American pastoral and work with youth in urban communities. Williams, a
medical doctor, was expressing how he felt more comfortable in places
with a history of aging and poverty. His work portrays both the struggle
and beauty of these places and the people in them.
In creating,
writing and speaking about moments in our work, perhaps we should be
more like the poet and try to capture the essence of what we want to say
while paying attention to the mood we care conveying with everyday
words. Poet Ezra Pound referred to this as the quest for fundamental
accuracy of statement, which he saw as the sole morality of poetry.
Much of the language and writing in our field is foreign to the way an event or conversation occurred. It is written sometimes to impress an imaginary audience of professionals, administrators and academics. Generally people like language that is clear and conveys an image of the situation the writer is trying to convey.
If we believe that our goal is to understand rather than prove, we should have confidence if we strive for fundamental accuracy of statement will advance our field just as poets have been instrumental advancing the social, cultural, and creative development of the world.
This is not to say that we should write poems in place of our reports in articles and conversations, but rather that we could learn from poets and the power of images and words that ring true and be a little more like them by choosing with care words that covey the images, feeling state, or analysis we are trying to share, including acknowledgment of the dualities and absurdities in our work. There is something very important about a line such as, “He got up from his chair and joined the activity” when presented in the context of a youth who had avoided involvement. Or, simply, “He smiled,” for a youth who had been “caged” in a life of despair. Properly placed in a vignette or case example, phrases like these can be very powerful in informing us and the reader or listener.