Much of my scholarship and teaching over the past two decades or so has been founded in exploring the impacts of what has been called social constructions. Put simply, social constructions are descriptions of the world that are particular to a certain place and time. These descriptions generally arise out a necessity to reinforce power relations in a given society. Often, they have little objective justification and obtain their truth value through associations with common sense. That is, they are true because we believe in them, not because they can be supported with reference to actual material conditions. Such social constructions include race, class, gender, and sexuality, our common sense perception of which are at wild variance from their material actuality. Race, for example, has no actual existence biologically or genetically, but that doesn’t mean it doesn’t have significant social force.
One of my earliest interests in social construction originated in my investigations into adolescents. I was working with young people who had been identified as adolescents and I was deeply influenced by the psychological definitions of who these young people were and how I thought they would or could act. I expected to see rebellion, emotional upheaval, impulsive decision making, and so on. And what I saw seemed to confirm what I had been taught to expect. And then, I stumbled across Philip Aries and the idea that childhood was created as a social category, rather than a biological fact. From there, I found my way to the literature that traced the term adolescence, and my view of those young people I was encountering in my work began to shift.
In my reading, I found that adolescence was introduced as a social category in the first decade of the 20th century. When the psychologist Stanley Hall wrote the initial definitive text defining adolescence in 1904, he shifted the perception of what constituted childhood and what it was to be an adult. Up until then, young people 13-19 were considered adults. This was a time of taking on adult responsibilities, such as developing a trade or starting a family. To be married at 16 or17 and having children was not at all unusual or frowned upon. However, with emergence and expansion of industrial capitalism, this began to change. In the late 1800’s there were changes in labor laws and a push for universal education that began to shift social perceptions of when adulthood began and how long childhood lasted.
The period of time from the late 1880’s into the early 20th century was a time of profound social upheaval. The was a significant financial crisis in the late 1800’s that has been compared to the great depression of the 1930’s. For those who could find work, working conditions in factories and mines were dangerous and poorly paid. There were strikes and political upheaval by workers in the emergent industrial capitalist economies of Europe and the United States. Many were calling for communist and socialist forms of revolution to overthrow the capitalist ruling class. In short, it was a time of social distress and transition.
It is this context that G. Stanley Hall “discovered” adolescence and redefined the ways in which we envision human development to this day. In particular, Hall’s assertion that adolescence was a period of developmental tumult marked by what he termed psychological “storm and stress” has been highly influential in how we see adolescence into the 21st century. Certainly, one way to see this is that Hall used the new science of psychology to uncover what had always been a biological distinction that characterized the body between ages 13-19. Adolescence had always existed but needed the innovative research technologies of science to discover its existence. That is to say, adolescence is hard wired into the body as a developmental stage.
This continues to be the view of many developmentalist who continue the tradition of scientific inquiry into the nature of the adolescent body and brain. Recent work on the frontal lobe development of adolescents and studies of the neurological foundations of risk taking are current examples of this way of understanding adolescent behavior and motivation. The continued importance of the term developmental in the CYC literature and foundational theoretical writings are illustrative of how this way of thinking impacts our field in both theory and practice.
However, there may be another way to see this. The anthropologist Margaret Mead writing some scant 20 years after Hall, argued that adolescence is a cultural phenomenon related to the development of industrial capitalism in the United States. Far from being a universal phenomenon rife with what Hall called “storm and stress,” Mead argued that pre-industrial societies do not have the characteristic period of psychological trauma we associate with adolescence. In her ethnography of young women in Samoa in the 1920’s, she found no sign of generational fractures, sexual or social anxieties, depression, or rebellion. The young women in her study seemed well adjusted and integrated into their social milieu. For Mead, this meant that the storm and stress of adolescence was not biologically driven but was an artifact of life under the emergent social storm and stress of capitalist development. It wasn’t so much that adolescents had the symptoms attributed to them by Hall. Instead, they were manifesting the symptoms of a society that was producing a neurotic subject class that Hall had identified as adolescents.
We might elaborate Mead’s contention by placing adolescence under the Marxist lens of base and superstructure. Of course, a full explication of this complex theoretical framework and its controversies would require several books to unpack. For our purposes here, however, we can gloss it in the following way. Marx asserted that in every historical period there was what he called a mode of production, This is the way we produce our lives as social beings. Put simply, it is what we do to provide for a certain standard and mode of living.
