CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 144 FEBRUARY 2011

Declaring War on Children

Gerry Fewster

Larry Baumgart’s “Warning to Parents” was a painful and familiar cry. Acknowledging that his own 13-year-old daughter had chosen the Family, friends, teachers, and police are seen as helpless while the professionals in the “self-fulfilling bureaucracies” are more “street culture” over “family values,” despite the “reasoning, coercion, bribery and intimidation” used to keep her safe at home, he declares a state of war and then sets out in search of the enemy.

He begins with the kids themselves – particularly those who prey upon the unwary and seduce new members into the transgressions and addictions of street life. Then he targets the philosophers and the law-makers who have been more committed to protecting the rights of children than with providing “deterrents” to effectively enforce their obedience.

Family, friends, teachers, and police are seen as helpless while the professionals in the
“self-fulfilling bureaucracies” are more concerned with the problems of their own “woefully inadequate services” than with the desperation of yet another parent looking for help. But, according to Baumgart, it is the “Generals” – the government ministers and elected officials – who are losing the war on the kids of the street culture. These are the people who should be taken to task and held accountable.

The pain, anger, and frustration of this parent is readily understandable to all who have found themselves screaming helplessly from the sidelines as their children turn Dungeons and Dragons into real-life dramas. His “warning” is bound to strike fear into the hearts of those who continue to watch their young ones struggle to come to terms with these confusing times.

But, however much we fear for the future and however much we feel rejected by those we claim to love, we cannot allow ourselves to declare war on our own kids. We cannot call upon the school, law enforcement, social service, and mental health systems to become our champions on an intergenerational battlefield. And we cannot reasonably expect our senior bureaucrats and lawmakers to replace the glue that seems to have been running out from our cherished versions of the family for quite some time.

It doesn’t take great insight to understand that the old “family values” are dead – if, in fact, they ever existed – and it doesn’t take very much foresight to realize that it’s futile to force stray sheep back into a fold that will never contain them again, no matter how vicious the dogs and how strong the fences. Why would kids choose to accept traditional family values in a world where men and women fight each other for power and where parent/ child relationships are increasingly defined by custody agreements and access orders? Why would kids say “no” to drugs in a society where the pharmaceutical quick fix has become the foundation of the health care system? And why would thoughtful young people buy into a way of being that has brought this planet to the brink of ecological chaos?

Young people are not the enemy, not even the “hard-core” ones. We adults have created these conditions, and it remains our responsibility to offer our kids a future that contains some reason for optimism. Personally, I don’t want them to follow in our footsteps and I’m not at all surprised that so many are choosing to reject the world we have created, even to the point of their own self-destruction.
Who has been there to offer any alternative? If there is another way, then let’s get on with the task of defining it, living it, and teaching it, rather than alienating ourselves still further by calling upon the forces of coercion to defend our dying empire.

Much as our hearts might go out to the Baumgart family, there really is no point in blaming one another and demanding accountability from the “authorities.” Nor is there any point in sitting down and blaming ourselves. We are all in this together, and such animosity is just one more reflection of a society that deserves to be rejected. If change is to take place, it won’t be through new laws, upgraded policing, and more effective professionals. It will begin where the problem is most painfully experienced in the direct relationship between each parent and each child.

This isn’t a call for parents to feel guilty about failure or for children to see themselves as victims of abuse, neglect, or deprivation. On the contrary, the challenge is to begin to create relation- ships in which each person grows to assume increasing levels of responsibility not in order to simply accept a pre- designed power structure or some prescribed set of values, but in order to respect and understand each other as unique and related human beings. In other words, we must learn to be with our kids in a different way, supporting them for all they bring into this world, rather than condemning them for not buying into our designs.

This isn’t about permissive parenting. We are still the adults and the teachers, but we must learn to speak honestly and clearly, living according to the values we purport to hold while acknowledging that we are not the guardians of the “truth” or the masters of the "only way." Contrary to popular belief, the role of the parent is not weakened or diminished by such humility, it is strengthened.

And, whether we like it or not, ultimately our kids will make their own choices. All we can ever hope for is that they make those decisions that fit them, in a way that respects the ability of others to also choose for themselves. As parents, it is our responsibility to ensure that choices can be made from a wide range of alternatives; this is the essence of self-responsibility.

In the final analysis, if the values we hold, the culture we create, and the future we envision address the most basic human needs for love, respect, and connection, then most kids will choose lives and relationships in which these needs can be addressed. No victims, no villains, no enemies, no war.

This article, written in response to a lengthy letter published in the Victoria Times Colonist, appeared in that newspaper on May 30, 1996.

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App