CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 298 DECEMBER 2023

Networkers

Doug Magnuson

Recently I chaired an M.S. defense in Physics. The student spent two years building a classification model for thousands of interstellar objects, the conversation was stimulating and the project interesting and useful. Twenty or so fellow students also showed up, interested in the study and interested in supporting their colleague. A paper based on the study has been submitted to a prominent physics journal.

This experience contrasts sharply with the direction of research in the helping professions for youth, particularly social work and child and youth care, where there is less and less interest in either learning from youth or in studying the effects of practice on youth. Increasingly, theses and doctoral defenses have no youth participants or very few. Sometimes students do “auto-ethnography,” studying themselves rather than young people. There are descriptions of fancy theories for interpreting data, but the theories are not used with their data, where they are usually simply reporting back what young people told them. Most theses in the helping professions are confirmations of what the student thinks they already know rather than discoveries.

Something similar is happening to practice. Agencies are given contracts for a service and no money is attached for evaluating that service. Practitioners are often not familiar with the research in their practice area; they did not learn about it in their professional training, nor did they learn that it was important to know about it. What they do receive in their education are numerous opportunities to “self-reflect” and “self-locate,” and they learn the importance of “self-care.” They know the importance of listening to youth, but the person they spend most of their education listening to is themselves.

This “inward” turn in education and practice encourages vulnerability to fads, charismatic sales pitches, and false intuitions. Most worrisome, in my opinion, is the lack of curiosity about the explicit and implicit effects of one’s own practices on youth. Curiosity is often replaced by a fundamentalist certainty about one’s beliefs and practices, despite the absence of evidence. Pretty websites and fanciful anecdotes are strategically provided, but few public or private agencies provide links on their website to any evaluations or research based on their program. They claim “gold-standard” quality but no gold-standard research is found.  

There is a lot of pretending. Mike Baizerman, of the University of Minnesota, asked the question, sometimes rhetorical, “In what situation would we call a youth worker?” How one answers this question communicates volumes, and there is much pretending that because one cares about children that one is important.  Some skepticism might be useful.

Some of these problems are evidence of “presentism,” the assumption that historical figures were misguided or evil and the belief that our own intentions are pure. For example, one assumes that historical figures knew they were doing harm. This is doubtful. A small number did, of course, but most thought they were doing the right thing. Today most of us are certain that historical practices are bad but that current intentions and practices are morally good, but there is not that much evidence for this claim. Bruno Bettelheim was a brilliant analyst of practice and a brilliant wordsmith, e.g., “Love is not enough.” Spectacular language, but it turned out that children were being manipulated and physically abused in his “laboratory school,” because they didn’t always conform to his theories. He was certain, but there was no oversight or evaluation, because his claims, his stories, and his good intentions were thought to be enough evidence.

Good intentions and pretty words are not enough. To claim expertise without basing this expertise in careful study, research, and professional evaluation and, increasingly, without any real experience is arrogant. Too many educators are sending students into the field with little understanding of the settings in which they work, with no idea what effectiveness means in that setting, no idea about the research literature, and armed with a handful of keywords. What they have are endless strings of citations but few to none of those citations have any data.

In education the modern home-schooling movement grew quickly in part because teacher unions claimed that only they knew how to teach. They were wrong, mostly. CYC and Social Work (with youth) educators claim expertise about practices they have never seen, much less studied, and practitioners obtain jobs in fields based on assumptions rather than facts about what they know. It is not a surprise that the turnover rate is high, as practitioners discovered belatedly, they know very little.

The Physics students demonstrate the value of serious efforts to understand the world. Instead of focusing on themselves, Social Work and Child and Youth Care might think about studying the complexities of the lives of children and youth and the relevant practices - if they want to be taken seriously.

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App