Defining to Exclude
Kiaras Gharabaghi
Lately there has been some discussion on CYC-Net and elsewhere about
defining the discipline of Child and Youth Care practice. Actually, the
discussion hasn’t really been about defining the discipline, but this
issue seems to always creep into whatever else it is we might be talking
about. In current discussions, attempts are made at stating specifically
what Child and Youth Care is and what it is not, fears are expressed at
the prospect of fragmenting or dividing the field based on language,
topics and themes, and the usual divisions amongst academics and
practitioners are variably lamented and celebrated. Our need to label
what we are talking about is an interesting phenomenon. Our need to
determine who gets to talk about what is also interesting but perhaps a
little worrisome. Our need to have opinions about how things ought to be
talked about is outright scary. And still, I am convinced that just
about everyone who has participated in the discussions as of late, and
perhaps most others involved in Child and Youth Care at some level
somewhere has pretty strong feelings about the whole issue of who
belongs and who does not. I can’t claim to be any different, and I have
thought a lot about why some contributions to the field are more
satisfying than others and why other contributions I find outright
offensive. I’ve come up with nine random self realizations:
- I think it is possible to simply be wrong and incompetent, and
some people are wrong and incompetent; I find it annoying to read
things written by them.
- I think everyone seeks to exclude others from their turf, and
Child and Youth Care as a discipline is very much a turf that we
protect and claim ownership of. I know I have a fairly distinct
image of our discipline that isn’t always theoretically sound or
practical, but it is deeply entrenched. I find opening the door to
expand or shift that image surprisingly difficult, but it helps to
be aware that my tendency is to try and exclude.
- Exclusion is a skill, and some people are very good at it and
able to exclude in ways that seem to suggest inclusion. The onus is
on the excluders to either acknowledge their desire to exclude or to
work harder to listen to the perspective of those not present (of
those feeling excluded). Very few people seem to do this work.
- I like it when occasionally, when the moment seems right, not
too often but perhaps more than once per year, we stop talking about
ourselves and our grand designs for the post modern nirvana of
perpetual deconstruction in the name of liberation (dogma) and make
even a faint reference to youth. That would be nice.
- I think the Canadian spelling of ‘behaviour’ is aesthetically
superior to the American spelling of ‘behavior’, and until this is
formally recognized, we should stop drawing any connections between
Child and Youth Care practice and behaviour/behavior.
- I find it offensive when some linguistic approaches to the
field claim ownership over the concept of
anti-oppression; in
fact, I find the most oppressive environments to be the ones that
demand of everyone to practice anti-oppression in the same way.
- I don’t think our field is at risk of being fragmented
or divided; I do think it is at risk of becoming (or perhaps
remaining) largely irrelevant.
- Amongst those who articulate their thoughts about the field
frequently and publically, I am always most impressed by those who
do so in lots of different ways, using lots of different languages,
and focusing on lots of different levels of abstraction, from the
very practical to the very abstract. I am less impressed by those
who resist any thought or approach that doesn’t immediately
translate into practice, but I am not all impressed by those who
seem to use language to mask a lack of knowledge and in the process
offend both the practitioners and the philosophers.
- I still believe that the drive to inclusion almost always
results in exclusion. Inclusion should not require a special drive
but simply be reflective of our humanity.
I know what you are thinking: hey look, he said he had nine points,
but clearly there are ten! To those of you who are simply wrong and
incompetent, I say “learn how to count!” To those of you who claim
ownership over anti-oppression, I say “who are you to say how many
points there are?” To those of you who worry about the fragmentation of
the field, I say “whose side are you on”? And to the children and youth
I have met over the years, I say “give me five”!