For example, in an agricultural society, the base is farming, in a hunter gatherer society, the base is hunting and gathering, in an industrial society, the base is factory-based production. All of the other activities in that society tend to center around supporting and extending the base. Marx called these related activities the superstructure which could include the government, courts, methods of education, family structures and so on. Marx argued that these social forms take different forms in different societies and historical periods under variations in the mode of production. In other words, society shifts and changes in response to changes in the mode of production.
For our purposes here, this also includes social roles and identities. While it was common under the feudal economic system in Europe in the middle ages to be and be known as a peasant, that social category and identity doesn’t exist in the 21st century in the same way. Very few people have a primary identity as a peasant. This can be said of any number of social roles that are specific to a particular historical period and mode of production. When seen through this lens, Mead’s assertion that adolescence emerges in response to industrial capitalism, is an indication that the role of the child under the agricultural mode of production of the 1800’s in the U.S. was shifting as the mode of production was changing. Adolescence was an indication that a new society was emerging that required a new form of childhood and children.
This sounds kind of reasonable until we recognize that such transitions from one society into the next can be fraught with massive conflicts, both internal and external. In the same period of the late 1800’s into the early 1900’s, we have significant shifts in the role of women, people of color, LGBTQ+ people, workers, families and so on.
For those of us working with young people, what this could mean is that adolescence is not necessarily a hard biological fact, but could be a symptom of a society in flux. That the storm and strife of adolescence is not so much a symptom of the individual young person, but instead a symptom of the cracks and fissures of the society in which they live. They could be seen as what the systemic family therapists call the “identified patient.”
The identified patient in family systems thinking is the person in the family who exhibits the symptoms of a break down or crisis in the family. Generally, such a crisis is unacknowledged or seemingly unresolvable and the identified patient begins to exhibit symptoms as a result. For systemic family therapists, it would be a mistake to treat the symptoms of the identified patient. The symptoms are not about the patient, they are manifestations of a systemic dysfunction in the family system in which they are embedded. I would suggest that we might benefit from beginning to see young people in a similar way. Perhaps their “symptoms” are less about them, and more about the dysfunctional social system in which they are embedded. Very possibly they are the symptom itself.
I was thinking of all of this because of an article I read recently in the New York Times which echoes rather clearly the set of ideas I am proposing here. Jamieson Webster in his article “Teenagers are Telling us Something is Wrong with America” delineates how many of the young people he sees in his practice as a psychologist and psychoanalyst,
immediately want to exit the world stage, as if all options are already on the table, played-out, disenchanted, and the only choice is to disappear, or take medicine, get famous, detach — other versions of disappearing, suicide being the most extreme.
He articulates in some detail the psychic stress the adolescents he sees are experiencing as they attempt to negotiate the emerging world of the 21st century. However, to put that crisis in context, I think we need to remember that our current time is also a moment in which we are shifting the mode of production, from industrial capitalism to cyber capitalism. If we take the thesis I have been proposing thus far seriously, then young people are manifesting the stresses and fractures of that change, much as they did at the turn of the last century. As Webster puts it,
Article after article shows us that America’s teenagers aren’t doing well, without putting their finger on what is wrong beyond issues of individual “mental illness” and the usual bugbears trotted out — social media, video games, the weakening of the family unit. But what are the teenagers telling us is wrong? We seem to have forgotten that adolescents are lightning rods for the zeitgeist. They live at the fault lines of a culture, exposing our weak spots, showing the available array of solutions and insolubilities. They are holding up a mirror for us to see ourselves more clearly.
The question for me at this moment in history, is will we make the same mistake we made when we accepted Hall’s developmental theses, while largely ignoring Mead’s cautionary advice? Will we in CYC continue to see adolescents as individual sites of emotional dysregulation and psychic turmoil that require individual remediation , either relational or medical? Or will we take the opportunity to look into the mirror young people are offering us and work with them to navigate this transition between economies and ways of life? Will we see that their pain and suffering is a reflection of a social dysfunction that can only be remedied by changing those aspects of our emerging world that are so profoundly dysfunctional that they are literally killing us, psychically and physically? CYC is one of the few places where this work is perfectly situated to occur. However, we would have to abandon some of our developmental sacred cows. But the stakes are high enough that I think it might be worth it.